Funeral Reform and the Materiality of Death in the Russian Civil War
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2021.1.571Keywords:
Soviet Russia, Civil War, funeral reform, everyday norms, secularization, death-related practicesAbstract
Based on documents produced by various Soviet institutions in Moscow, Ivanovo-Voznesensk, and Yaroslavl’ in 1917–1922, this paper looks at the transformations of the Soviet funeral industry during the Civil War. After the October Revolution, a series of decrees proclaimed the secularization of funeral practices and attempted to purify them of monetary relations and hierarchy. The funeral ranks, or razryady, were eliminated, and Soviet institutions were obliged to provide equal services for all citizens regardless of their social background. This initiative was part of a larger project of creating a new man with new values by changing everyday practices. Due to administrative difficulties caused by the regime change and wartime challenges, the implementation of the funeral reform was fraught with perturbations at state, local, and family level. In Moscow, these problems led to the fullfledged “funeral crisis” of 1919, when the rise in mortality, serious shortages in supplies, and bureaucratic prevarications resulted in dead bodies being left unburied for prolonged periods of time. In the smaller towns of Ivanovo-Voznesensk and Yaroslavl’, the crisis was less intense, and the funeral industry, while being transformed in accordance with the decrees, could still cope with popular demands. Several factors might explain this difference, including town size and the less rigid attitude of the provincial authorities to the implementation of funeral innovations. The ambitious funeral reform was not entirely successful: this paper argues that the attempts to change this death-related industry did not concern the fundamental norms of dealing with the dead, namely the idea shared by both the Soviet officials and the population that a dead body deserves personal space, privacy, and respect.
References
Bonch-Bruevich, V. (1968). Otdelenie tserkvi ot gosudarstva [Separation of Church and State]. In Deyateli Oktyabrya o religii i tserkvi. Moscow, Mysl’, pp. 12–13.
Bulgakov, S (1913). Nastol’naya kniga dlya svyashchenno-tserkovno-sluzhitelei [A Handbook for Priests]. 3rd Ed., new and update. Kiev, Tipografiya Kievo-Pecherskoi Uspenskoi lavry. 1772 p.
Dekret o kladbishchakh i pokhoronakh ot 7 dekabrya [Decree on Cemeteries and Funerals. December 7]. (1918). In Biblioteka normativno-pravovykh aktov SSSR [website]. URL: http://www.libussr.ru/doc_ussr/ussr_414.htm (accessed: 01.05. 2020).
Erlichman, V. V. (2004). Poteri narodonaseleniya v XX veke. Spravochnik [Population Losses in the 20th Century. A Handbook]. Moscow, Russkaya panorama. 175 p.
GAIO [State Archive of Ivanovo Region]. Stock R31. List 1. Dos. 52, 193; Stock R139. List 1. Dos. 17, 40; Stock R1175. List 1. Dos. 52a.
Galkin, M. (1919). Akty sostoyanii (prodolzhenie). Novoe zakonodatel’stvo i soobshcheniya s mest [Acts of Statuses. (Continuation). New Legislation and Messages from the Field]. In Revolyutsiya i tserkov’. No. 2, pp. 5–9.
GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. Stock R4390. List 12. Dos. 40.
GAYAO [State Archive of Yaroslavl’ Region]. Stock R122. List 1. Dos. 6, 7, 119, 133, 214; Stock R208. List. 1. Dos. 23, 56.
Grazhdanskaya voina i inostrannaya interventsiya v SSSR [Civil War and Foreign Intervention in the USSR]. (1983). Moscow, Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. 704 p.
Grigor’ev, M. A. (2005). Peterburg 1910-kh godov. Progulki v proshloe [Petersburg in the 1910s. Walks into the Past]. St Petersburg, Rossiiskii institut istorii iskusstv. 280 p.
Kodeks zakonov ob aktakh grazhdanskogo sostoyaniya, brachnom, semeinom i opekunskom prave [Code of Regulations Regarding Civil Statuses, Marital Law, Family Law, and Tutelage]. (N. d.). In Istoricheskie materialy [website]. URL: http://istmat.info/node/31624 (accessed: 01.05.2020).
Krasnaya Moskva, 1917–1920 gg. [Red Moscow, 1917–1920]. (1920). Moscow, Gosudarstvennaya obraztsovaya tipografiya (byvshaya tovarishchestva I. D. Sytina). 380 p.
Maksudov, S. (1989). Poteri naseleniya SSSR [Population Losses in the USSR]. Benson, Vermont, Chalidze Publ. 298 p.
Malysheva, S. (2019). “Na miru krasna”. Instrumentalizatsiya smerti v Sovetskoi Rossii [Make Less Trouble. The Instrumentalisation of Death in Soviet Russia]. Moscow, Novyi khronograf. 464 p.
Mironova, E. V. (2018). Arkhangel’skoe kladbishche Kazani: opyt istoricheskogo issledovaniya [The Kazan Arkhangel’skoye Cemetery: An Essay on History]. In Istoricheskaya etnologiya. Vol. 3. No. 1, pp. 137–148. DOI 10.22378/he.2018-3-1.137-148.
Panin, A. (2017). Gorodskaya povsednevnost’ posle 1917 goda po materialam Tul’skogo nekropolya [Post-1917 Everyday Town Life according to Materials from the Tula Town Necropolis]. In Istoriya. Istoriki. Istochniki. No. 2, pp. 48–65.
Safonov, A. (2012). Ukaz 17 aprelya 1905 g. “Ob ukreplenii nachal veroterpimosti” v kontekste formirovaniya instituta svobody sovesti v zakonodatel’stve Rossiiskoi imperii [Edict from 17 April 1905 On Strengthening the Foundations of Religious Tolerance in the Context of Forming the Institution of Freedom of Conscience in the Legislation of the Russian Empire]. In Istoriya i sovremennost’: belorusskaya gosudarstvennost’ v vostochnoevropeiskom tsivilizatsionnom kontekste. Sbornik nauchnykh rabot, posvyashchennykh 90-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya professora I. A. Yukho. Minsk, Biznesofset, pp. 337–344.
Sobranie uzakonenii i rasporyazhenii pravitel’stva za 1917–1918 g. [Code of Regulations of the Government, 1917–1918] (1942). Moscow, Upravlenie delami Sovnarkoma SSSR. 1483 p.
Sokolova, A. (2019). Soviet Funeral Services: From Moral Economy to Social Welfare and Back. In Revolutionary Russia. Vol. 32. No. 2, pp. 251–271. DOI 10.1080/09546545.2019.1687188.
TsGAMO [Central State Archive of the Moscow Region]. Stock 66. List 1. Dos. 306; List 12. Dos. 682.
Urlanis, B. (1968). Dinamika naseleniya SSSR za 50 let [USSR Population Dynamics over 50 years]. In Naselenie i narodnoe blagosostoyanie. Moscow, MESI, pp. 20–43.
Zasosov, D. A, Pyzin, V. I. (2003). Povsednevnaya zhizn’ Peterburga na rubezhe XIX–XX vekov [Everyday Life in Petersburg at the Turn of the 20th Century]. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya. 480 p.
