“Repressions Are Necessary; the Newspaper Hype Is Not”: Explaining Terror in Soviet Terms
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2020.3.492Keywords:
terror; Stalinism; press; propaganda; Communist International; historiographyAbstract
Ever since Robert Conquest’s pioneering study of Joseph Stalin’s Soviet Union first appeared in 1968, the high point of state-sponsored violence in the 1930s has been commonly referred to as the “Great Terror”. The subsequent adoption of the eponymous title by scholars to describe the broader phenomenon of “state terror” in the Stalinist period is similarly now widespread within the field. This terminology is, however, highly problematic. In the language and ideology of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU) terror was consistently portrayed as a threat to, rather than strategy of, the state. It formed part of a tightly controlled terminology of terror, rooted in the Party’s experiences of revolution and civil war, and employed by the regime to marginalize and condemn opponents in official propaganda and private discourse. This study will address this key distinction and illuminate an important element of continuity in the tactics, ideology and self-perception of the CPSU, and its satellite parties within the Communist International, when approaching challenges to their authority (both real and imagined), whether they were of a social, political or even international flavour. Deploying a case study approach, this paper will demonstrate the extent to which “terror” and other related language offered a stable characterisation of the “enemy” throughout the interwar period.
References
Acton, E., Stableford, Т. (2005). The Soviet Union: A Documentary History. 2 Vols. Exeter, Univ. of Exeter Press. Vol. 1. 1917–1940. 448 p.
Brandenberger, D. (2011). Propaganda State in Crisis: Soviet Ideology, Indoctrination, and Terror under Stalin, 1927–1941. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 372 p.
Brandenberger, D., Zelenov, M. V. (2019). Stalin’s Master Narrative: A Critical Edition of the History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks). Short Course. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 768 p.
Brooks, J. (2001). Thank You, Comrade Stalin! : Soviet Public Culture from Revolution to Cold War. Princeton, N. Y., Princeton Univ. Press. 340 p.
Bulgakov, M. (2009). The Heart of a Dog / transl. by M. Glenny. L., Vintage Books. 144 p.
Chase, W. (2005). Stalin as Producer: The Moscow Show Trials and the Construction of Mortal Threats. In Davies, S., Harris, J. (Eds.). Stalin: A New History. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 226–248.
Conquest, R. (1968). The Great Terror: Stalin’s Purge of the Thirties. L., Macmillan. 584 p.
Conquest, R. (2008). The Great Terror: A Reassessment. L., Pimlico. 608 p.
Davies, R. W., Khlevniuk, O. V., Rees, E. A. (2003). The Stalin-Kaganovich Correspondence, 1931–36. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 476 p.
Davies, S., Harris, J. (2014). Stalin’s World: Dictating the Soviet Order. N. Haven, CT, Yale Univ. Press. 360 p.
Degras, J. (2005). The Communist International 1919–1943. Documents. 3 Vols. L., Oxford Univ. Press. Vol. 3. 1929–1943. 494 p.
East View Information Services. Pravda Digital Archive (DA-PRA). (N. d.). In East View on Demand. Internet Archive [official website]. URL: https://dlib.eastview.com/(mode of access: 09.01.2020).
Getty, J. A., Naumov, O. V. (1999). The Road to Terror: Stalin and the Self-Destruction of the Bolsheviks, 1932–1939. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 672 p.
Harris, J. (Ed.). (2013). The Anatomy of Terror: Political Violence Under Stalin. Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press. 344 p.
Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. (N. d.). In Harvard Library [official website]. URL: https://library.harvard.edu/collections/hpsss/index.html (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Kahneman, D. (2012). Thinking, Fast and Slow. L., Penguin. 512 p.
Kang-Bohr, Y. (2005). Appeals and Complaints: Popular Reactions to the Party Purges and the Great Terror in the Voronezh Region, 1935–1939. In Europe-Asia Studies. Vol. 57. No. 1, pp. 135–154. DOI 10.1080/096681305200031417.
Kershaw, I. (2016). To Hell and Back: Europe 1914–1949. L., Penguin Books. 624 p.
Khlevniuk, O. V. (2004). The History of the Gulag: From Collectivization to the Great Terror. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 448 p.
Komsomol’skaya Pravda [Komsomolskaya Pravda]. (1939). 24 November.
Lenoe, M. (2010). The Kirov Murder and Soviet History. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 872 p.
McDermott, K., Stibbe, M. (Eds.). (2010). Stalinist Terror in Eastern Europe: Elite Purges and Mass Repression. Manchester, Manchester Univ. Press. 272 p.
People’s Commissariat of Justice of the USSR. Report of Court Proceedings in the Case of the Anti-Soviet “Bloc of Rights and Trotskyites”. (1938). Moscow, The People’s Commissariat of Justice. 799 p.
Rees, E. A. (2004). Political Thought from Machiavelli to Stalin: Revolutionary Machiavellism. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan. 340 p.
Rees, E. A. (2012). Iron Lazar: A Political Biography of Lazar Kaganovich. L., Anthem. 340 p.
Rentola, K. (1998). The Finnish Communists and the Winter War. In J. of Contemporary History. Vol. 33. No. 4, pp. 591–607.
RGASPI [Russian State Archive of Social and Political History]. Stock 76. List 3. Dos. 294. In Arkhiv Aleksandra N. Yakovleva [website]. URL: https://www.alexanderyakovlev.org/fond/issues-doc/1020036/ (mode of access: 22.01.2020).
Ryan, J. (2012). Lenin’s Terror: The Ideological Origins of Early Soviet State Violence. L., Routledge. 272 p.
Ryan, J. (2015). The Sacralization of Violence: Bolshevik Justifications for Violence and Terror during the Civil War. In Slavic Rev. Vol. 74. No. 4, pp. 808–831. DOI 10.5612/slavicreview.74.4.808.
Service, R. (1995). Lenin: A Political Life. 3 Vols. Basingstoke, Macmillan. Vol. 3. The Iron Ring. 393 p.
Service, R. (2003). A History of Modern Russia: From Nicholas II to Putin. L., Penguin. 708 p.
Service, R. (2004). Stalin: A Biography. L., Macmillan. 736 p.
Shearer, D. (2009). Policing Stalin’s Socialism: Repression and Social Order in the Soviet Union, 1924–1953. N. Haven, CT, L., Yale Univ. Press. 536 p.
Shearer, D. (2018). Stalin at War, 1918–1953, Patterns of Violence and Foreign Threat. In Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas. Vol. 66. No. 2, pp. 188–217. DOI 10.25162/jgo-2018-0008.
Short Course – History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks) Short Course / ed. by A Commission of the Central Committee of the C. P. S. U. (B.). (1939). Moscow, Intern. Publ. Co. In From Marx to Mao [website]. URL: http://www.marx2mao.com/Other/HCPSU39NB.html (mode of access: 09.01.2020).
Solzhenitsyn, A. (1974). The Gulag Archipelago, 1918–1956: An Experiment in Literary Investigation, I–II / transl. by T. Whitney. L., Collins Harvill Press. 660 p.
Spencer, M. L. G. (2018). Stalinism and the Soviet-Finnish War, 1939–40: Crisis Management, Censorship and Control. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan. 244 p.
Spencer, M. L. G. (2020). Exploring the Problem of “Theory-induced Blindness” in History: A Case Study Approach. In York Scholarship of Teaching and Learning J. (In print.)
Thompson, E. M. (1991). Nationalist Propaganda in the Soviet Russian Press, 1939–1941. In Slavic Rev. Vol. 50. No. 2, pp. 385–399.
Waterlow, J. (2018). It’s Only a Joke, Comrade! Humour Trust and Everyday Life Under Stalin. Oxford, CreateSpace Independent Publ. Platform. 308 p.
