The Archetype of the Motherland in Modern Political Discourse (Aleksandr Prokhanov vs Dmitry Bykov)

Authors

  • Yekaterina Postnikova

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2018.4.353

Keywords:

Motherland; political metaphor; mythopoetics; satirical poetry; journalistic writing; political discourse; national mythology

Abstract

This article analyses the transformation of the archetype of the Motherland in opposed mytho-political systems and political discourses of contemporary Russia. It does so with reference to journalistic speeches and articles by Aleksandr Prokhanov and Dmitry Bykov (and satirical poems by the latter). The article demonstrates that the political opponents legitimise/delegitimise and sacralise/desacralise power by choosing a certain aspect of the archetype of the Motherland and reviving the mythology of hierogamy by projecting the archetype of the Father Tsar onto the current political leader. Another effective method of creating the image of Russia and interpreting events is the metaphor of family and gender, which both the writer and the poet use skillfully. The article aims to identify the aspects of the Motherland archetype and to understand the peculiarities characterising the usage of political metaphors for creating the image of the Motherland and their place in the mytho-political systems, relying on methods of mythopoetic and cognitive analysis. The author concludes that in the satirical poems and journalistic speeches of the opposition member Dmitry Bykov, the Motherland is a mother abandoning her children, an alcoholic mother, a mother devouring its children – an Antimother. Of all the gender and family metaphors related to the image of Russia, Bykov chooses antenatal and anticreative metaphors, emphasising, whenever possible, his own masculinity (on the principle of the masculinisation of his own self/his people). However, in the articles and speeches of the conservative Alexander Prokhanov from the early 2000s, the author observes a sacralisation of the Motherland, with the writer emphasising the positive and bright side of the holy image (Holy Russia). However, in his recent journalistic writings, there is a marked preference for the archetype of the Father Tsar, sacralisation of the authorities. and the worship of the state; he uses gender metaphors with a tendency for the masculinisation of one’s own people and the feminisation of others.

Author Biography

Yekaterina Postnikova

Dr. Hab. (Philology), Leading Researcher, Folklife Culture Laboratory of the Research Institute of Historical Anthropology and Philology, Nosov Magnitogorsk State Technical University.

38, Lenin Ave., 455000, Magnitogorsk, Russia.

ekaterinapost@mail.ru

References

Bykov, D. (2004). Sovremennik [A Contemporary]. In Tormoza [website]. URL: http://www.tormoza.org/links/Bykov/nekrasov.html (mode of access: 20.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2011). Za vse, za vse tebya blagodaryu ya [I Thank You for Everything]. In Moskovskii Komsomolets [official website]. 29 Apr. URL: http://www.mk.ru/politics/2011/04/29/585383-vmesto-sebya-Bykovposlal-putinu-edkie-stihi.html (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2012). Odinnadtsataya zapoved’ [The Eleventh Commandment]. In LutKult [website]. 10 February. URL: http://litcult.ru/lyrics.ljubimie-stihi/438 (mode of access: 15.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2014). Grubovatoe [The Blunt]. In Novaya gazeta [official website]. No. 121. 27 October. URL: https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2014/10/25/61697-
grubovatoe (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2015a). “Novaya gazeta” kak “Zavtra” nashego dnya [Novaya Gazeta is the Zavtra of Our Days]. In Bykov, D. Blud truda. Esse. St Petersburg, Limbus Press, Izdatel’stvo K. Tublina, pp. 325–336.

Bykov, D. (2015b). Synovnee [The Filial]. In Novaya gazeta [official website]. No. 53. 25 May. URL: https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2015/05/23/64251-synovnee (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2015d). Rodina protiv Materi [Motherland against Mother]. In Profil’: ezhenedel’nyi zhurnal [official website]. 30 January. URL: http://www.profile.ru/pryamayarech/item/91823-rodina-protiv-materi (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2015g). Chuzhoi epigraf [Borrowed Epigraph]. In Novaya gazeta [official website]. No. 35. 6 Apr. URL: https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2015/04/04/63681-chuzhoy-epigraf (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2015v). Mat’ moya vsya v sazhe [My Mother is All Sooty]. In Profil’ [website]. No. 48. 28 December. URL: http://ru-bykov.livejournal.com/2281251.html (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Bykov, D. (2016a). No obraz Rossii trekhsloinyi… [But Russia’s Image is Three-Layered]. In Bykov, D. Esli net: kniga stikhov. 2015–2016 [If Not: A Book of Poetry. 2015–2016]. St Petersburg, Gelion Plyus. 124 p. URL: http://ru-bykov.livejournal.com/2726879.html (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Krechetnikov, A. (2014). Poet i tsar’: Dmitrii Bykov o Vladimire Putine [The Poet and the Tsar: Dmitriy Bykov on Vladimir Putin]. In BBC: Russkaya sluzhba [official website]. 31 Dec. URL: http://www.bbc.com/russian/russia/2014/12/141231_bykov_interview_putin (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Lotman, Yu. M., Uspensky, B. A. (1977). Rol’ dual’nykh modelei v dinamike russkoi kul’tury (do kontsa XVIII) [The Role of Dual Models in the Dynamics of Russian Culture (until the Late 18th Century)]. In Trudy po russkoi i slavyanskoi filologii. Vol. 28. Tartu, Tartuskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, pp. 3–36.

Novodvorskaya, V. (2008). Ne do ordena. Byla by Rodina [I Do Not Care about the Award. I Wish I Had a Motherland]. In RU.Delfi [official website]. 30 Apr. URL: http://ru.delfi.lt/opinions/comments/vnovodvorskaya-ne-do-ordena-byla-by-rodina.d?id=16787373 (mode of access: 01.05.2015).

Polosin, V. (1999). Mif. Religia. Gosudarstvo. Issledovanie politicheskoi mifologii [Myth. Religion. State. A Study on Political Mythology]. Moscow, Ladomir. 440 p.

Postnikova, E. G. (2014). Tema vlasti v tvorchestve M. E. Saltykova-Shchedrina i F. M. Dostoevskogo (myfopoeticheskii i khudozhestvenno-filosofskii aspekty) [The Theme of Power in the Works of M. E. Saltykov-Shchedrin and F. M. Dostoyevsky (Mythopoetic, Artistic, and Philosophical Aspects)]. Avtoref. dis. … doktora filologicheskikh nauk. Yekaterinburg, S. n. 42 p.

Prokhanov, A. (2013). Chetyre tsveta Putina [The Four Colours of Putin]. Moscow, Algoritm. 256 p.

Prokhanov, A. (2014). Gde ty, svyataya Rus’ [Where Are You, Holy Russia]. In Zavtra [website]. No. 35. 28 August. URL: http://ru-prokhanov.livejournal.com/309399.html (mode of access: 25.08.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2016). Preodolima li eta nenavist’? [Is this Hatred Surmountable?]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [web portal]. 24 November. URL: http://x6z.ru/aleksandrproxanov-preodolima-li-eta-nenavist-24-11-2016/#more-5855 (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2017a). Ezheborets [Hedgehog Fighter]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [web portal]. 25 May. URL: http://x6z.ru/aleksandr-proxanov-ezheborec (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2017b). Russkuyu revolyutsiyu ne zaryt’. Ona vechna [The Russian Revolution Cannot Be Buried. It Is Eternal]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [web portal]. 26 Apr. URL: http://x6z.ru/aleksandr-proxanov-russkuyu-revolyuciyu-ne-zaryt-onavechna-26-04-2017/#more-8841 (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2017d). Sobiranie utrachennoi bylo mechty [Assembling an Almost Lost Dream]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [web-portal]. 10 March. URL: http://x6z.ru/aleksandrproxanov-sobiranie-utrachennoj-bylo-mechty-10-03-2017/ (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2017e). Led i plamen’ [Ice and Flame]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [webportal]. 26 Jan. URL: http://x6z.ru/aleksandr-proxanov-lyod-i-plamen-26-01-2017/ (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2017g). Eto my ugovorili Putina [It Was Us Who Persuaded Putin]. In InoSMI [website]. 27 June. URL: http://inosmi.ru/politic/20170627/239682243.html (mode of access: 27.06.2017).

Prokhanov, A. (2017v). Vse pederasty uekhali v London [All Pederasts Have Left for London]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [web-portal]. 23 April. URL: http://x6z.ru/aleksandrproxanov-vse-pederasty-uexali-v-london-23-04-2017/ (mode of access: 25.07.2017).

Prokhanov, A., Kurginyan, S. (2017). Beseda o Lenine [A Talk about Lenin]. In Informatsionnyi razrez [web-portal]. 28 Apr. [web portal]. URL: http://x6z.ru/sergej-kurginyan-i-aleksandr-proxanov-beseda-o-lenine-21-04-2017/#more-8871 (mode of access: 25.08.2017).

Ryabov, O. V. (2015). “Rodina-mat’” v simvolicheskoi politike perioda “Bolotnoi revolyutsii”: legitimizatsiya i deligitimizatsiya vlasti [The Motherland in Symbolic Politics of the Period of the Swamp Revolution: The Legitimisation and Delegitimisation of Power]. In Labirint. Zhurnal sotsial’no-gumanitarnykh issledovanii. No. 4, pp. 64–81.

Ryabova, T. B., Ryabov, O. V. (2010). Nastoyashchii muzhchina rossiiskoi politiki? (k voprosu o gendernom diskurse kak resurse vlasti) [The Real Man of Russian Politics? (On Gender Discourse as a Resource of Power)]. In Polis. Politicheskie issledovaniya. No. 5, pp. 48–63.

Shchepanskaya, T. B. (2006). Diskursy rossiiskoi vlasti: terminy rodstva [Discourses of Russian Power: Terms of Kinship]. In Bocharov, V. V. (Ed.). Antropologiya vlasti. Khrestomatiya po politicheskoi antropologii v 2 t. St Petersburg, Izdatel‘stvo Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Vol. 1. Vlast‘ v antropologicheskom diskurse, pp. 462–487.

Published

2018-12-25

How to Cite

Postnikova, Y. (2018). The Archetype of the Motherland in Modern Political Discourse (Aleksandr Prokhanov vs Dmitry Bykov). Quaestio Rossica, 6(4), 1174–1187. https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2018.4.353

Issue

Section

Disputatio