Failed Alliance: The Failure of Negotiations on the Soviet-French Military Convention against German Revanchism
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2022.2.699Keywords:
World War II, Red Army, Soviet-French mutual assistance pact of 1935, military conventionAbstract
This article considers the course and results of Soviet-French negotiations on the conclusion of a military convention in 1935–1937. The question of creating a full-fledged military alliance between the two countries arose immediately after they signed a mutual assistance pact in 1935, but initially neither side was fully prepared for this. The impetus for the intensification of negotiations was the events of March 1936 when the Soviet leadership, having failed to normalise its relations with Germany, became convinced of the weakness of the French position against the background of the events of the Rhine crisis. Military and diplomatic contacts began in June 1936 and became especially intense in autumn when L. Blum’s cabinet initiated negotiations between the General Staffs of the two countries. However, at the beginning of 1937, it became clear that for their successful outcome, it was necessary to overcome the resistance of influential military-political circles, which the French government turned out to be incapable of doing. The Soviet side insisted on a transition to direct mutually binding negotiations, but in the summer of 1937, after the resignation of the Blum government, contacts on this issue eroded.
References
Alexander, M. S. (1992). The Republic in Danger: General Maurice Gamelin and the Politics of French Defence, 1933–1940. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 573 p.
AVP RF [Archive of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation]. Stock 05. List 15. File 110. Dos. 94, 95, 97; List 17. File 135. Dos. 109; File 136. Dos. 110.
Belousova, Z. S. (1976). Frantsiya i evropeiskaya bezopasnost’, 1929–1939 [France and European Security]. Moscow, Nauka. 418 p.
Berstein, S. (2006). Léon Blum. Paris, Fayard. 835 p.
Bezymenskii, L. A. (2000). Gitler i Stalin pered skhvatkoi [Hitler and Stalin before the Fight]. Moscow, Veche. 504 p.
Carley, M. J. (2006). A Soviet Eye on France from the rue de Grenelle in Paris, 1924–1940. In Diplomacy & Statecraft. Vol. 17. No. 2, pp. 295–346. DOI 10.1080/09592290600695292.
Carley, M. J. (2021). “Komediya, obernutaya ironiyei vnutri tragedii”: franko-sovetskie popytki konsul’tatsii mezhdu genshtabami (1936–1937) [“A Comedy Wrapped in Irony inside a Tragedy”: Franco-Soviet Attempts at Consultations between General Staffs (1936–1937)]. In Zhurnal rossiiskikh i vostochnoevropeiskikh istoricheskikh issledovanii. No. 1, pp. 45–91.
Crémieux-Brilhac, J.-L. (1990). Les Français de l’an 40. 2 vols. Paris, Gallimard. Vol. 1. La guerre, oui ou non? 647 p.
Dessberg, F. (2009). Le triangle impossible. Les relations franco-soviétiques et le facteur polonais dans les questions de sécurité en Europe (1924–1935). Bruxelles, Peter Lang. 440 p.
Documents diplomatiques français. 2e série 1936–1939. (1966). 19 vols. Paris, Imprimerie nationale. Vol. 3. 844 p.
Dokumenty vneshnei politiki SSSR v 24 t. [Documents of the Foreign Policy of the USSR. 24 Vols.] (1957–2000). Moscow, Politizdat. Vol. 18. 786 p. Vol. 19. 823 p. Vol. 20. 788 p.
Dullin, S. (2009). Stalin i ego diplomaty. Sovetskii Soyuz i Evropa, 1930–1939 gg. [Stalin and His Diplomats: The Soviet Union and Europe, 1930–1939]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 318 p.
Duroselle, J.-B. (1983). La Décadence 1932–1939. Paris, Imprimerie nationale. 568 p.
Fitzpatrick, Sh. (2008). Povsednevnyi stalinizm. Sotsial’naya istoriya Sovetskoi Rossii v 30-e gody: gorod [Everyday Stalinism. Social History of Soviet Russia in the 1930s: City.]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 332 p.
Isserson, G. S. (1988). Sud’ba polkovodtsa [The Fate of a Commander]. In Druzhba narodov. No. 5, pp. 179–192.
Ken, O. N. (2008). Mobilizatsionnoe planirovanie i politicheskie resheniya (konets 1920-kh – seredina 1930-kh gg.) [Mobilisation Planning and Political Decisions (Late 1920s – Mid-1930s)]. Moscow, OGI. 510 p.
Le Temps. (1936). 21 août.
Loizeau, L. (1955). Une mission militaire en URSS. In Rev. des deux mondes. No. 8, pp. 252–276.
Orlov, B. M. (1990). V poiskakh soyuznikov: komandovanie Krasnoi Armii i problemy vneshnei politiki SSSR v 30-kh godakh [In Search of Allies: The Command of the Red Army and the Problems of Foreign Policy of the USSR in the 30s]. In Voprosy istorii. No. 4, pp. 40–53.
Rapport fait au nom de la Commission chargée d’enquêter sur les événements survenus en France de 1933 à 1945. (1951–1952). 11 vols. Paris, Imprimerie de l’Assemblée Nationale. Vol. 1. 286 p.
RGVA [Russian State Military Archive]. Stock 33987. List 3a. Dos. 740, 760, 1027.
Sipols, V. Ya. (1989). Diplomaticheskaya bor’ba nakanune Vtoroi mirovoi voiny [Diplomatic Struggle on the Eve of World War II]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. 360 p.
Soutou, G.-H. (2015). La grande illusion. Quand la France perdait la paix, 1914–1920. Paris, Tallandier. 379 p.
Vaïsse, M. (1981). Les militaires français et l’alliance franco-soviétique au cours des années 1930. In Forces armées et systèmes d’alliance. Colloque international d’histoire militaire et d’études de défense nationale, Montpellier, 2–6 septembre 1981. Paris, Fondation pour les études de Défense nationale, pp. 688–703.
