Party Political Course and Ukrainian History in the USSR
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2020.5.557Keywords:
history of Ukraine, Academy of Sciences, N. L. Rubinstein, A. M. Pankratova, Voprosy IstoriiAbstract
This article offers contextual analysis of unpublished editorials from one of the issues of Voprosy Istorii academic journal, published in 1955. The issue focuses on the problems of studying the history of Ukraine and was written by N. L. Rubinstein, an outstanding Soviet historian and historiographer. The historian discusses the problems related to the history of Ukraine between the fifteenth and nineteenth centuries, as well as the formulation of the academic heritage of pre-revolutionary historians and the “school” of M. S. Grushevsky. The need to overcome a dependence on the conceptual heritage of “Ukrainian bourgeois-nationalist historiography”, which, according to the historian, practically leveled the achievements of Ukrainian scholars, is a red thread through the article. A kind of “familiar track effect” caused significant gaps in the study of Ukrainian 17th- and 18th-century history, as well as the dominance of negative assessments in understanding the process of integration of Ukraine into the Russian state. For the first time in Soviet historical science, the unpublished editorial voiced the need to overcome the monopoly on the study of Ukrainian history held exclusively by institutions of the Ukrainian SSR. In this regard, Rubinstein paid special attention to the Institute of History of the USSR Academy of Sciences, which, in his view, had to be transformed into a key organisational centre for future research. All this suggests a potential divide in the academic study of Ukrainian history in the USSR and its conceptual rethinking, since Rubinstein was highlighting existing research issues. Via the case study of the unpublished Rubinstein editorial, the author demonstrates how the production of academic texts and regulation of research in the USSR were closely intertwined with administrative academic positions and personal connections of Moscow academics and Ukrainian historians (sometimes informally). Under these conditions, the directives of the party leadership at the centre and in the provinces fell into a certain dependence on the internal organsation of the academic community. Existing personal connections opened the way for a kind of academic lobbyism. This kind of lobbying paved the way for the entry of controversial ideas, interpretations, and conceptions that did not fit into the existing ideological framework in the difficult political conditions of the day.
References
Afiani, V. Yu, Esakov, V. D. (Eds.) (2010). Akademiya nauk v resheniyakh Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) – VKP(b) – KPSS. 1922–1991 [Academy of Sciences in the Decisions of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) – VCP(b) – CPSU]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. Vol. 2. 1952–1958. 1279 p.
ARAN [Archive of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow]. Stock 697. List 2. Dos. 48; List 3. Dos. 323, 337, 465; Stock 1714. List 1. Dos. 83.
Dmitriev, S. S. (1964). K istorii sovetskoi istoricheskoi nauki. Istorik N. L. Rubinshtein (1897–1963) [On the History of Soviet Historical Science. Historian N. L. Rubinstein (1897–1963)]. In Uchenye zapiski Gor’kovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriko-filologicheskaya. Iss. 72, pp. 415–478.
Єkel’chik, S. (2008). Іmperіya pam’yatі. Rosіis’ko-ukraїns’kі stosunki v radyans’kіi іstorichnіi uyavі [The Empire of Memory. Russian-Ukrainian Relations in the Soviet Historical Imagination]. Kiїv, Kritika. 303 p.
Іnstitut іstorії Ukraїni NAN Ukraїni. Dokumenti і materіali. 1936–1991 u 2 kn. [Institute of History of Ukraine, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. Documents and Materials. 1936–1991. 2 Books]. (2011). Kiїv, Іnstitut іstorії Ukraїni NAN Ukraїni. Book 1. 1936–1947. 630 p.
NIOR RGB [Research Department of Manuscripts of the Russian State Library]. Stock 521. List 1. Carton 1. Dos. 1; Carton 12. Dos. 12; Carton 23. Dos. 6, 13, 14; Carton 24. Dos. 7, 20; Carton 28. Dos. 18.
Pis’ma Anny Mikhailovny Pankratovoi [Letters from Anna Mikhailovna Pankratova]. (1988). In Voprosy istorii. No. 11, pp. 54–79.
Pokonchit’ s proyavleniyami marrizma v arkheologii [To End the Marrism in Archaeology] (1952). In Voprosy istorii. No. 12, pp. 11–17.
Protiv sub”ektivistskikh oshibok v izuchenii istorii sovetskogo obshchestva [Against Subjectivist Errors in the Study of the History of Soviet Society] (1952). In Voprosy istorii. No. 12, pp. 3–10.
Rubinshtein, N. L. (1954). Dve nauchnye raboty po istorii Osvoboditel’noi voiny ukrainskogo naroda 1648–1654 godov [Two Scholarly Works on the History of the War of Independence of the Ukrainian People in 1648–1654.]. In Voprosy istorii. No. 11, pp. 133–139.
Rubinshtein, N. L. (1962). O putyakh istoricheskogo issledovaniya [On Ways of Historical Research]. In Istoriya SSSR. No. 6, pp. 8–114.
Sidorova, L. A. (2000). “Voprosy istorii” akademika A. M. Pankratovoi [“Voprosy istorii” by Academician A. M. Pankratova]. In Istorik i vremya. 20–50-e gody XX veka. A. M. Pankratova. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Rossiiskogo universiteta druzhby narodov, Mosgorarkhiv, pp. 76–84.
Sidorova, L. A. (2012). “Kratkii kurs istorii Ukrainy” v kontekste sovetskoi istoricheskoi nauki kontsa 1940-kh gg. [“A Short Course in the History of Ukraine” in the Context of Soviet Historical Science of the Late 1940s.]. In Bylye gody. No. 2 (24), pp. 48–53.
Stepanov, B. E. (2017). Sovetskaya istoricheskaya periodika v 1950–1960-e gody: ramki i predely modernizatsii [Soviet Historical Periodicals in the 1950s and 1960s: Scope and Limits of Modernisation]. In Vishlenkova, E. A., Dmitrieva, A. N., Samutina, N. V. (Eds.). Sad uchenykh naslazhdenii. Sbornik trudov Instituta gumanitarnykh istorikoteoreticheskikh issledovanii k yubileyu professora I. M. Savel’evoi. Moscow, Izdatel’skii dom Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki, pp. 227–250.
Tikhomirov, M., Yatsunskii, V., Chermenskii, E., Dmitriev, S. (1954). Nauchnyi trud po istorii Ukrainy [Scholarly Work on the History of Ukraine]. In Pravda. No. 108 (13 041), pp. 2–3.
Tikhonov, V. V. (2016). Ideologicheskie kampanii “pozdnego stalinizma” i sovetskaya istoricheskaya nauka (seredina 1940-kh – 1953 g.) [The Ideological Campaigns of “Late Stalinism” and Soviet Historical Science]. Moscow, St Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriya. 424 p.
Tikhonov, V. V. (2017). Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv noveishei istorii: dokumenty Otdela nauki i kul’tury TsK KPSS (mart 1953 g. – sentyabr’ 1955 g.) o kontrole nad “natsional’nymi istoriyami” narodov SSSR [Russian State Archive of Contemporary History: Documents of the Department of Science and Culture of the CPSU Central Committee on Control over “National Histories” of the Peoples of the USSR]. In Vestnik arkhivista. No. 4, pp. 135–146. DOI 10.28995/2073-0101-2017-4-135-146.
U leshchatakh totalіtarizmu: Pershe dvadtsyatirіchchya Іnstitutu іstorії Ukraїni NAN Ukraїni (1936–1956 pp.). Zbіrnik dokumentіv і materіalіv u 2 ch. [In the Grip of Totalitarianism: The First 20th Anniversary of the Institute of History of Ukraine of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine (1936–1956). Collection of Documents and Materials. 2 Parts]. (1996). Kiїv, Іnstitut іstorії Ukraїni NAN Ukraїni. Part 1. 146 p. Part 2. 247 p.
Yas’, O. (2016). “Na cholі respublіkans’koї nauki…”. Іnstitut іstorії Ukraїni (1936–1986). Narisi z іnstitutsіonal’noї ta іntelektual’noї іstorії (do 80-rіchchya ustanovi) [“At the Head of the Republican Science”. Institute of History of Ukraine (1936–1986). Essays on Institutional and Intellectual History (To the 80th Anniversary of the Institution)]. Kiїv, NAN Ukraїni, Іn-t іstorії Ukraїni. 542 p.
Za dal’neishii pod”em istoricheskoi nauki v SSSR [For the Further Rise of Historical Science in the USSR]. (1952). In Voprosy istorii. No. 9, pp. 3–16.
Za glubokoe izuchenie istorii ukrainskogo naroda [For Deep Study of the History of the Ukrainian People]. (1955). In Voprosy istorii. No. 7, pp. 3–10.
Zaruba, V. M. (2004). Mikhailo Slabchenko v epіstolyarnіi ta memuarnіi spadshchinі (1882–1952) [Mykhailo Slabchenko in the Epistolary and Memoir Heritage (1882–1952)]. Dnіpropetrovs’k, Yuridichna akademiya Ministerstva vnutrishnikh sprav, Lіra LTD. 352 p.
Zimin, A. A., Mochalov, V. D., Novosel’skii, A. A. (1954). Tsennyi trud po istorii Ukrainskoi SSR [Valuable Work on the History of the Ukrainian SSR]. In Voprosy istorii. No. 6, pp. 128–132.
