The Cornerstone of the Tax System: The Introduction of an Income Tax in the Russian Empire

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2019.4.435

Keywords:

Russian Empire; income tax; taxation; financial reforms

Abstract

In the early twentieth century, the Russian Empire was one of the few European countries where there was no income tax; at the same time, during periods of acute deficit, the government considered the possibility of transition to income taxation and even developed various bills. However, as they were reluctant to deprive the nobility of their privileges and thus strengthen the position of the commercial and industrial strata of society, the idea remained unfulfilled. The article focuses on the main projects for the imposition of an income tax in Russia from 1892 (the most well-developed project in the nineteenth century) to 1916 (the one adopted for implementation). The article analyses the historical conditions behind the drafting of the bills, viewpoints on the innovations expressed in the government, the economic efficiency of the innovations, and the results of the discussions. Of special interest are the discussions which took place in the State Council at special meetings devoted to the implementation of the tax, because it transpires that the Ministry of Finance was one of the few liberal agencies consistently advocating for the transition to progressive income taxation. The same views were held by the legal departments of the Ministry of Finance, i. e. the treasury chamber and tax inspectorates. Other agencies emphasised the irrelevance, complexity, and deficiency of income tax. An income tax was introduced not as the main tax in the fiscal system but as an additional one to existing direct and indirect taxes, which caused various controversies. From the point of view of economic efficiency, the expected income from the introduction of the tax was so insignificant that it devalued the idea of its implementation. ‘The law on the introduction of an income tax’ adopted in 1916 was perceived by society as a great achievement, but it is scarcely possible to talk about its impact on the state budget because of the events of 1917.

Author Biography

Elena Kravtsova

Dr. Hab. (History), Professor, Kursk State Medical University.

3, K. Marx Str., 305041, Kursk, Russia.

ORCID 0000-0003-1363-2165

ek7500@mail.ru

References

Anan’ich, N. I. (1979). K istorii podatnykh reform 1880-kh godov. Vvedenie dopolnitel’nykh sborov k promyslovomu nalogu: 3-protsentnogo i raskladochnogo [On the History of Tax Reforms of the 1880s. Introduction of Additional Fees to the Tax on Trade: 3 Percent Tax and Split Direct Tax]. In Istoriya SSSR. No. 1, pp. 159–173.

Bakunin, N. M. (1915). Doklad [Report]. In Izvestiya obshchestva finansovykh reform. No. 10, pp. 24–27.

Belyaev, S. G. (2002). P. L. Bark i finansovaya politika Rossii 1914–1917 gg. [P. L. Bark and the Financial Policy of Russia, 1914–1917]. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. 620 p.

Bogolepov, M. I. (1907). Finansy, pravitel’stvo i obshchestvennye interesy [Finance, Government, and Public Interest]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya O. N. Popova. 334 p.

Bokhanov, A. N. (1986). Vopros o podokhodnom naloge v Rossii i krupnaya burzhuaziya (konets XIX – nachalo XX v.) [The Question of Income Tax in Russia and the Upper Middle Class (Late 19th ‒ Early 20th Centuries)]. In Istoricheskie zapiski. Vol. 114, pp. 276–302.

Bulanzhe, M. (1998). Iz istorii podokhodnogo naloga i naloga na pribyl’ [From the History of Income Tax and Profit Tax]. In Nalogovyi vestnik. No. 6, pp. 147–149.

GAKO [State Archives of Kursk Region]. Stock 144. List 1. Dos. 118.

Gavrikov, P. G. (Ed.). (1912). Osnovnye zadachi podatnogo i otsenochnogo dela (rukovodstvo dlya podatnykh inspektorov, zemskikh i gorodskikh uprav po raznym voprosam podatnogo i otsenochnogo dela) [The Main Tasks of the Tax and Valuation Case (a Guide for Tax Inspectors, Zemsky and City Administrations on Various Issues of Tax and Valuation)]. Kiev, Izdatel’stvo knizhnogo magazina N. Ya. Oglobina. 180 p.

Genzel’, P., Sokolov, A. (1916). Finansovaya reforma v Rossii [The Financial Reform in Russia]. Moscow, Tipografiya G. Lissnera i D. Sobko. 49 p.

Imshenitskii, B. (1917). Nesostoyatel’nost’ dorevolyutsionnoi nalogovoi sistemy. Odna iz prichin ugnetennogo sostoyaniya trudyashchikhsya klassov [The Failure of the Pre-Revolutionary Tax System. One of the Reasons for the Depressed State of the Working Classes]. Kiev, Tipografiya P. I. Bonadurer. 32 p.

Istoricheskaya spravka po voprosu o vvedenii podokhodnogo naloga v Rossii (materialy k proektu Polozheniya o gosudarstvennom podokhodnom naloge) [The Historical Background on the Introduction of Income Tax in Russia (Materials for the Draft Regulation on the State Income Tax)]. (N. d.). St Petersburg, S. n. 57 p.

K voprosu o preobrazovanii deistvuyushchei nalogovoi sistemy [On the Transformation of the Existing Tax System]. (1915). Petrograd, Tipografiya Ministerstva finansov. 28 p.

Kirillov, A. K. (2017). Ot podushnoi podati k podokhodnomu nalogu: podatnye reform kapitalisticheskoi Rossii i ikh voploshchenie v Zapadnoi Sibiri vtoroi poloviny XIX – nachala XX veka [From Per Capita Tax to Income Tax: Tax Reforms of Capitalist Russia and Their Implementation in Western Siberia in the Second Half of the 19th and Early 20th Centuries]. Novosibirsk, Parallel’. 178 p.

Knyazev, V. G. (1999). S. Yu. Vitte i nalogovaya politika Rossii [S. Yu. Witte and the Tax Policy of Russia]. In Finansy. No. 10, pp. 30–33.

Kravtsova, E. S. (2007). Istoriya sbora nalogov v rossiiskoi provintsii na rubezhe XIX–XX stoletii [The History of Tax Collection in the Russian Province at the Turn of the 20th Century]. Kursk, Izdatel’stvo Kurskogo gosudarstvennogo meditsinskogo universiteta. 164 p.

Kravtsova, E. S. (2008a). Podokhodnyi nalog v Rossiiskoi imperii na rubezhe XIX–XX stoletii: ot idei do voploshcheniya v zhizn’ [Income Tax in the Russian Empire at the Turn of the 20th Century: From Idea to Implementation]. In Vestnik Rossiiskogo universiteta druzhby narodov. No. 5, pp. 89–93.

Kravtsova, E. S. (2008b). Osvobozhdennye ot prizyva oblagalis’ pryamym nalogom [The Ones Exempted from Conscription Taxed Directly]. In Voenno-istoricheskii zhurnal. No. 2, pp. 64–66.

Kravtsova, E. S. (2010). Opyt organizatsii nalogovogo dela v Rossii v kontse XIX – nachale XX stoletiya [The Experience of Organising Tax Affairs in Russia in the Late 19th ‒ Early 20th Centuries]. Kursk, Izdatel’stvo Kurskogo gosudarstvennogo meditsinskogo universiteta. 303 p.

Kravtsova, E. S. (2012). Diskussiya o prinyatii kvartirnogo naloga v Rossii v kontse XIX veka [Discussion on the Adoption of a Residential Tax in Russia in the Late 19th Century]. In Izvestiya Yugo-Zapadnogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. No. 4, pp. 139–141.

Kravtsova, E. S. (2017). Problemy reformirovaniya nalogovoi sistemy Rossiiskoi imperii v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny (po vospominaniyam P. L. Barka) [Problems of Reforming the Tax System of the Russian Empire during the First World War (according to the Memoirs of P. L. Bark)]. In Ekonomicheskaya istoriya. Vol. 13. No. 4, pp. 38–47. DOI 10.15507/2409–630Х.039.013.201704.038–047.

Kutler, N. N. (1911). K voprosu o vvedenii v Rossii podokhodnogo naloga [On the Introduction of an Income Tax in Russia]. In Izvestiya obshchestva finansovykh reform. No. 2, pp. 3–14.

Mariskin, O. I. (2004). Gosudarevo tyaglo. Nalogooblozhenie krest’yanstva Rossii vo vtoroi polovine XIX – pervoi treti XX veka (po materialam Srednego Povolzh’ya) [The Sovereign Tax. Taxation of the Peasantry of Russia in the Second Half of the 19th ‒ First Third of the 20th Centuries (Based on the Materials of the Middle Volga)]. Saransk, Izdatel’stvo Mordovskogo universiteta. 240 p.

Novoe vremya [Novoe vremya]. (1907). 23 March.

Obshchaya gosudarstvennaya rospis’ dokhodov i raskhodov na 1906 god [General State Inventory of Income and Expenses for 1906]. (1906). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Ministerstva finansov. 180 p.

Podokhodnyi nalog. Ozhidaemoe chislo platel’shchikov, ikh dokhod i summa naloga po issledovaniyam, provedennym podatnymi inspektorami i Kazennymi palatami v 1909–1910 gg. [Income Tax. The Expected Number of Payers, Their Income and the Amount of Tax on Research Conducted by the Tax Inspectors and the Treasury in 1909‒1910]. (1910). St Petersburg, Tipografiya N. Ya. Stoikovoi. 84 p.

Pogrebinskii, A. P. (1968). Gosudarstvennye finansy tsarskoi Rossii v epokhu imperializma [State Finances of Tsarist Russia in the Era of Imperialism]. Moscow, Finansy. 275 p.

Proekt gosudarstvennoi rospisi dokhodov i raskhodov na 1915 g. s ob”yasneniem ministra finansov [The Draft State Inventory of Income and Expenses for 1915 with the Explanation of the Minister of Finance]. (1914). Petrograd, Tipografiya V. Kirshbauma. 770 p.

Proekt gosudarstvennoi rospisi dokhodov i raskhodov na 1917 g. s ob”yasneniem ministra finansov [The Draft State Inventory of Income and Expenses for 1917 with the Explanation of the Minister of Finance]. (1916). Petrograd, Tipografiya V. Kirshbauma. 298 p.

RGIA [Russian State Historical Archive]. Stock 23. List 1. Dos. 273; Stock 560. List 38. Dos. 193; Stock 573. List 34. Dos. 300.

Shepelev, L. E. (1981). Tsarizm i burzhuaziya vo vtoroi polovine XIX veka. Problemy torgovo-promyshlennoi politiki [Tsarism and the Upper Middle Class in the Second Half of the 19th Century. Problems of Trade and Industrial Policy]. Leningrad, Nauka. 275 p.

Sobolev, M. (1915). Perestroika finansovoi sistemy Rossii v svyazi s vvedeniem podokhodnogo naloga i poimushchestvennykh nalogov [The Restructuring of the Russian Financial System in Connection with the Introduction of an Income Tax and Property Taxes]. In Zheleznov, V. Ya. (Ed.). Voprosy finansovoi reformy v Rossii v 3 t. Moscow, Tovarishchestvo “Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva”. Vol. 1. Iss. 1, pp. 1‒12.

Sovet Ministrov Rossiiskoi imperii v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Bumagi A. N. Yakhontova (zapiski zasedanii i perepiska) [The Council of Ministers of the Russian Empire during the First World War. Papers by A. N. Yakhontov (Notes of Meetings and Correspondence)]. (1999). St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin. 560 p.

Stepanov, V. L. (1998). N. Kh. Bunge. Sud‘ba reformatora [N. Ch. Bunge. The Fate of the Reformer]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 398 p.

Torgovo-promyshlennaya gazeta [Torgovo-promyshlennaya gazeta]. (1907). 22 March.

Tverdokhlebov, V. (1916). O reforme pryamykh nalogov v Rossii [On Direct Tax Reform in Russia]. In Zheleznov, V. Ya. (Ed.). Voprosy finansovoi reformy v Rossii v 3 t. Moscow, Tipografiya G. Lissnera i D. Sobko. Vol. 1. Iss. 2, pp. 50–75.

Zakharov, V. N., Petrov, Yu. A., Shatsillo, M. K. (2006). Istoriya nalogov v Rossii. IX – nachalo XX [The History of Taxes in Russia between the 9th and Early 20th Centuries]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 296 p.

Zhurnal komissii po voprosu vvedeniya podokhodnogo oblozheniya [Journal of the Commission on the Issue of Income Tax Introduction]. (1905). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Ministerstva finansov. 49 p.

Zhurnal s”ezda podatnykh inspektorov Kurskoi gubernii: 25–27 sentyabrya 1909 [Journal of the Congress of Tax Inspectors of Kursk Province: September 25–27, 1909]. (1910). Kursk, Tipografiya P. Z. Libermana. 155 p.

Published

2019-12-21

How to Cite

Kravtsova, E. (2019). The Cornerstone of the Tax System: The Introduction of an Income Tax in the Russian Empire. Quaestio Rossica, 7(4), 1229–1242. https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2019.4.435

Issue

Section

Problema voluminis