Judicial Investigators of Siberia: “Transitional” Justice of the Late 19th Century
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2023.3.832Keywords:
Russian Empire in the late 19th century, justice reform, judicial investigators, police, crime, SiberiaAbstract
One of the means of improving Russian justice in the era of Alexander II was the introduction of judicial investigators. Belatedly, in 1885, they were introduced into the pre-reform Siberian justice system and until 1897, were intended to investigate crimes together with police officials, which was a kind of transitional step towards the subsequent improvement of the court. The use of micro-historic detailing, as well as legislative acts, reports, materials of personal origin, statistics, periodicals, and archival documentation make it possible to comprehensively examine the activities of specialist investigators in Siberia on the eve of the Judicial Statutes of 1864 applied to the region, thereby significantly supplementing the ideas about the patterns of transformations of justice in the late Russian Empire, conditions of functioning of state bodies on the Siberian outskirts and their critical condition. The reform of 1885 was inconsistent, and as a result, the investigative part did not have sufficient resources or the ability to fight crime effectively. The content and staff of judicial investigators turned out to be insignificant; many were young and had no professional experience. Also, they fell into a hostile bureaucratic environment, managed extensive areas and were guided by outdated rules of procedure, but at the same time, they demonstrated official superiority in investigations over different ranks of the police. The latter ones were quite often ignorant and did not try to perform their secondary investigative duties. The activities of police officials were characterised by slowness and lack of professionalism, which worsened the performance of the entire Siberian investigative apparatus. Audits revealed systemic disorders and caused its arsenal to be regarded as unsuitable for defeating crime, and in government circles, the idea of the need for a new judicial transformation in Siberia prevailed. Having become a part of archaic justice in 1885–1897, the institution of judicial investigators confirmed the impossibility of the continued existence of “transitional” justice and called for the need to apply Judicial Statutes in full.
References
Adon’eva, I. G. (2010). “Velikaya polureforma”: preobrazovaniya sudebnoi vlasti Zapadnoi Sibiri v otsenkakh mestnoi yuridicheskoi intelligentsii (konets XIX – nachalo XX v.) [“The Great Semi-Reform”: Transformation of the Judicial Power of Western Siberia According to the Assessments of the Local Legal Intelligentsia (Late 19th – Early 20th Centuries)]. Novosibirsk, Izdatel’stvo Novosibirskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 224 p.
Badikov, P. (1890). Otpravlenie pravosudiya v Zabaikal’skoi oblasti [Administration of Justice in Trans-Baikal Region]. In Zhurnal grazhdanskogo i ugolovnogo prava. No. 10, pp. 1–27.
Baralevskii, V. (1895). Ustroistvo sudebnoi chasti na ostrove Sakhalin [Arrangement of the Judicial Unit on Sakhalin Island]. In Zhurnal Yuridicheskogo obshchestva pri Imperatorskom Sankt-Peterburgskom universitete. No. 9, pp. 68–74.
Borisovskii, N. F. (1899). V doreformennoi Sibiri. (Iz dnevnika mestnogo starozhila) [In Pre-Reform Siberia. (From the Diary of a Local Old-Timer)]. In Istoricheskii vestnik. No. 2, pp. 538–563.
Brazol, B. L. (1914). Sledstvennaya chast’ [Investigative Part]. In Sudebnye ustavy 20 noyabrya 1864 g. za pyat’desyat let v 2 t. Petrograd, Senatskaya tipografiya. Vol. 2, pp. 65–114.
Domershchikov, M. P. (Ed.). (1897). Vremennye pravila o primenenii Sudebnykh ustavov v guberniyakh i oblastyakh Sibiri, s zakonodatel’nymi motivami i raz’’yasneniyami [Temporary Rules on the Application of the Judicial Charters in the Provinces and Regions of Siberia, with Legislative Motives and Clarifications]. St Petersburg, Izdanie Yuridicheskogo knizhnogo magazina N. K. Martynova. II, IV 82 p.
GA v Tobol’ske [State Archive of Tobolsk]. Stock 152. List 37. Dos. 875; Stock 158. List 2. Dos. 16, 31; Stock 377. List 1. Dos. 21, 52; Stock 479. List 5. Dos. 1.
GAIO [State Archive of Irkutsk Region]. Stock 239. List 1. Dos. 20; Stock 245. List 5. Dos. 127, 180.
GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. Stock R-5881. List 2. Dos. 299.
GATO [State Archive of Tyumen Region]. Stock 40. List 2. Dos. 392.
Gazenvinkel’, K. B. (1889). Ob usloviyakh proizvodstva formal’nykh sledstvii po zakonu 25 fevralya 1885 g. [On the Conditions for the Production of Formal Investigations under the Law as of February 25, 1885]. Tobolsk, Tobol’skaya gubernskaya tipografiya. 45 p.
Gellertov, N. P. (1893). Usilenie sledstvennoi chasti v Tobol’skoi gubernii [Strengthening the Investigative Unit in Tobolsk Province]. In Zhurnal grazhdanskogo i ugolovnogo prava. No. 7, pp. 25–34.
Krestyannikov, E. A. (2013). Politsiya i politseiskoe sledstvie v Zapadnoi Sibiri (1822–1897 gg.) [Police Investigation in Western Siberia, 1822–1897]. In Rossiiskaya istoriya. No. 3, pp. 84–99.
Krestyannikov, E. A. (2017). P. V. Vologodskii na puti k advokature: okruzhenie, interesy i deyatel’nost’ yurista na nachal’nom etape professional’noi kar’ery [P. V. Vologodsky on the Way to Attorneyship: The Environment, Interests, and Activities of the Lawyer at the Initial Stage of His Professional Career]. In Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. No. 416, pp. 113–118. DOI 10.17223/15617793/416/17.
Krestyannikov, E. A. (2018). Finansovye aspekty sudebnoi reformy v Sibiri (konets XIX – nachalo XX v.) [Judicial Reform in Siberia: Financial Aspects (Late 19th – Early 20th Centuries)]. In Rossiiskaya istoriya. No. 2, pp. 22–34.
La-n, M. A. (1902). Kur’ezy sibirskoi stariny. (Iz arkhivnykh del i rasskazov starozhilov) [Curiosities of Siberian Antiquity. (From Archival Files and Stories of Old-Timers)]. In Sibirskii nablyudatel’. No. 12, pp. 98–111.
Ledonne, J. P. (1974). Criminal Investigations before the Great Reforms. In Russian History. Vol. 1. No. 2, pp. 101–118.
Otchet po deloproizvodstvu Gosudarstvennogo soveta za sessiyu 1893–1894 gg. v 2 t. [Report on the Office of State Council for the Session of 1893–1894]. (1894). St Petersburg, Gosudarstvennaya tipografiya. Vol. 2. 905 p.
PSZ [Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire]. Collection 2. Vol. 35, 39. Collection 3. Vol. 5, 8, 13, 16.
RGIA [Russian State Historical Archive]. Stock 1405. List 69. Dos. 7107d; List 87. Dos. 9921е, 10393.
Sbornik statisticheskikh svedenii Ministerstva yustitsii [Collection of Statistical Information of the Ministry of Justice]. (1893). Iss. 7. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Pravitel’stvuyushchego senata. 147 p.
Serov, D. O., Fedorov, A. V. (Eds.). (2017). Istoriya sledstviya v Rossii [History of Investigation in Russia]. Moscow, Yurlitinform. 280 p.
Sibirskaya gazeta [Sibirskaya Gazeta]. (1883). October 30.
Sibirskii vestnik [Sibirskii Vestnik]. (1885). May 16. (1892). November 13.
Spisok chinam vedomstva Ministerstva yustitsii v 4 ch. [List of Ranks of Departments of the Ministry of Justice. 4 Parts]. (1888). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Pravitel’stvuyushchego senata. Part 4. 72 p.
Tarnovskii, E. N. (1899). Itogi russkoi ugolovnoi statistiki za 20 let (1874–1894 gg.) [Results of Russian Criminal Statistics over 20 Years (1874–1894)]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Pravitel’stvuyushchego senata. 408 p.
Tri poslednikh samoderzhtsa. Dnevnik A. V. Bogdanovich [The Last Three Autocrats. A. V. Bogdanovich’s Diary]. (1924). Moscow, Leningrad, Izdatel’stvo L. D. Frenkel’. 504 p.
Vologodskii, P. V. (1892). Iz istorii voprosa o sudebnoi reforme v Sibiri [From the History of Judicial Reform in Siberia]. In Russkoe bogatstvo. No. 12, pp. 1–13.
Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Podgotovitel’nye materialy v 12 t. [Highly Established Commission for the Revision of Legal Provisions on the Judicial Side. Preparatory Materials. 12 Vols.]. (1895). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Pravitel’stvuyushchego senata. Vol. 10. 122 p.
