Maksim Grek’s Writings against the Jews in His Codices
Keywords:Maksim Grek, Samuel of Morocco, Isak Sobaka, 16th-century journalism, Jewish teaching, author’s codices, heretics, preaching of Orthodoxy
The handwritten heritage of Maksim Grek contains three epistles contending the Jewish teaching. They do not constitute a series and occupy different positions in the codices of the author’s intra vitam writings. Based on them, Russian scholars have long developed a concept of the active participation of Maksim Grek in fighting the heresy of the Judaizers, which is disproved by the modern studies of the publicist’s works. The study aims to determine the role of the anti-Jewish writings of the Wise Man from the Mount of Athos in forming the author’s codices. Two works occupy the position of concluding chapters of the codices. The polemic Writings Contending Samuel the Jew have signs of a text closely related to another one. There is neither an introduction nor a conclusion, the statements are brief, and the system of an internal organisation into rubrics is unclear. The text is to be perceived in the context of the source, i. e. The Epistle of Rabbi Samuel of Morocco. A similar text architectonics is observed in the Epistle to a Certain Man who became interested in Lucidarius. Words against Samuel Israeli was written in the late 1540s in Tver Otroch Monastery as a reaction to the request of a certain Georgy to comment on The Epistle of Rabbi Samuel of Morocco. The essay was attached, maybe by one of the scholars, as chapter 73 to the Khludov Сollection, written in the early 1550s in St Trinity Monastery. The Advice to the Orthodox Congress on Isak the Jew, a Magician, Sorcerer, and Cheat proved intriguing. Its title does not match the content, nor is it possible to determine which congress is meant and who Isak the Jew was. We cannot agree with the assumption that Isak Sobaka was the main character. The author emphasises the intertext ties between The Advice to the Orthodox Congress and the 1554 message of Ivan IV to Maksim Grek. The main idea of The Advice to the Orthodox Congress to execute heretics could not have been authored by Maksim Grek. The Advice occupies the place of one of the last chapters (Chapter 45) of the Joasaphus Collection and may be inauthentic. The Word on the Nativity of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, also against the Jews (Chapter 5 of the Joasaphus Collection) is an example of a solemn speech by an Orthodox preacher written in the late 1530s – early 1540s and should be regarded as a programmatic work by Maksim Grek contending the Jewish teaching. The main goal of the ecclesiastical publicist is to prove the divine nature of Christ and to accuse the Jews of His death. The dispersion of the three compositions in the systematised codices indicates different times of their creation, varying intentions, and diverse implementations of the author’s concepts.
Akty istoricheskie sobrannye i izdannye Arkheograficheskoyu komissieyu v 5 t. [Historical Acts Collected and Published by the Archaeological Commission. 5 Vols.]. (1841–1842). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Ekspeditsii zagotovleniya gosudarstvennykh bumag. Vol. 1. 614 p. (AI).
Bulanin. D. M. (2019). “Polnoe sobranie sochinenii” Maksima Greka. Nachalo raboty i plan ee zaversheniya [The Complete Works of Maksim Grek. The Beginning of Work and Plan for Its Completion]. In Studi Slavistici. Vol. 16. No. 2, pp. 119–137. DOI 10.13128/Studi_Slavis-7656.
Bulanin. D. M. (2021). Nad stranitsami “Perevodov zhidovstvuyushchikh” [Turning the Pages of the Translations by Judaizers]. In Drevnyaya Rus’. Voprosy medievistiki. No. 2, pp. 216–222. DOI 10.25986/IRI.2021.84.2.017.
GIM [State Historical Museum]. Sinodal’noe sobranie. No. 491. Turn of the 17th Century. 651 f.
Golubinskii, A. A. (1911). Istoriya russkoi tserkvi v 2 t. [The History of the Russian Church. 2 Vols.]. Moscow, Izdanie Imperatorskogo obshchestva istorii i drevnostei rossiiskikh pri Moskovskom universitete. Vol. 2. Part 1. 616 p.
GPNTB SO RAN [State Public Scientific Technological Library of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. Otdel redkikh i rukopisnykh knig (ORiRK). Sobranie M. N. Tikhomirova. No. 271. Second Half of the 19th Century. 651 f.
Ikonnikov. V. S. (1915). Maksim Grek i ego vremya. Istoricheskoe issledovanie [Maksim Grek and His Time. A Historical Study]. Kiev, Tipografiya Imperatorskogo universiteta svyatogo Vladimira. 651 p.
Kasapi, I. (2008). Otnoshenie Maksima Greka k eretikam [The Attitude of Maksim Grek to Heretics]. In Rossiya – Afon: tysyacheletie dukhovnogo edinstva. Materialy Mezhdunarodnoi nauchno-bogoslovskoi konferentsii. Moskva, 1–4 oktyabrya 2006 g. Moscow, Pravoslavnyi Svyato-Tikhonovskii gumanitarnyi universitet, pp. 297–301.
Kazakova, N. A. (1960). Vassian Patrikeev i ego sochineniya [Vassian Patrikeev and His Works]. Moscow, Leningrad, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. 363 p.
Lurye, Ya. S. (1960). Ideologicheskaya bor’ba v russkoi publitsistike kontsa XV – nachala XVI v. [The Ideological Struggle in the Russian Jouralistic Writings of the Late 15th – Early 16th Centuries]. Moscow, Leningrad, Akademiya nauk SSSR. 528 p.
Makarii, the Metropolitan of Moscow. (1996). Istoriya Russkoi Tserkvi v 7 kn. [The History of the Russian Church. 7 Books]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Spaso-Preobrazhenskogo Valaamskogo monastyrya. Book 4. Part 1. 590 p.
Manokhin, A. A. (2021). Sobor 1490 g. kak osnova konstruirovaniya “eresi zhidovstvuyushchikh” [The Council of 1490 as the Basis of the Construction of the Heresy of the Judaizers]. In Khristianskoe chtenie. No. 4, pp. 412–448. DOI 10.47132/1814-5574. National Library of Paris. Manuscript Slave. 123. Late 16th century. 715 f.
Pokrovskii, N. N., Shmidt, S. O. (Eds.). (1971). Sudnye spiski Maksima Greka i Isaka Sobaki [Sudnye Spiski by Maksim Grek and Isak Sobaka]. Moscow, Tipografiya Glavnogo arkhivnogo upravleniya Akademii nauk SSSR. 191 p.
Reverend Maksim Grek (2014–). Sochinenia [Writings] / ed. by N. V. Sinitsyna. Moscow, Rukopisnye pamyatniki Drevnei Rusi. Vol. 2. 432 p. (PMG).
RGB [Russian State Library]. Stock 37. Sobranie T. F. Bol’shakova. No. 285. First half of the 1550s. 306 f.; Stock 173/I. Sobranie MDA. No. 42. The turn of the 1550s. 416 f.; Stock 173/III. Sobranie MDA. No. 138. The turn of the 1550s. 236 f.; Stock 98. Sobranie E. E. gorova. No. 355. 17th century. 538 f.; Stock 354. Sobranie Vologodskoi dukhovnoi seminarii. No. 238. The turn of the 18th century. 118 f.
Shashkov, A. T. (1983). Tagil’skii sbornik sochinenii Maksima Greka (kodikologicheskie zametki) [The Tagil Collected Works by Maksim Grek (Codicological Notes)]. In Rukopisnaya traditsiya XVI–XIX vv. na vostoke Rossii. Novosibirsk, Nauka, pp. 4–14.
Sinitsyna, N. V. (1977). Maksim Grek v Rossii [Maksim Grek in Russia]. Moscow, Nauka. 332 p.
Sochinenia Maxima Greeka [Works of Venerable Maksim Grek]. (1859–1860). Kazan, Tipografiya gubernskogo pravleniya. Part 1. 553 p. Part 2. 460 p.
Zyablitsyna, N. A. (2013). Istoriya izucheniya tserkovnoslavyanskogo perevoda traktata “Uchitelya Samuila oblichenie” [The History of Studying of the Church Slavonic Translation of the Treatise Denunciation of Master Samuel]. In Prostranstvo i vremya. No. 2 (12), pp. 54–61. DOI 2226-7271provr_st2-12.2013.22.