A ‘Thirst for Torment’ vs Suffering ‘for Righteousness’: The Polemics of Old Believer Sacrifice at the Turn of the Era

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2021.4.638

Keywords:

sacrifice, martyrdom, self-immolation, admonition, Old Belief, Patriarch Joachim, Feofan Prokopovich, popular religiosity, Petrine era

Abstract

This article describes Old Believer polemics about sacrifice via self-immolation and other forms of ‘self-inflicted death’ between the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. The main object of condemnation by the Russian state and church authorities was the Old Believer system of sacralising one’s own sufferings (the creation and distribution of related narratives, appeals to popular religiosity, and the veneration of new martyrs). The author examines Old Believer writings and decrees, admonitions, and texts created by the authorities as parts of one discursive field and concludes that rational methods for combating Old Believer martyrs were consolidated in the Petrine era at the conceptual level in order to preserve the taxable population. Feofan (Prokopovich) offered the most original explanation for the widespread Old Believer veneration of new martyrs by interpreting it as bliss at being ‘persecuted for righteousness’ (1722): this interpretation was the basis for his admonition On the Invalidity of Unauthorised Suffering. The active disciplinary intervention of the authorities in the sacrificial discourse and the misinterpretation of self-sacrifice that spread among the Old Believers led their leaders to speak of piety as an indispensable condition for salvation. The desire of various participants in the discourse to speak on this topic generated, if not to a specific “language”, then a whole set of experiences embodied in genetically different rhetoric.

Author Biography

Alexey Popovich

Laboratory Researcher, Laboratory for the Study of Primary Sources, Ural Federal University named after the first President of Russia B. N. Yeltsin.

19, Mira Str., 620002, Yekaterinburg, Russia.

ORCID 0000-0002-0658-8795

alexeypopowich@mail.ru

References

Belyankin, Yu. S. (2012). Tserkov’ i gosudarstvo v polemike so staroobryadtsami vo vtoroi polovine XVII v. (na primere deyatel’nosti Moskovskogo Pechatnogo dvora) [Church and State in their Polemics with Old Believers in the Second Half of the 17th Century (with Reference to the Activities of the Moscow Printing House)]. Dis. … kand. ist. nauk. Moscow, S. n. 289 p.

Biokhronika Petra Velikogo (1672–1725 gg.) [The Biochronicle of Peter the Great (1672–1725)]. [website]. (N. d.). URL: https://spb.hse.ru/humart/history/peter/biochronic/246798653 (accessed: 10.08.2021).

Buganov, V. I. (1969). Moskovskie vosstaniya kontsa XVII veka [Moscow Uprisings of the Late 17th Century]. Moscow, Nauka. 440 p.

Crummey, R. O. (2011). Old Believers in a Changing World. DeKalb, Northern Illinois Univ. Press. XIII, 267 p.

Demidova, L. D. (2015). Ob istokakh traditsii pochitaniya muchenikov za veru [On the Origins of the Tradition of Venerating Martyrs for the Faith]. In Religioznye i politicheskie idei v proizvedeniyakh deyatelei russkoi kul’tury XVI–XXI vv. Novosibirsk, Izdatel’stvo Sibirskogo otdeleniya RAN, pp. 41–57.

Dmitriev, L. A. (1973). Zhitiinye povesti russkogo Severa kak pamyatniki literatury XIII–XVII vekov. Evolyutsiya zhanra legendarno-biograficheskikh skazanii [Hagiographic Stories of the Russian North as Literary Aretfacts of the 13th–17th Centuries. The Evolution of the Genre of Legendary Biographical Legends]. Leningrad, Nauka. 303 p.

Eleonskaya, A. S. (1978). Utverzhdenie tsennosti zhizni (“Otrazitel’noe pisanie” inoka Evfrosina) [Assertion of the Value of Life (“The Opposite Scripture” of Monk Evfrosin)]. In Eleonskaya, A. S. Russkaya publitsistika vtoroi poloviny XVII veka. Moscow, Nauka, pp. 186–231.

Gur’yanova, N. S. (1996). “Opisanie o nelepykh sluchayakh i neobychnykh pustynnomu zhitiyu deistvakh, vnesshikhsya ot svoevol’nikov” [“Description of the Absurd Cases and Unusual Hermit Activities from the Svoevol’niki]. In Russkoe obshchestvo i literatura pozdnego feodalizma. Novosibirsk, Sibirskii khronograf, pp. 225–246.

Joachim, patriarch (1683). Slovo blagodarstvennoe o izbavlenii tserkvi ot otstupnikov [A Sermon of Thanks for the Deliverance of the Church from Apostates]. Moscow, Pechatnyi dvor. 128 p.

Ivan Filippov (2005). Istoriya Vygovskoi staroobryadcheskoi pustyni [History of the Vyg Old Believer Hermitage]. Moscow, Tretii Rim. 377 p.

Kalugin, V. V. (2013). Kievskie fal’sifikatory nachala XVIII veka (“Trebnik 1329 g. mitropolita Feognosta”) [Kiev Falsifiers of the Early 18th Century (The 1329 Trebnik by Metropolitan Feognost)]. In Staroobryadchestvo v Rossii (XVII–XX vv.). Sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Iss. 5. Moscow, Yazyki slavyanskoi kul’tury, pp. 127–183.

Lavrov, A. S. (2000). Koldovstvo i religiya v Rossii: 1700–1740 gg. [Witchcraft and Religion in Russia: 1700–1740]. Moscow, Drevlekhranilishche. 575 p.

Lileev, M. I. (1895). Iz istorii raskola na Vetke i v Starodub’e [From the History of the Schism in Viatka and Starodubye]. Kiev, Tipografiya G. T. Korchak-Novitskogo. Iss. 1. XII, 596 p.

Makhotina, E. (2019). Melankholiya prikhodit v Rossiyu : Monastyri kak dolgauzy v Rossii v XVIII veke [Melancholia Arrives in Russia: Monasteries as Asylums in Eighteenth-Century Russia]. In Vivlioθika. E-Journal of Eighteenth-Century Russian Studies. Vol. 7, pp. 21–46. DOI 10.21900/j.vivliofika.v7.783.

Mal’tsev, A. I. (1982). Neizvestnoe sochinenie S. Denisova o tarskom “bunte” 1722 g. [S. Denisov’s Unknown Work about the Tara “Revolt” (1722)]. In Istochniki po kul’ture i klassovoi bor’be feodal’nogo perioda. Novosibirsk, Nauka, pp. 224–241.

Ob”yavlenie ot Svyateishego Pravitel’stvuyushchego Vserossiiskogo Sinoda vo uveshchanie obretayushchimsya vo vsem Rossiiskom gosudarstve raskol’nikam (5 iyulya 1725 g.) [Announcement from the Most Holy Governing All-Russian Synod in Exhortation to Schismatics Found throughout the Entire Russian State (5 July 1725)]. (1890). In Barsov, E. V. Novye materialy dlya istorii staroobryadchestva XVII–XVIII vekov. Moscow, Universitetskaya tipografiya, pp. 157–161.

Loparev, Kh. (Ed.). (1895). Otrazitel’noe pisanie o novoizobretennom puti samoubiistvennykh smertei. Vnov’ naidennyi staroobryadcheskii traktat protiv samosozhzheniya 1691 goda [Opposite Scripture on the Newly Invented Path of Suicidal Death: A Newly Found Old Believer Treatise against Self-Immolation (1691)]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya I. N. Skorokhodova. [4], 72, 160 p.

Pigin, A. V. (Ed.). (2010). Pamyatniki knizhnoi stariny Russkogo Severa: kollektsii rukopisei XV–XX vekov v gosudarstvennykh khranilishchakh Respubliki Kareliya [The Book Antiquities of Northern Russia: Manuscript Collections from the 15th–20th Centuries in the State Depositories of the Republic of Karelia]. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin. 604 p.

Panchenko, A. (2020). “Starye sekty” na novyi lad: problemy i perspektivy izucheniya russkikh religioznykh dissidentov XVIII–XX vv. [‘Old Sects’ in a New Light: How to Study Russian Religious Dissent, 1700–1900]. In Gosudarstvo, religiya, tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom. No. 3 (38), pp. 7–37. DOI 10.22394/2073-7203-2020-38-3-7-37.

Panich, T. V. (2004). Kniga “Shchit very” v istoriko-literaturnom kontekste kontsa XVII veka [The Shield of Faith in the Historical and Literary Context of the Late 17th Century]. Novosibirsk, Sibirskii khronograf. 327 p.

Plyukhanova, M. B. (2000). O natsional’nykh sredstvakh samoopredeleniya lichnosti: samosakralizatsiya, samosozhzhenie, plavanie na korable [On National Means of Personal Self-Determination: Self-Sacralisation, Self-Immolation, Sailing on a Ship]. In Iz istorii russkoi kul’tury. 2nd Ed. Moscow, Yazyki russkoi kul’tury. Vol. 3, pp. 380–459.

Polnoe sobranie postanovlenii i rasporyazhenii po vedomstvu pravoslavnogo ispovedaniya Rossiiskoi imperii [Complete Collection of Decrees and Orders for the Department of the Orthodox Confession of the Russian Empire]. (1869–1911). St Petersburg, Sinodal’naya tipografiya. Vol. 3. [10], 260 p. Vol. 4. [2], 16, 366 p.

Popovich, A. I. (2020a). “Izobrazhaya zhertvu”: pafos oblicheniya i muchenichestva v sochineniyakh Ivana Groznogo i Andreya Kurbskogo [“Playing the Victim”: The Message of Denunciation and Martyrdom in the Works of Ivan the Terrible and Andrey Kurbsky]. In Problemy istoricheskoi poetiki. Vol. 18. No. 4, pp. 67–98. DOI 10.15393/j9.art.2020.8743.

Popovich, A. I. (2020b). Osmyslenie konflikta s gosudarstvom cherez ponyatie zhertvy v staroobryadcheskikh sochineniyakh XVIII veka [Understanding the Conflict with the State through the Concept of Sacrifice in 18th-Century Old Believers’ Writings]. In Staroobryadchestvo v istorii i kul’ture Rossii: problemy izucheniya. (K 400-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya protopopa Avvakuma). Moscow, Institut rossiskoi istorii RAN, pp. 129–142.

Prokopovich, F. (1722). Khristovy o blazhenstvakh propovedi tolkovanie [An Interpretation of Christ’s Sermons on the Beatitudes]. 1st Ed. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Aleksandro-Nevskogo monastyrya. 141 l.

Prokopovich, F. (1865). Pis’mo k Yakovu Markevichu – iz Peterburga ot 10 maya 1720 goda [A Letter to Yakov Markevich from St Petersburg (May 10, 1720)]. In Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii. Vol. 1. Kiev, Tipografiya Kievo-Pecherskoi lavry, pp. 287–294.

PSZ [Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire]. Collection 1. Vol. 6.

Pul’kin, M. V. (2013). Samosozhzheniya staroobryadtsev (seredina XVII – XIX v.) [The Self-Immolation of Old Believers (mid-17th – 19th Centuries]. Moscow, Russkii fond sodeistviya obrazovaniyu i nauke. 336 p.

Pypin, A. N. (1883). Svodnyi staroobryadcheskii sinodik [Consolidated Old Believer Synodik]. 2nd Ed. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Dobrodeeva. [2], V, 60 p.

RGIA [Russian State Historical Archive]. Stock 796. List 2. Dos. 528.

Romanova, E. V. (2012). Massovye samosozhzheniya staroobryadtsev v Rossii v XVII–XIX vekakh [The Mass Self-Immolations of Old Believers in Russia in the 17th–19th Centuries]. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge. 288 p.

Shashkov, A. T. (2013). “Neoskvernyaemoe kreshchenie ognem” [“The Undefiled Baptism with Fire”]. In Shashkov, A. T. Izbrannye trudy. Yekaterinburg, Basko, pp. 163–179.

Voskresenskii, N. A., Anisimov, E. V. (Eds.). (2020). Zakonodatel’nye akty Petra I. Redaktsii i proekty zakonov, zametki, doklady, donosheniya, chelobit’ya i inostrannye istochniki. Sbornik dokumentov v 3 t. [Legislative Acts of Peter I. Versions and Drafts, Notes, Reports, Denunciations, Petitions and Foreign Sources. Collection of Documents. 3 Vols.] / introd. by D. O. Serov, archival introd. by A. A. Bogdanov. Moscow, Drevlekhranilishche. Vol. 2. Akty ob obshchestvennykh klassakh. Vol. 3. Akty o promyshlennosti i torgovli. 848 p.

Yukhimenko, E. M. (1994). Kargopol’skie “gari” 1683–1684 godov. (K probleme samosozhzhenii v russkom staroobryadchestve) [Kargopol “Fumes” of 1683–1684. (On the Issue of Self-Immolations in Russian Old Belief)]. In Staroobryadchestvo v Rossii. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Iss. 1. Moscow, Arkheograficheskii tsentr, pp. 64–119.

Zhivov, V. (2012). Dva etapa distsiplinarnoi revolyutsii v Rossii XVII i XVIII stoletiya [Two Stages of the Disciplinary Revolution in Russia: The Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries]. In Cahiers du monde russe. Vol. 53. No. 2–3, pp. 349–374. DOI 10.4000/monderusse.9386.

Published

2021-12-22

How to Cite

Popovich, A. (2021). A ‘Thirst for Torment’ vs Suffering ‘for Righteousness’: The Polemics of Old Believer Sacrifice at the Turn of the Era. Quaestio Rossica, 9(4), 1259–1277. https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2021.4.638

Issue

Section

Problema voluminis