Tomsk Judge Alexander Levberg: The Facets of Collaboration with Bolsheviks at the Beginning of the Civil War
Keywords:justice, Soviet regime, White movement, Civil War, judicial figures, A. E. Levberg, Tomsk, Siberia
In 1917, the Soviet regime began to introduce new forms of state and legal relations. The former system of justice was being violently destroyed, which led to a split in the judicial community and caused significant changes in the legal culture of practitioners, who were thrown into unavoidable political and professional choices. In this article, the author refers to the story of judge A. E. Levberg and studies the professional paths of Siberian judicial figures who joined Soviet institutions, finding out the motives governing their actions and evaluating the repressive measures employed. The study makes it possible to add new information to data on the mechanisms of revolutionary transformations, helps explain the patterns of how state legal systems functioned, and increases knowledge about human behaviour during a deep social and political conflict. A central focus on everyday life, micro-historical analysis, and the use of various sources (print media, private sources, and archival documentation introduced into scholarly circulation for the first time) make it possible to comprehensively consider reports on the liquidation of pre-revolutionary courts and the transfer of their employees to work for the Bolsheviks. Such decisions did not necessarily entail the intentional participation of judicial personnel in the construction of the new regime, as it could have been caused by material need; moreover, it allowed judges to continue their judicial practice and fulfill their professional duty to society. Many might have considered their work in the Soviet state apparatus as subversion against it. The judicial community itself considered cooperation with the Soviets a betrayal of the principles of corporate solidarity and ideals of justice. After the Bolsheviks had been overthrown, their collaborators from among the judiciary were prosecuted. Despite social and professional hostility towards them, these people avoided severe punishment: the legal framework did not classify their actions as a crime, and no provision existed for sanctioning moral or political choices.
Bourdieu, P. (2017). O gosudarstve. Kurs lektsii v Kollezh de Frans (1989–1992) [On the State. A Course of Lectures at the College de France (1989–1992)]. Moscow, Delo. 720 p.
Dekrety Sovetskoi vlasti v 18 t. [Decrees of the Soviet Authorities. 18 Vols.]. (1957). Moscow, Gospolitizdat. Vol. 1. 25 oktyabrya 1917 g. – 16 marta 1918 g. 626 p.
Fominykh, S. F. (Ed.). (1996). Professora Tomskogo universiteta. Biograficheskii slovar’ [Professors of Tomsk University. Biographical Dictionary]. Tomsk, Izdatel’stvo Tomskogo universiteta. Iss. 1. 1888–1917. 288 p.
GAIO [State Archive of Irkutsk Region]. Stock 245. List 4. Dos. 44.
GAOO [State Archive of Omsk Region]. Stock 25. List 1. Dos. 317, 356; Stock 391. List 1. Dos. 4, 8, 12.
GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. Stock R-193. List 1. Dos. 2; Stock R-4369. List 1. Dos. 86; List 3. Dos. 1, 228; List 5. Dos. 74.
GATO [State Archive of Tomsk Region]. Stock R-53. List 1. Dos. 188; Stock R-173. List 1. Dos. 80.
Golos naroda [Golos Naroda]. (1918). June 8; July 18, 20.
Huskey, Eu. (1993). Rossiiskie advokaty i sovetskoe gosudarstvo. Proiskhozhdenie i razvitie sovetskoi advokatury. 1917–1939 [Russian Lawyers and the Soviet State. The Origin and Development of the Soviet Bar. 1917–1939]. Moscow, Institut gosudarstva i prava RAN. 184 p.
Krasil’nikov, S. A., Pystina, L. I., et. al. (2007). Intelligentsiya Sibiri v pervoi chetverti XX veka: status i korporativnye tsennosti [The Siberian Intelligentsia in the First Quarter of the 20th Century: Status and Corporate Values]. Novosibirsk, Sova. 310 p.
Krestiyannikov, E. A. (2018). Finansovye aspekty sudebnoi reformy v Sibiri (konets XIX – nachalo XX v.) [Judicial Reform in Siberia: Financial Aspects (Late 19th – Early 20th Centuries)]. In Rossiiskaya istoriya. No. 2, pp. 22–34.
Krestiynnikov, E. A. (2017). P. V. Vologodskii i prisyazhnye poverennye v Sibiri [P. V. Vologodsky and Sworn Attorneys in Siberia]. In Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. No. 419, pp. 152–159. DOI 10.17223/15617793/419/20.
Levin-Stankevich, B. L. (1996). The Transfer of Legal Technology and Culture: Law Professionals in Tsarist Russia. In Balzer, H. D. (Ed.). Russia’s Missing Middle Class: The Professions in Russian History. Armonk, N. Y., M. E. Sharpe, pp. 223–249.
Maier, N. (1921–1923). Sluzhba v Komissariate yustitsii i narodnom sude [Service in the Commissariat of Justice and the People’s Court]. In Arkhiv russkoi revolyutsii [v 22 t.] / publ. by I. V. Gessen. Berlin, Slovo. Vol. 8, pp. 56–109.
Materialy Narodnogo komissariata yustitsii. Iss. 1. Pervyi Vserossiiskii s’’ezd oblastnykh i gubernskikh komissarov yustitsii [Materials of the People’s Commissariat of Justice. Iss. 1. First All-Russian Congress of Regional and Provincial Commissars of Justice]. (1918). Moscow, Narodnyi komissariat yustitsii. 60 p.
Murav’ev, N. V. (1889). Prokurorskii nadzor v ego ustroistve i deyatel’nosti. Posobie dlya prokurorskoi sluzhby [Prosecutorial Supervision in Its Creation and Activities. Benefits for the Prosecution Service]. Moscow, Universitetskaya tipografiya. Vol. 1. Prokuratura na Zapade i v Rossii. 554 p.
Narkevich, S. Ya. (1922). Zakrytie irkutskikh sudebnykh ustanovlenii [The Closure of Irkutsk Judicial Establishments]. In Ezhenedel’nik sovetskoi yustitsii. No. 44–45, pp. 35–37.
Omskii vestnik [Omskii Vestnik]. (1917). December 29, 30.
Prikazy po vedomstvu Ministerstva yustitsii [Orders by the Ministry of Justice]. (1917). In Zhurnal Ministerstva yustitsii. No. 7–8, pp. 81–123.
Proletarii [Proletarii]. (1918). January 12.
Put’ naroda [Put’ Naroda]. (1918). February 22; March 24, 29.
Reforma mestnogo suda v Sibiri [Reform of the Local Court in Siberia]. (1911). In Trudy Yuridicheskogo obshchestva pri Imperatorskom Tomskom universitete. Iss. 2. Tomsk, Tipografiya Sibirskogo tovarishchestva pechatnogo dela. 30 p.
Shakhrai, S. M., Krakovskii, K. P. (2017). Yuristy i revolyutsiya. Pro et Contra [Lawyers and Revolution. Pro et Contra]. Moscow, Kuchkovo pole. 552 p.
Sibirskaya zhizn’ [Sibirskaya Zhizn’]. (1918). June 18; July 4, 27.
Solomon, P. (2008). Sovetskaya yustitsiya pri Staline [Soviet Justice under Stalin]. Moscow, ROSSPEN, Fond Pervogo Prezidenta Rossii B. N. El’tsina. 464 p.
Svobodnaya Sibir’ [Svobodnaya Sibir’]. (1918). January 11.
TsGIA SPb [Central State Historical Archive of St Petersburg]. Stock 2297. List 1. Dos. 9, 12, 19.
Ukazy i prikazy Vremennogo pravitel’stva [Decrees and Orders of the Provisional Government]. (1917). In Zhurnal Ministerstva yustitsii. No. 4, pp. 19–22.
Vologodskii, P. V. (2006). Vo vlasti i v izgnanii. Dnevnik prem’er-ministra antibol’shevistskikh pravitel’stv i emigranta v Kitae (1918–1925 gg.) [In Power and in Exile: The Diary of the Prime Minister of Anti-Bolshevik Governments and an Émigré in China (1918–1925)]. Ryazan’, publ. by P. A. Tribunskii. 619 p.
Zlobintsev, V. I. (1918). Sudoustroistvo i sudoproizvodstvo po dekretam № 1 i 2 [The Judicial System and Legal Proceedings According to Decrees Nos. 1 and 2]. In Znamya revolyutsii. April 17.
Znamya revolyutsii [Znamya Revolyutsii]. (1918). January 5, 28; March 23.
Zvezdov, A. A. (1957). V period podgotovki Oktyabr’skoi revolyutsii [During the Preparation for the October Revolution]. In V boyakh za vlast’ Sovetov (vospominaniya uchastnikov sotsialisticheskoi revolyutsii i Grazhdanskoi voiny v Omske i Omskoi oblasti). Omsk, Omskoe oblastnoe knizhnoe izdatel’stvo, pp. 38–43.