Birthday Collections — Pro et Contra




A. Kh. Goldenberg; V. N. Zakharov; birthday collection of articles; a scholarly collection; a local text


What are the ideological and artistic peculiarities of collections of articles published in connection with a scholar’s birthday and how are they different from high-ranking academic journals? In this article, the reviewers analyse two collections of articles on philology issued to commemorate scholars’ birthdays and try to answer these questions. Except for expressing respect, such collections are manifestations of the cultural and academic views and achievements of the scholar, their followers, and students. Such collections aim to draw attention to the personality of a scholar who has established a school and is developing their field of knowledge; also, it is an opportunity to evaluate their achievements and the achievements of their school, which has its own methods and followers. The reviewers analyse materials of both collections and conclude that they can be characterised by a diversity of views and methods from literary criticism on Russian literature compared with precedent texts of world literature. On the other hand, the disadvantage of such collections is the fact that they contain many articles authored by people willing to express their gratitude to the scholar but failing to comply with the theme and concept of the collection. The reviewers conclude that, overall, such collections are meant as an attempt at a collective search for scholarly truth. Together with high-ranking journals indexed in Russian and international databases, such collections are a valuable fund, accumulating scholarly research works as they focus on the new discoveries of different schools of knowledge.

Author Biographies

Irina Dergacheva

Dr. Hab. (Philology), Head of the Department of Linguistics, Moscow State Institute of Culture.

7, Bibliotechnaya Str., 141406, Khimki, Moscow Region, Russia.

ORCID 0000-0002-4878-2027

Elena Sozina

Dr. Hab. (Philology), Head of the Center of the History of Literature, Institute of History and Archaeology, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Professor, Ural Federal University named after the first President of Russia B. N. Yeltsin.

16, S. Kovalevskaya Str., 620990, Yekaterinburg, Russia.

19, Mira Str., 620002, Yekaterinburg, Russia.

ORCID 0000-0002-7462-4153


De La Fortelle, A., Mnikh, R. (Eds.). (2019). Literaturovedeniya ocharovannaya dal’. Festshrift v chest’ 74-letiya professora L. Gellera v 2 t. [The Charming Distance of Literary Studies: Festschrift in Honour of the 74th Birthday of Professor L. Geller. 2 Vols.]. Lausanne, Siedlce, Wydawnictvo Naukowe Instytutu Kultury. Vol. 1. 376 p. Vol. 2. 308 p.

Kalinin, I., Ichin, K. (Eds.). (2019). Energiya krizisa. Sbornik v chest’ I. P. Smirnova [The Energy of Crisis. A Collection in Honour of I. P. Smirnov]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 392 p.

Koz’mina, E. Yu. (2014). Yubileinyi sbornik nauchnykh trudov: kharakteristika izdaniya [A Birthday Collection of Scholarly Papers: Characteristics of the Publication]. In Russkii yazyk: chelovek, kul’tura, kommunikatsiya – IV. Sbornik materialov Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, 15 aprelya – 15 maya 2014 g., g. Yekaterinburg. Yekaterinburg, Izdatel’stvo Ural’skogo universiteta, pp. 198–208.

Magomedova, D. M., Zuseva-Ozkan, V. B., Fedunina, O. V. (Eds.). (2019). Literaturoman(n)iya. K 90-letiyu Yu. V. Manna. Sbornik statei [Literaturoman(n)iya. For the 90th Birthday of Yu. V. Mann. A Collection of Articles]. Moscow, Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi gumanitarnyi universitet. 694 p.

Markovich, V. M. (2002). Kontseptsiya “stadial’nosti literaturnogo razvitiya” v rabotakh G. A. Gukovskogo 1940-kh gg. [The Concept of the “Stadiality of Literary Development” in the Works of G. A. Gukovsky in the 1940s]. In Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. No. 3 (55), pp. 77–105.

Pigin, A. V. Andrianova, I. S. (Eds.). (2019). Filologiya kak prizvanie. Sbornik statei k yubileyu professora V. N. Zakharova [Philology as a Vocation. A Collection of Articles for the Birthday of Professor V. N. Zakharov]. Petrozavodsk, Izdatel’stvo Petrozavodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 664 p.

Tropkina, N. E. (Ed.). (2019). Vostok – Zapad: prostranstvo lokal’nogo teksta v literature i fol’klore. Sbornik statei k 70-letiyu professora A. Kh. Gol’denberga [East – West: The Space of Local Texts in Literature and Folklore. A Collection of Articles for the 70th Birthday of Professor A. Kh. Goldenberg]. Volgograd, Nauchnoe izdatel’stvo Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo sotsial’no-pedagogicheskogo universiteta “Peremena”. 471 p.

Tynyanov, Yu. N. (1977). Poetika. Istoriya literatury. Kino [Poetics. The History of Literature. Cinema]. Moscow, Nauka. 574 p.

Virolainen, M. N. (2017). “Uzly” i “tsikly” v istorii russkoi literatury [“Knots” and “Cycles” in the History of Russian Literature]. In Russkaya literatura. No. 3, pp. 5–13.



How to Cite

Dergacheva, I., & Sozina, E. (2020). Birthday Collections — Pro et Contra. Quaestio Rossica, 8(3), 1070–1086.



Controversiae et recensiones