To See Russian History as Part of the Pan-European Continuum

  • Denis Lyapin


The author reviews a book by Nancy Shields Kollmann, a well-known specialist in the history of early-modern Russia and professor at Stanford University (California, USA). The book is a vast study of the judicial proceedings and enforcement of sentences in Russia between the 15th and early 18th centuries. The reviewer analyses the structure of the book, its methods, and the narrative: he focuses on Kollmann’s basic concept, according to which Russia should be regarded as part of the all-European continuum. This conclusion is of considerable importance for understanding Russian history. The reviewer argues that Russian academia should pay close attention to the work as it contains many valuable factual materials and interesting observations. Another factor that the reviewer considers relevant is that the author’s principles of work and the peculiarities of her representation of the material differ from the traditions of Russian historical scholarship. However, the translation tends to be literal. This book about “crime and punishment” is an important step for understanding the sociopolitical peculiarities of Russia’s development in the early modern period.

Author Biography

Denis Lyapin

Dr. Hab. (History), Associate Professor, Bunin Yelets State University.

28, Kommunarov Str., 399770, Yelets, Russia.


Davies, L. (2004). State Power and Community in Early Modern Russia. The Case of Kozlov, 1635–1649. N. Y., Palgrave Macmillan. 504 р.

Keenan, E. (1986). Russian Political Folkways. In Russian Rev. No. 2, pp. 118–119.

Kollmann, N. (2016). Prestuplenie i nakazanie v Rossii rannego Novogo vremeni [Crime and Punishment in Early Modern Russia] / transl. by P. I. Prudovsky, ed. A. B. Kamenskiy. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2016. 617 p.

Kollmann, N. (2001). Soedinennye chest’ju. Gosudarstvo i obshhestvo v Rossii rannego novogo vremeni [Bound by Honor: State and Society in Early Modern Russia] / transl. by A. B. Kamenskiy, ed. B. N. Florja. Moscow, Drevlehranilishhe, 2001. 460 с.

Kollmann, N. (1999). By Honor Bound: State and Society in Early Modern Russia. Ithaca and London, Cornell Univ. Press, 296 p.

Kollmann, N. (2017). The Russian Empire 1450–1801. Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press. 512 p.

Kollmann, N. (1987). Kinship and Politics: The Making of the Muscovite Political System, 1345–1547. Stanford, Stanford Univ. Press, 324 p.

Kollmann, N. (1998). Russia // The New Cambridge Medieval History. Vol. 7 c 1415–1500. Ed. by Ch. Allamand. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 748–770.

Kollmann, N. (2012). Crime and Punishment in Early Modern Russia. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press, 488 p.

Ljapin, D. (2015). Prichiny vosstanija v Moskve v 1648 g. [Causes for the Uprising in Moscow in 1648]. In Voprosy istorii. № 1. Pp. 90–98.

Maul’, V. (2017). Russkij bunt kak aktual’naja problema sovremennoj gumanitaristiki: istochniki, metody i perspektivy izuchenija [Russian Rebellion as a Relevant Issue in the Modern Humanities: Sources, Methods, and Prospects of Study]. In Istorija: Fakty i simvoly. No 3, pp. 28–34. DOI 10.24888/2410-4205-2017-12-3-28-34.

Pipes, R. (1990). Russia Under the Old Regime. L., Penguin Books, 1990. 361 p.
How to Cite
Lyapin, D. (2018). To See Russian History as Part of the Pan-European Continuum. Quaestio Rossica, 6(2), 605–612.
Controversiae et recensiones