Women’s Daily Life in the Occupation: Sexual Violence in Documents and Soviet Propaganda
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2024.2.898Keywords:
Great Patriotic War, women’s everyday life, occupation, rape, prostitutionAbstract
The problem of sexual violence in the occupied Soviet territories during the Great Patriotic War is an under-researched and taboo subject in the Russian public sphere. It is viewed either from the perspective of collaboration in prostitution and cohabitation, or from the perspective of gender discrimination and sexual violence. At the same time, it is extremely difficult to differentiate these features of women’s everyday life under the conditions of the “war of annihilation”. Based on the documents of the Extraordinary State Commission for the Investigation of the Atrocities of the German Fascist Invaders, partisan reports, and other documents, as well as articles from the wartime periodical press, the author compares images of sexual violence with the practices of women’s everyday life under occupation. In the propaganda of the warring countries, the image of the abused female body was actively used to incite hatred of the enemy. Rape and the forcing of women under occupation to work in brothels were presented in this light. A comparison of propaganda images and specific facts of violence presented in official and ego-documents shows the existence of discrepancies between images and practices. While rape was fairly accurately portrayed in official texts, the problem of prostitution was less accurately reflected in reality. Individual women used their bodies as a means of survival and received various material benefits in return. The population did not perceive legal prostitution in the categories of propaganda and interpreted it as a betrayal. Although some decrees were passed during the war in both Germany and the USSR that treated violence against women as a crime, women were not recognised as victims in the Soviet public trials or at the Nuremberg Tribunal and did not receive compensation. During the transition to peace, the problem of sexual violence lost its pragmatic propaganda function and was excluded from the collective memory. Nevertheless, the increase in violence against women during the Second World War led to the adoption of the Geneva Convention for the Protection of Victims of War in 1949, which was ratified by the Soviet Union in 1954.
References
Beck, B. (2004). Wehrmacht und sexuelle Gewalt: Sexualverbrechen vor deutschen Militärgerichten, 1939–1945. Paderborn, Schöningh. 370 S.
Bez sroka davnosti: prestupleniya natsistov i ikh posobnikov protiv mirnogo naseleniya na okkupirovannoi territorii RSFSR v gody Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny. Kurskaya oblast’. Sbornik dokumentov [Without a Statute of Limitations: Crimes of the Nazis and Their Accomplices against the Civilian Population in the Occupied Territory of the RSFSR during the Great Patriotic War. Kursk Region. Collection of Documents]. (2020). Moscow, Fond “Svyaz’ epokh”. 488 p.
Byulleten’ No. 7 UNKVD po Kurskoi oblasti o polozhenii v okkupirovannykh raionakh Kurskoi oblasti za period s 1 po 31 marta 1942 g. [Bulletin No. 7 of the NKVD for Kursk Region on the Situation in the Occupied Areas of Kursk Region for the Period from March1 to March 31, 1942]. (N. d.). In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http://victims.rusarchives.ru/byulleten-no‑7‑unkvd-po-kurskoy-oblasti-o-polozhenii-v-rayonakh-kurskoy-oblasti-okkupirovannykh (accessed: 01.04.2023).
Dubina, V. (2011). Boleznennaya tema Vtoroi mirovoi voiny: pamyat’ o seksual’nom nasilii po obe storony fronta [Painful Theme of the Second World War: The Memory of Sexual Violence on Both Sides of the Front]. In Vestnik Rossiiskogo gosudarstvennogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriya: Literaturovedenie. Yazykoznanie. Kul’turologiya. No. 17 (79), pp. 47–56.
Dyukov, A. R. (2007). Za chto srazhalis’ sovetskie lyudi [What Did the Soviet People Fight for?]. Moscow, Yauza, Eksmo. 573 p.
Fragment kinokhroniki iz “Soyuzkinozhurnal No. 23” [Fragment of Newsreel from “Soyuzkinozhurnal No. 23”]. In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http://victims.rusarchives.ru/fragment-kinokhroniki-iz-soyuzkinozhurnal-no‑23‑o-razrusheniyakh-izlodeyaniyakh-nemecko‑0 (accessed: 03.05.2023)
GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. Stock R‑7021. List 8. Dos. 26; List 86. Dos. 48; List 116. Dos. 324; List 148. Dos. 38; List 149. Dos. 17; List 149. Dos. 16.
GARO [State Archive of Rostov Region]. Stock R‑3613. List 1. Dos. 24.
K zhenshchinam vsego mira! Vystupleniya na zhenskom antifashistskom mitinge, sostoyavshemsya v Moskve v Kolonnom zale Doma Soyuzov 7 sentyabrya 1941 g. [To Women All over the World! Speeches at the Women’s Anti-Fascist Rally Held in Moscow in the Pillar Hall of the House of the Unions on September 7, 1941]. (1941). Moscow, Gospolitizdat. 47 p.
Kepov, A. G. (2002). Kursk v period okkupatsii 1941–1943 gg. [Kursk during the Occupation of 1941–1943.]. In Kurskie memuary. No. 2. Kursk, S. n., pp. 23–45.
Kovalev, B. N. (2009). Kollaboratsionizm v Rossii v 1941–1945 gg.: tipy i formy [Collaborationism in Russia in 1941–1945: Types and Forms]. Velikii Novgorod, Novgorodskii gosudarstvennyi universitet imeni Yaroslava Mudrogo. 372 р.
Lotareva, D., Tikhonov, V. (2014). Sobesednik Rokossovskogo [An Interlocutor of Rokossovsky’s]. In Rodina. No. 12, pp. 27–30.
Mühlhäuser, R. (2010). Eroberungen. Sexuelle Gewalttaten und intime Beziehungen deutsche Soldaten in der Sowjetunion, 1941–1945. Hamburg, Hamburger Ed. 416 S.
“Novyi poryadok” fashistskikh maroderov [“New Order” of Fascist Marauders]. (1941). In Izvestiya. No. 155. July 3.
Nyurnbergskii protsess. Sbornik materialov v 8 t. [Nuremberg Trials. Collection of Materials. 8 Vols.]. (1987–1999). Moscow, Yuridicheskaya literatura.
O merakh nakazaniya dlya nemetsko-fashistskikh zlodeev, vinovnykh v ubiistvakh i istyazaniyakh sovetskogo grazhdanskogo naseleniya i plennykh krasnoarmeitsev, dlya shpionov, izmennikov Rodiny iz chisla sovetskikh grazhdan i ikh posobnikov. Ukaz prezidiuma Verkhovnogo soveta SSSR № 39 ot 19 aprelya 1943 g. [On Punishment Measures for Nazi Villains Guilty of the Murder and Torture of the Soviet Civilian Population and Captured Red Army Soldiers, for Spies, Traitors to the Motherland from among Soviet Citizens and Their Accomplices. Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR No. 39 of April 19, 1943]. (N. d.). In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http//victims.rusarchives.ru/ukaz-prezidiuma-verkhovnogo-soveta-sssr-no‑39‑omerakh-nakazaniya-dlya-nemecko-fashistskikh-zlodeev?ysclid=lh7huxgsuo426127281 (accessed: 03.05.2023).
O povsemestnykh grabezhakh, razorenii naseleniya i chudovishchnykh zverstvakh germanskikh vlastei na zakhvachennykh imi sovetskikh territoriyakh. Nota narcoma inostrannykh del SSSR V. M. Molotova [On Widespread Robberies, Devastation of the Population, and Monstrous Atrocities of the German Authorities in the Soviet Territories They Captured. Note from the People’s Commissar for Foreign Affairs of the USSR V. M. Molotov]. (N. d.). In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http://victims.rusarchives.ru/nota-narkoma-inostrannykh-del-sssr-molotova‑6‑yanvarya‑1942 (accessed: 03.05.2023).
Obvinitel’noe zaklyuchenie po delu o zverstvakh nemetsko-fashistskikh zakhvatchikov v g. Smolenske i Smolenskoi oblasti [Indictment in the Case of the Atrocities of the Nazi Invaders in the City of Smolensk and Smolensk Region]. (N. d.). In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http://victims.rusarchives.ru/10–12–1945‑obvinitelnoe-zaklyuchenie-podelu-o-zverstvakh-nemecko-fashistskikh-zakhvatchikov (accessed: 03.05.2023).
Obvinitel’noe zaklyuchenie prokuratury Chernomorskogo flota [Indictment from the Black Sea Fleet Prosecutor’s Office]. (N. d.). In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http://victims.rusarchives.ru/obvinitelnoe-zaklyuchenie-prokuratury-chernomorskogoflota-po-delu-o-zverstvakh-nemeckikh-okkupantov (accessed: 03.05.2023).
Organy gosudarstvennoi bezopasnosti SSSR v Velikoi Otechestvennoi voine. Sbornik dokumentov v 8 t. [State Security Bodies of the USSR in the Great Patriotic War. Collection of Documents]. (2003). Moscow, Rus’. Vol. 3. Krushenie “blitskriga”. Book 1 (1 yanvarya – 30 iyunya 1942 g.). 706 p.
Proklyatie i mest’ fashistskim varvaram! [Curse and Revenge on the Fascist Barbarians!]. (1941). In Pravda. No. 353. Dec. 21.
Razvedyvatel’naya svodka № 8 4‑go upravleniya NKVD SSSR [Intelligence Report No. 8 of the 4th Directorate of the NKVD of the USSR]. In Victims.rusarchives [website]. URL: http://victims.rusarchives.ru/razvedyvatelnaya-svodka-no‑8–4‑go-upravleniyankvd-sssr-o-polozhenii-vo-vremenno-okkupirovannykh (accessed: 03.05.2023).
Rebrova, I. V. (2008). “Zhenskaya” povsednevnost’ v problemnom pole istorii Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny [“Women’s” Everyday Life in the Problem Field of the History of the Great Patriotic War]. In Zhenshchina v rossiiskom obshchestve. No. 2 (47), pp. 25–33.
RGASPI [Russian State Archive of Socio-Political History]. Stock 17. List 11. Dos. 490; Stock 69. List 1. Dos. 983, 1047, 2048; Stock 269. List 1. Dos. 353.
Sak, K. V. (2021). Iznasilovaniya na Vostochnom fronte: rassledovanie, prestupniki i ikh zhertvy [Rape on the Eastern Front: Investigation, Perpetrators, and Their Victims]. In Tragediya voiny. Gumanitarnoe izmerenie vooruzhennykh konfliktov XX veka. Moscow, Rossiiskoe voenno-istoricheskoe obshchestvo, Yauza, pp. 128–143.
Sholokhov, M. A. (1942). Nauka nenavisti [Science of Hate]. Moscow, Pravda. 24 p.
Smert’ nemetskim okkupantam! [Death to the German Occupiers!]. (1941). In Izvestiya. No. 304. December 25.
Titarenko, D. N. (2020). Sud’ba infektsionnykh i venericheskikh bol’nykh v period natsistskoi okkupatsii (na primere Ukrainy) [The Fate of Infectious and Venereal Patients during the Nazi Occupation (with Reference to Ukraine)]. In Velikaya Otechestvennaya voina v istorii i pamyati narodov yuga Rossii: sobytiya, uchastniki, simvoly. Rostov-on-Don, Izdatel’stvo Yuzhnogo nauchnogo tsentra RAN, pp. 418–427.
Titarenko, D. N., Penter, T. (Eds.). (2013). Opyt natsistskoi okkupatsii v Donbasse: svidetel’stvuyut ochevidtsy [The Experience of the Nazi Occupation in the Donbass: Eyewitnesses Testify]. Donetsk, Svit knigi. 465 p.
Ul’yanov, P. V. (2019). Obraz Bel’gii kak “zhertvy” v britanskoi propagande perioda Pervoi mirovoi voiny [The Image of Belgium as a “Victim” in British Propaganda during the First World War]. In Izvestiya Altaiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. No. 2 (106), pp. 75–79. DOI 10.14258/izvasu(2019)2–13.
Zhigunov, D. V. (N. d.). Dnevnik [Diary]. In Prozhito [website]. URL: https://prozhito.org/note/439015 (accessed: 03.05.2023).
