Empire after Empire: Military Legacy and the Creation of Nation States
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2024.1.872Keywords:
Russian Empire, imperial legacy, armed forces, revolution of 1917, national elitesAbstract
This article considers the transfer of the military imperial heritage into new hands after 1917, which was especially in demand since this transition took place in an environment of aggravated political, ethnic, and religious conflicts. The most important role in this process was played by the bearers of army practices – soldiers, officers, and generals of various nationalities. A long war was accompanied by a separation of command personnel: military leaders who had not proved their professional worth gave up leadership positions to those who had proved themselves better in leading troops. Breaking the established hierarchical patterns, the turbulence of the revolutionary era allowed many ambitious and talented military leaders to occupy high positions, which was impossible in normal circumstances. The high administrative burden that lay on the generals and officers of the Russian imperial army and the experience of running a military economy prepared them for the role of statesmen in the new states that arose from the ruins of the Russian Empire. Military reserves concentrated in front-line areas made it possible to resolve issues of material support for the national armed forces.
References
Abaza, K. V. (1889). Kratkaya istoriya 7‑go grenaderskogo Samogitskogo generalad” yutanta grafa Totlebena polka. 1788–1817–1833–1888 [Brief History of the 7th Grenadier Samogitian Adjutant General Count Totleben’s Regiment. 1788–1817–1833–1888]. Moscow, Tipografiya tovarishchestva I. N. Kushnerev i K°. 100 p.
Arutyunyan, A. O. (1971). Kavkazskii front 1914–1917 gg. [Caucasian Front. 1914–1917]. Erevan, Aiastan. 415 p.
Asadov, Yu. A. (1999). Armyanskie ofitsery na tsarskoi sluzhbe. Kratkii entsiklopedicheskii spravochnik [Armenian Officers in the Tsar’s Service. A Brief Encyclopaedic Handbook]. Moscow, Inter-vesy. 63 p.
Asadov, Yu. A. (2004). 1000 ofitserskikh imen v armyanskoi istorii. Pyatigorsk: istorichesko-biograficheskie ocherki [1000 Officers’ Names in Armenian History. Pyatigorsk: Historical and Biographical Sketches]. Pyatigorsk, APAKIDRIF. 300 p.
Asadov, Yu. A. (2016). Armyanskii general’skii korpus tsarskoi Rossii. Istoriko-biograficheskie ocherki (1724–1921) [Armenian General Corps of Tsarist Russia. Historical and Biographical Sketches (1724–1921)]. Moscow, Pero. 304 p.
Basilaya, Sh. I. (1968). Zakavkaz’e v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny [Transcaucasia During the First World War] / ed. by M. Sh. Khvartskiya. Sukhumi, Alashara. 363 p.
Borodkin, M. M. (1905). Iz noveishei istorii Finlyandii. Vremya upravleniya N. I. Bobrikova [From the Modern History of Finland. Time of N. I. Bobrikov’s Tenure]. St Petersburg, Tovarishchestvo R. Golike i A. Vil’borg. [12], IV, 482 p.
Borodkin, M. M. (1909). Istoriya Finlyandii. Vremya Aleksandra I [History of Finland. The Time of Alexander I]. St Petersburg, Gosudarstvennaya tipografiya. XXI, [3], 635 p.
Borodkin, M. M. (1910). Finlyandskaya okraina v sostave russkogo gosudarstva [The Finnish Periphery as Part of the Russian State]. 2nd Ed. St Petersburg, Gosudarstvennaya tipografiya. [6], 121 p.
Borodkin, M. M. (1915). Istoriya Finlyandii. Vremya imperatora Nikolaya I [History of Finland. The Time of Emperor Nicholas I]. Petrograd, Gosudarstvennaya tipografiya. XXVI, 716 p.
Derzhavin, A. (1897). Rasskaz unter-ofitsera Apsheronskogo polka Samoily Ryabova o svoei boevoi sluzhbe na Kavkaze [The Story of Non-Commissioned Officer of the Apsheron Regiment Samoyla Ryabov about His Military Service in the Caucasus]. In Kavkazskii sbornik. Vol. 18, pp. 352–381.
Eliseev, F. I. (2001). Kazaki na Kavkazskom fronte. 1914–1917. Zapiski polkovnika Kubanskogo kazach’ego voiska v trinadtsati broshyurakh-tetradyakh [Cossacks on the Caucasian Front. 1914–1917. Notes of the Colonel of the Kuban Cossack Troops in Thirteen Brochures]. Moscow, Voenizdat. 290 p.
Fedorov, E. (1907). Podgotovka Finlyandskoi revolyutsii. 1899–1905 [Preparation of the Finnish Revolution. 1899–1905]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya A. S. Suvorina. 110 p.
“Finlyandskaya armiya” i ee osobennosti. Spravka o sostave, chislennosti i privilegiyakh finskoi armii [“Finnish Army” and Its Features: Information on the Composition, Strength, and Privileges of the Finnish Army]. (1891). In Finlyandskaya okraina Rossii. Sbornik statei, ocherkov, pisem, dokumentov i inykh materialov dlya izucheniya tak nazyvaemogo Finlyandskogo voprosa. Iss. 1. Moscow, Universitetskaya tipografiya. XXII, 635 p.
Fotokhronograf. Istoriya v fotografiyakh – goroda i strany, sobytiya i lyudi. Gruzinskaya demokraticheskaya respublika 1918–1921 [Photochronograph. History in Photographs: Cities and Countries, Events and People. The Democratic Republic of Georgia 1918–1921]. In Fotokhronograf. [website]. URL: https://photochronograph.ru/2017/12/04/gruzinskaya-demokraticheskaya-respublika‑1918–1921/ (accessed: 09.02.2024).
Kamenskii, N. (1908). Sovremennoe polozhenie Finlyandii s tochki zreniya oborony gosudarstva. K finlyandskomu voprosu v Gosudarstvennoi Dume [The Present Situation of Finland from the Point of View of the Defence of the State. The Finnish Question in the State Duma]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Glavnogo upravleniya udelov. 65 p.
Klinge, M. (2005). Imperskaya Finlyandiya [Imperial Finland]. St Petersburg, Kolo. 614 p.
Kovalevskii, V. A. (1910). Komandirovka diviziona leib-dragun v Finlyandiyu v Vil’manstrand v lager’ finskikh voisk v 1888 godu [Command of the Lifeguard Division in Finland to Vilmanstrand to the Finnish Troops Camp in 1888]. In Russkaya starina. No. 7, pp. 65–82.
Kudryavtseva, L. (2004). Bor’ba za “mesto pamyati” v imperii: istoriya pamyatnika osnovatelyu Vyborga Torgil’su Knutssonu [Struggle for a “Place of Memory” in the Empire: The History of the Monument to Vyborg’s Founder Torgils Knutsson]. In Ab Imperio. No. 2, pp. 417–447. DOI 10.1353/imp.2004.0029.
Kuropatkin, A. N. (1910). Zadachi russkoi armii v 3 t. [Tasks of the Russian Аrmy. 3 Vols.]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya V. Bezobrazov i Co. Vol. 1. Zadachi armii po ob”edineniyu russkogo plemeni i vykhodu k moryam: Kaspiiskomu, Baltiiskomu i Chernomu. 593 p.
Laidinen, A. P. (1972). Ocherki istorii Finlyandii vtoroi poloviny ХVIII veka [Sketches of the History of Finland in the Second Half of the 18th Century]. Leningrad, Nauka. 160 p.
Makhlayuk, N. P. (1900). Boevaya letopis’ 14‑go Grenaderskogo Gruzinskogo generala Kotlyarevskogo polka. Vtoroe stoletie 1800–1900 [Battle Chronicle of the 14th Grenadier Georgian General Kotlyarevsky’s Regiment. Second Century 1800–1900]. Tiflis, Izdano 14‑m Grenaderskim Gruzinskim polkom pri sodeistvii Voennno-istoricheskogo otdeleniya
Shtaba Kavkazskogo voennogo okruga. [2], IV, [2], 412, [4], 46, [6] p.
Moskovskie vedomosti [Moskovskie Vedomosti]. (1890). No. 252. 10 October.
Orlov, G. (1908). Finlyandskie pamyatniki vragam Rossii [Finnish Monuments to Russia’s Enemies]. In Novoe vremya. 19 October. No. 11712.
Osherov, E. B. Suni, L. V. (1986). Finliandskaya politika tsarizma na rubezhe XIX–XX vv. [Finnish Policy of Tsarism at the Turn of the 20th Century]. Petrozavodsk, Izdatel’stvo Petrozavodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 71 p.
PSZ [The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire]. Collection 2. Vol. 25, 29, 30, 38.
RGA VMF [Russian State Archive of the Naval Fleet]. Stock 410. List. 3. Dos. 608.
RGIA [Russian State Historical Archive]. Stock 1268. List 8. Dos. 216.
RGVIA [Russian State Military History Archive]. Stock 409. List 1. Dos. 45989.
Screen, J. E. O. (1986). The Helsinki Yunker School 1846–1879. A Case Study of Officer Training in the Russian Army. Helsinki, SHS. 320 p.
Spisok polkovnikam po starshinstvu na 1 marta 1913 [List of Colonels by Seniority as of 1 March 1913]. (1913). St Petersburg, Voennaya tipografiya. 1621 p.
Stackelberg, K. K. (1881). Poltora veka konnoi gvardii. 1739–1880: Izlozhenie dlya nizhnikh chinov Konnoi leib-gvardii polka polkovnika barona K. Shtakel’berg [One and a Half Century of the Horse Guards. 1739–1880. Outline for the Lower Ranks of the Horse Lifeguards Regiment Colonel Baron K. Stackelberg]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya V. F. Demakova. [2], VI, 232, 38 p.
Tinchenko, Ya. (2007). Ofitserskii korpus armii Ukrainskoi Narodnoi Respubliki [Officer Corps of the Army of the Ukrainian People’s Republic]. Kiev, Tempora. 535 p.
Weimarn, F. (1884). Finskie voiska [Finnish Troops]. In Voennyi sbornik. No. 3, pp. 23–31.
