The USSR as a “Great Power”: Imperial Narratives and the State’s Status, 1920–1935
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2023.3.833Keywords:
international relations, Soviet foreign policy, USSR in the 1920s–1930s, conceptual history, great powerAbstract
This article analyses the adaptation and re-semantisation of the “great power” concept in Soviet public discourse between 1920 and 1935. The actualisation of the “great power” concept in the public discourse of this period was associated with the need to comprehend the USSR in the system of international relations, the one of “great powers”. After the First World War and the revolutionary events of the early twentieth century, Russia was excluded from the European system of international relations, and the USSR had to fight for the recognition of the new state formation. Simultaneously, the new authorities had to defend their positions within the country. In addition, the new state was in a complex relationship with the legacy of the Russian Empire. Denying numerous imperial attitudes at the ideological level, the USSR had to deal with old institutions, including the diplomatic and authoritative language of Imperial Russia. At the same time, new goals required revision of inconvenient intellectual constructs. The author aims to establish how the “great power” concept was rethought and appropriated by the Bolsheviks and the Soviet authorities after the 1917 Revolution and the Civil War (1917–1922). The author identifies several main stages of rethinking the concept in public discourse and, based on an analysis of the press, proves that the “great power” concept was only partially resemanticised. It acquired new semantic connotations (primarily ideological) while retaining a significant part of the previous pre-revolutionary attitudes. The author reveals that from the early 1920s, there were attempts to assign the “great power” status to Soviet Russia. During this period, the great-power narrative was re-actualised and stabilised. The main factor confirming the “great power” status is the country’s internal successes.
References
Adomeit, H. (1995). Russia as a ‘Great Power’ in World Affairs: Images and Reality. In Intern. Affairs. Vol. 71. No. 1, pp. 35–68.
Anisimov, M. Yu. (2020). Rossiya v sisteme velikikh derzhav v tsarstvovanie Elizavety Petrovny (1741–1761 gg.) [Russia in the Great Power System of During the Reign of Elizaveta Petrovna (1741–1761)]. Moscow, Tovarishchestvo nauchnykh izdanii KMK. 457 p.
Ashukin, N. S., Ashukina, M. G. (1955). Krylatye slova: literaturnye tsitaty, obraznye vyrazheniya [Catchphrases: Literary Quotes, Figurative Expressions]. Moscow, Khudozhestvennaya literatura. 665 p.
Bor’ba bol’shevikov za sozdanie Kommunisticheskogo Internatsionala. Materialy i dokumenty 1914–1919 gg. [The Struggle of the Bolsheviks for the Creation of the Communist International. Materials and Documents, 1914–1919]. (1934). Moscow, Partiinoe izdatel’stvo. 260 p.
Brooks, J. (2000). Thank You, Comrade Stalin! Soviet Public Culture from Revolution to Cold War. Princeton, Princeton Univ. Press. 344 p.
Bystrova, N. E. (2016). “Russkii vopros” v 1917 – nachale 1920 g.: Sovetskaya Rossiya i velikie derzhavy. [“Russian Question” in 1917 – Early 1920s: Soviet Russia and the Great Powers]. Moscow, St Petersburg, Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ. 368 p.
Dullin, S. (2011). Logika velikoi derzhavy i lovushki proshlogo: stalinskaya vneshnyaya politika epokhi pervoi pyatiletki [Great Power Logic and Past Traps: Stalin’s Foreign Policy of the First Five-Year Plan]. In Istoriya stalinizma: itogi i problemy izucheniya. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, Moskva, 5–7 dekabrya 2008 g. Moscow, ROSSPEN, pp. 236–255.
Istorik-marksist [Istorik-Marksist]. (1926). No. 2; (1928). No. 10; (1930). No. 17.
Izvestiya [Izvestiya]. (1917). 19 Nov.; (1919). 3 June; (1920). 27 June; 10 Sept.; (1921). 30 June; 17 July; 8 Oct.; 11 Nov.; 24, 28 Dec.; (1922). 1 Jan.; (1924). 2 Feb.
Kennedy, P. (1987). The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers: Economic Change and Military Conflict from 1500 to 2000. N. Y., Random House. 677 p.
Khlevnyuk, O. V., Devis, R. U., Kosheleva, L. P., Ris, E. A., Rogovaya, L. A. (Eds.). (2001). Stalin i Kaganovich. Perepiska. 1931–1936 gg. [Stalin and Kaganovich. Correspondence. 1931–1936]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 798 p.
Knorin, V. (Ed.). (1932). Poslevoennyi kapitalizm v osveshchenii Kominterna. Sbornik dokumentov i rezolyutsii kongressov i ispolkomov Kominterna [Postwar Capitalism in the Coverage of the Comintern. Collection of Documents and Resolutions of the Congresses and Executive Committees of the Comintern]. Moscow, Partiinoe izdatel’stvo. 180 p.
Kommunisticheskii Internatsional v dokumentakh. Resheniya, tezisy i vozzvaniya kongressov Kominterna i plenumov IKKI, 1919–1932. [Communist International in Documents. Decisions, Theses, and Appeals of the Congresses of the Comintern and Plenums of the ECCI, 1919–1932]. (1933). Moscow, Partiinoe izdatel’stvo. 1007 p.
Koselleck, R. (1996). A Response. In Lehmann, H., Richter, M. (Eds.). The Meaning of Historical Terms and Concepts: New Studies on Begriffsgeschichte. Washington DC, German Historical Inst., pp. 59–70.
Koselleck, R. (2014). Vvedenie [Introduction]. In Zaretskii, Yu., Levinson, K., Shirle, I. (Eds.). Slovar’ osnovnykh istoricheskikh ponyatii. Izbrannye stat’i v 2 t. / transl. by K. Levinson, ed. by Yu. Arnautova. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. Vol. 1, pp. 23–44.
Krest’yanskaya revolyutsiya na yuge Rossii: s pis’mami L. N. Tolstogo tsaryu [Peasant Revolution in the South of Russia: With Letters from L. N. Tolstoy to the Tsar]. (1902). Berlin, Izdanie Ioanna Rede. 66 p.
Lenin, V. I. (1944). O natsional’noi gordosti velikorossov [On the National Pride of the Great Russians]. Moscow, OGIZ, Gospolitizdat. 7 p.
Lenin, V. I. (1958–1983). Polnoe sobranie sochinenii v 55 t. [Complete Works. 55 Vols.]. 5th Ed. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo politicheskoi literatury.
Liprandi, A. P. (1914). Evreistvo i antisemitizm [Jewishness and Anti-Semitism]. In Mirnyi trud. Kharkov, Tipografiya “Mirnyi trud”. 276 p.
Martin, T. (2011). Imperiya polozhitel’noi deyatel’nosti. Natsii i natsionalizm v SSSR, 1923–1939. [The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 855 p.
Neumann, I. (2008). Russia as a Great Power, 1815–2007. In J. of Intern. Relations and Development. No. 11, pp. 128–151.
Nikiforov, L. A. (1950). Russko-angliiskie otnosheniya pri Petre I [Russian-English Relations under Peter I]. Moscow, Gospolitizdat. 282 p.
Niva [Niva]. (1893). No. 10; (1896). No. 20; (1904). No. 13; (1909). No. 25; (1914). No. 21.
Odinnadtsatyi s”ezd RKP(b). Mai–aprel’ 1922 g. Protokoly [Eleventh Congress of the RCP(b). May–April 1922. Minutes]. (1936). Moscow, Partizdat. 840 p.
Ogonek [Ogonek]. (1923). No. 8, 32; (1925). No. 5; (1930). No. 3.
Pravda [Pravda]. (1912). 10, 12, 20 Oct.; (1913). 23 Feb.; (1920). 22 Jan.; 25 June; 23 July; (1922). 9 Nov.; (1924). 4 Nov.; (1927). 27 Oct.; (1929). 23, 24 July; (1930). 17 Feb.; (1934). 29 Oct.; (1935). 1 May; 17 Nov.
Pravda truda [Pravda Truda]. (1913). 27 Sept.
Rabochii [Rabochii]. (1917). 9 Sept.
Rich, P. B. (2009). Russia as a Great Power. In Small Wars & Insurgencies. Vol. 20. No. 2, pp. 276–299.
Russkoe bogatstvo. Literaturnyi, nauchnyi i politicheskii zhurnal [Russkoe Bogatstvo. Literary, Scientific, and Political Journal]. (1903). No. 7.
Sborniki dokumentov po mezhdunarodnoi politike i mezhdunarodnomu pravu. Vyp. 9. Sovetsko-amerikanskie otnosheniya, 1919–1933. [Collections of Documents on International Politics and International Law. Iss. 9. Soviet-American Relations, 1919–1933]. (1934). Moscow, Narodnyi komissariat inostrannykh del.
Scott, H. M. (2007). The Emergence of the Eastern Powers, 1756–1775. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 308 p.
Sevost’yanov, G. N. (Ed.). (2011). Moskva – Berlin: politika i diplomatiya Kremlya, 1920–1941. Sbornik dokumentov v 3 t. [Moscow – Berlin: Kremlin Politics and Diplomacy, 1920–1941. Collection of Documents. 3 Vols.]. Moscow, Nauka. Vol. 1. 1920–1926. 1031 p.
Stalin, I. V. (1923). Organizatsionnyi otchet Tsentral’nogo Komiteta RKP(b) XII s”ezdu RKP(b). 17 aprelya 1923 g. [Organisational Report of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) to the 12th Congress of the RCP(b). April 17, 1923]. In Dvenadtsatyi s”ezd Rossiiskoi kommunisticheskoi partii (bol’shevikov). Stenograficheskii otchet. Moscow, Krasnaya nov’. 705 p.
Stalin, I. V. (1946–1951). Sochineniya v 13 t. [Works. 13 Vols.]. Moscow, OGIZ, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoi literatury.
Vdovin, A. I. (2018). SSSR. Istoriya velikoi derzhavy. 1922–1991 [The USSR. The History of a Great Power. 1922–1991]. Moscow, Prospekt. 786 p.
Vestnik Evropy [Vestnik Evropy]. (1871). March.
Voennyi vestnik [Voennyi Vestnik]. (1933). No. 11.
Voina i revolyutsiya [Voina i Revolyutsiya]. (1930). No. 6.
Vysochaishii manifest o voine s Ottomanskoyu Portoi ot 20 oktyabrya 1853 g. [Imperial Manifesto on the War with the Ottoman Porte. October 20, 1853]. (1855). In Khronika sovremennykh voennykh izvestii. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Glavnogo shtaba Ego Imperatorskogo Velichestva po voenno-uchebnym zavedeniyam, pp. 18–19.
XIV s”ezd Vsesoyuznoi Kommunisticheskoi partii (b). Dekabr’ 1925 goda. Stenograficheskii otchet [XIV Congress of the All-Union Communist Party (b). December 1925. Verbatim Report]. (1926). Moscow, Gosizdat. 1032 p.
Zinov’ev, G. E. (1926). Sochineniya v 16 t. [Works. 16 Vols.]. Leningrad, Gosizdat. Vol. 8. Voina i krizis sotsializma. 691 p.
