“A Territory of Threat”: The Banning of the Herrnhut Communities in Livonia and Local Society in 1743
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2023.3.822Keywords:
Herrnhut Brethren, Russian Empire in the 18th century, Nikolaus Ludwig von Zinzendorf, Erdmuthe Dorothea von Zinzendorf, Livonia, Ösel, commissions, LandtagAbstract
This article analyses the decree issued by Empress Elizaveta Petrovna on April 16, 1743, the first in the Russian Empire and targeting the Herrnhut Brethren Community. It has been mentioned in historiography but quoted from secondary sources and interpreted as a decree directed against the missionaries, even though J. Eckardt (1876) and, recently, O. Teigeler (2006) put it in the context of the history of the Herrnhut communities in Livonia. The author analyses the content and implementation of the decree of 1743 in the context of the development of the Herrnhut communities in Livonia, including the island of Ösel, in the 1720s–1730s. The documents of the investigative case against the Herrnhut communities preserved in the fund of the Secret Chancellery (RGADA) and partly copied in the investigation dossier compiled by the College of Justice for Livonia, Estland, and Finland and kept in the fund of the College of Foreign Affairs in AVPRI, reveal that by 1743, the St Petersburg authorities did not consider the sermon of the Herrnhut to threaten them or Orthodoxy, nor did they have any idea of the doctrine itself. First, the decree ordered that Countess von Zinzendorf be caught, as the purpose of her stay in St Petersburg in 1743 was unclear. Further, the decree of 1743 was not intended against the few missionaries settled in St Petersburg who were striving to reach Asia through the Russian Empire. The correspondence between Chancellor A. P. Bestuzhev-Rumin and I. A. Cherkasov, Cabinet Minister of Empress Elizaveta Petrovna, reveals that the action taken on the community in 1743 was largely prompted by the foreign policy circumstances. The main threat to the central government was the commissions set up a year earlier by local noble elected bodies, i. e. the Landtags and the Ober-Consistory, to investigate the activities of the Herrnhut communities in Livonia. The activities of the Baltic nobility carried out independently of the imperial centre aroused the gravest suspicions because its specific rights and privileges, though confirmed by the Peace of Nystadt, were kept vague for the St Petersburg authorities by the 1740s. The local nobility, dramatically involved in the activities of the Herrnhut communities in the 1720s–1740s, found themselves in a difficult position, torn between their adherence to the doctrine and the need to remain loyal to the St Petersburg authorities, fulfilling the requirements of the personal decree of 1743.
References
Andreeva, N. S. (2008). Pribaltiiskie nemtsy i rossiiskaya pravitel’stvennaya politika v nachale XX veka [Baltic Germans and the Russian Governmental Policy in the Early 20th Century]. St Petersburg, Mir. 309 p.
AVPRI [Archive of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Empire]. Stock 10. List 10/1. Dos. 1. 1743–1744.
Babich, M. V. (2003). Gosudarstvennye uchrezhdeniya XVIII veka: Komissiya petrovskogo vremeni [The State Institutions of the 18th Century: The Petrine Commission]. Moscow, ROSSPEN, 477 p.
Babich, M. V. (2007). Petrovskaya i anninskaya administratsiya skvoz’ prizmu personala tsentral’nykh komissii [The Petrine and Annine Administrations through the Prism of the Staff of the Central Commissions]. In Trudy Ermitazha. Sbornik statei. Iss. 38. Petrovskoe vremya v litsakh – 2007. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha, pp. 29–36.
Cherkasov, I. A. (2007). Pis’ma barona Ivana Antonovicha Cherkasova vitse-kantsleru Alekseyu Petrovichu Bestuzhevu-Ryuminu (1743–1747) [Letters from Baron Ivan Antonovich Cherkasov to Vice-Chancellor Alexei Petrovich Bestuzhev-Rumin (1743–1747)]. In Rossiiskii Arkhiv. Istoriya Otechestva v svidetel’stvakh i dokumentakh XVIII–XX vv. Iss. 16. Moscow, Studiya “TRITE”, pp. 9–60.
Eckardt, J. (1876). Livland im achtzehnten Jahrhundert Umrisse zu einer livländischen Geschichte. Leipzig, A. Brockhaus. 595 S.
Fundaminskii, M. I. (2004). Kommunikatsionnaya set’ gall’skikh pietistov v Rossii [The Halle Pietist Communication Network in Russia]. In Inoslavnye tserkvi v Sankt-Peterburge. Doklady kongressa, 8–10 oktyabrya 2003 g. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Sankt-Peterburskogo universiteta, pp. 57–61.
Gerasimov, I., Glebov, S., Mogil’ner, M. (Eds.). (2017). Novaya imperskaya istoriya Severnoi Evrazii [A New Imperial History of Northern Eurasia]. Kazan, Ab Imperio. 628 p.
Hagen, M. von. (2004). Imperii, okrainy i diaspory: Evraziya kak antiparadigma [Empires, Peripheries, and Diasporas: Eurasia as an Anti-Paradigm]. In Novaya imperskaya istoriya postsovetskogo prostranstva. Kazan, Tsentr issledovanii natsionalizma i imperii, pp. 127–162.
Hoffmann, C. G. (1748–1749). Sammlung von einigen wider die Herrnhuther ergangenen hohen Kayserlichen, Königlichen, Chur- und Fürstlichen, Reichsstädtischen, und andern Befehlen und Verordnungen. Bände 1–2. Wittenberg, Zerbst, Verlegts Samuel Gottfried Zimmermann.
Kapitulyatsiya s pastorom i prepodavatelem latinskogo yazyka Tobiasom Plichnikom [The Service Contract with Pastor and Latin Teacher Tobias Plashnig]. (2015). In Fedyukin, I., Lavrinovich, M. (Eds.). “Regulyarnaya akademiya uchrezhdena budet…“. Obrazovatel‘nye proekty v Rossii v pervoi polovine XVIII veka. Moscow, Novoe izdatel‘stvo, pp. 297–298.
Keller, M. (Hrsg.). (1987). Russen und Russland aus deutscher Sicht. Bd. 2. 18. Jahrhundert. Aufklärung. München, Fink. 682 S.
Lenz, W., Welding, O., Amburger, E., Krusenstjern, G. von. (Hrsg.). (1970). Deutschbaltisches Biographisches Lexikon 1710–1960. Köln, Wien, Böhlau. In Baltisches biografisches Lexikon digital (2012–) [website]. URL: https://bbld.de/ (accessed: 20.08.2023).
Mettele, G. (2010). Identities Across Borders: The Moravian Brethren as a Global Community. In Strom, J. (Ed.). Pietism and Community in Europe and North America, 1650–1850. Leiden, Boston, Brill, pp. 155–177.
Meyer, D. (2000). Zinzendorf und die Herrnhuter Brüdergemeine: 1700–2000. Göttingen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprechtю 175 S.
Peucker, P. (2010). Pink, White, and Blue: Function and Meaning of the Colored Choir Ribbons with the Moravians. In Strom, J. (Ed.). Pietism and Community in Europe and North America, 1650–1850. Leiden, Boston, Brill, pp. 179–197.
Pisarenko, K. A. (2010). Vstupitel’nya stat’ya. Pamyatnaya zapiska o zavershenii avstro-russkogo konflikta iz-za dela markiza Botty, 1744 g. [Introduction. A Memorandum on the Completion of the Austro-Russian Conflict Induced by the Marquis de Botta Case, 1744.]. In Rossiiskii Arkhiv. Istoriya Otechestva v svidetel’stvakh i dokumentakh XVIII–XX vv. Iss. 19. Moscow, Studiya “TRITE”, pp. 9–18.
RGADA [Russian State Archive of Ancient Acts]. Stock 7. List 1. Dos. 1195. Parts 1–2.
Rieber, A. (2004). Menyayushchiesya kontseptsii i konstruktsii frontira: sravnitel’noistoricheskii podkhod [The Changing Notions and Constructions of the Frontier: A Comparative-Historical Approach]. In Novaya imperskaya istoriya postsovetskogo prostranstva. Kazan, Tsentr issledovanii natsionalizma i imperii, pp. 199–222.
Rjeoutski, V., Gouzevitch, D. (Eds.). (2019). Inostrannye spetsialisty v Rossii v epokhu Petra Velikogo. Biograficheskii slovar’ vykhodtsev iz Frantsii, Vallonii, frankoyazychnykh Shveitsarii i Savoii: 1682–1727 [Foreign Specialists in Russia during the Epoch of Peter the Great. A Biographical Dictionary of Nationals of France, Wallonia, French-Speaking Switzerland, and Savoy: 1682–1727]. Moscow, Lomonosov”. 798 p.
Romanovich-Slavatinskii, A. V. (1912). Dvoryanstvo v Rossii ot nachala XVIII veka do otmeny krepostnogo prava: svod materialov i priugotovitel’nye etyudy dlya istoricheskogo issledovaniya [The Nobility in Russia from the Early 18th Century to the Abolition of Serfdom: A Collection of Materials and Preparatory Sketches for a Historical Study]. Kiev, Pechatnya S. P. Yakovleva. 578 p.
Ryazhev, A. S. (2016). Missionerskaya rabota pietistov i gernguterov v pervoi polovine XVIII v.: plany v otnoshenii rossiiskogo buddizma [The Missionary Work of Pietists and Herrnhut Brethren in the First Half of the 18th Century: Some Plans Concerning Russian Buddhism]. In Velikie evraziiskie migratsii. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, 11–14 oktyabrya 2016 g. Elista, Izdatel’stvo Kalmytskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, pp. 407–414.
Teigeler, O. (2006). Die Herrnhuter in Russland: Ziel, Umfang und Ertrag ihrer Aktivitäten. Göttingen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. 726 S.
Winter, E. (1953). Halle als Ausgangspunkt der deutschen Russlandkunde im 18. Jahrhundert. Berlin, Akademie Verlag. 502 S.
Wirtschafter, E. (2013). Religion and Enlightenment in Russia. The Teachings of Metropolitan Platon. DeKalb, NIU Press. 200 p.
Zutis, Ya. Ya. (1946). Ostzeiskii vopros v XVIII veke [The Baltic Question in the 18th Century]. Riga, Knigoizdatel’stvo i tipogrfiya No. 2 VAP. 649 p.
