“Her Language Must Be the Language of Figures”. Medical Statistics of the Russian Empire and the Kingdom of Prussia: A Comparative Perspective
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2023.2.801Keywords:
medical statistics, biopolitics, Russian Empire, Kingdom of Prussia, L. Krug, K. Arsen’evAbstract
This article examines the history of the establishment of departmental medical statistics in the Russian Empire and the Kingdom of Prussia in the first half of the nineteenth century. Starting from M. Foucault’s concepts of biopolitics and governmentality, historians have studied the medical and statistical mechanisms for representing “public health” in England, France, and other West European countries in some detail. The case of the Russian Empire remains unexplored in this respect. Researchers have predominantly turned to hygienic statistics and data on mortality and fertility in Russian cities of the late imperial period, while the early period has long remained untouched. Moreover, these data have been analyzed apart from the transnational context of their creation. This article seeks to fill this gap partially. By comparing the introduction of two key medico-statistical indicators in Prussia and Russia (the nomenclature of diseases and the indicator of causes of death by disease), it has been argued that the Russian authorities, in their governing practices, followed mainly the Prussian path. In addition, both countries came to the same statistical model of representing the “public health” of the nation/empire. However, in the case of the Russian Empire, this transition was stretched over many decades and was carried out haphazardly. The article analyzes the main causes of this uneven implementation. In conclusion, it discusses the advantages and disadvantages of each country’s medical and statistical models.
References
Arsen’ev, K. I. (1835). Plan zanyatii statisticheskogo otdeleniya Soveta Ministerstva vnutrennikh del [Plan of Studies of the Statistical Department of the Council of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. St Petersburg, S. n. 37 p.
Arsen’ev, K. I. (Eds.). (1839). Materialy dlya statistiki Rossiiskoi imperii, izdavaemye s vysochaishego soizvoleniya pri Statisticheskom otdelenii Soveta Ministerstva vnutrennikh del v 2 ch. [Materials for Statistics of the Russian Empire Published with the Highest Permission of the Statistical Division of the Council of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. 2 Parts]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Ministerstva vnutrennikh del. Part 1. 690 p.
Boeckh, R. (1861). Die Bearbeitung von Kreisstatistiken durch die königlichen Landräthe in Folge des Ministerialrescripts vom 11. April 1859. In Zeitschrift des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. No. 12, S. 307–320.
Boeckh, R. (1863). Die geschichtliche Entwicklung der amtlichen Statistik des Preußischen Staates. Berlin, R. Decker. 105 S.
Eliseeva, I. I., Dmitriev, A. L. (2016). Ocherki po istorii gosudarstvennoi statistiki Rossii [Essays on the History of State Statistics of Russia]. St Petersburg, Rostok. 288 p.
Engel, E. (1860). Zur Geschichte des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. Eine Erinnerungsfeier seiner Errichtung. In Zeitschrift des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. No. 1, S. 3–8.
Engel, E. (1861). Die Sterblichkeit und die Lebenserwartung im preußischen Staate und besonders in Berlin. 1. Hauptabschnitt und II. Hauptabschnitt 1–3. In Zeitschrift des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. No. 13, 14, 15, pp. 321–352.
Engel, E. (1862a). Die Sterblichkeit und die Lebenserwartung im preußischen Staate und besonders in Berlin. Fortsetzung. I. 4. Die Absterbeordnung und die Lebenserwartung. I. 5. Die Sterbefälle in der Zeit von 1816 bis 1860 nach den Todesursachen. In Zeitschrift des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. No. 3, S. 50–68.
Engel, E. (1862b). Die Sterblichkeit und die Lebenserwartung im preußischen Staate und besonders in Berlin, Schluss. In Zeitschrift des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. No. 10, S. 217–243.
Engel, E. (1862c). Über die neuesten Fortschritte in der Organisation der amtlichen Statistik in Preußen. In Zeitschrift des königlich preußischen statistischen Bureaus. No. 7, 8. S. 161–176.
Engel, E. (1879). Katalog der Bibliothek des Königlichen Statistischen Bureaus zu Berlin. Berlin, Verlag des Königlichen Statistischen Bureaus. Abt. 2. 732 S.
Espagne, M. (1994). Sur les limites du comparatisme en histoire culturelle. In Genèses, 17, 1994. Les objets et les choses, sous la direction de Francine Soubiran-Paillet, pp. 112–121. DOI 10.3406/genes.1994.1266.
Espagne, M. (2018). Istoriya tsivilizatsii kak kul’turnyi transfer [History of Civilizations as a Cultural Transfer]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 816 p.
Foucault, M. (2009). Security, Territory, Population. Lectures at the Collège de France, 1977–78. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan. 464 p.
Fournier, P. (2009). Épidémies et médicalisation des territoires ruraux (vers 1770 – vers 1830). In Siècles. Vol. 30, pp. 61–83. DOI 10.4000/siecles.136.
Gatina, Z. (2017). Vrachebnaya ekspertiza v sisteme upravleniya Rossiiskoi imperii pervoi poloviny XIX veka [Medical Expertise in the System of Government of the Russian Empire in the First Half of the 19th Century]. Dis. … kand. ist. nauk Moscow, S. n. 240 p.
Greenwood, M. (1942). Medical Statistics from Graunt to Farr. In Biometrika Vol. 32. No. 3/4, pp. 203–225. DOI 10.2307/2332126.
Hacking, I. (1991). How Should We Do the History of Statistics? In Burchell, G., Gordon, C., Miller, P. (Eds.). The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality with Two Lectures by and an Interview with Michel Foucault. Chicago, Univ. of Chicago Press, pp. 181–196.
Herzen, A. (1973). My Past and Thoughts: The Memoirs of Alexander Herzen / transl. by C. Garnett. Berkeley, Univ. of California Press. 684 p.
Holquist, P. (2001). To Count, to Extract, to Exterminate: Population Statistics and Population Politics in Late Imperial and Soviet Russia. In Martin, T., Suny, R., (Eds.). A State of Nations: Empire and Nation-Making in the Age of Lenin and Stalin. N. Y., Oxford Univ. Press, pp. 111–144.
Jepson, W. E. (2004). Of Soil, Situation, and Salubrity: Medical Topography and Medical Officers in Early Nineteenth-Century British India. In Historical Geography. Vol. 32, pp. 137–155.
Krafft, W. L. (1782). Essai sur les Tables des mariages, des noissances, O’ des morts de la Ville de St Petersbourg, dans le période de 17 ans, debuis 1764 jusqu’à 1780. In Acta Academiae Scientiarum Imperialis Petropolitanae, Pars Prior, pp. 3–66.
Markovin, A. P. (1993). Razvitie meditsinskoi geografii v Rossii [The Development of Medical Geography in Russia]. St Petersburg, Nauka. 176 p.
Markuzon, F. D. (1955). Sanitarnaya statistika v gorodakh predrevolyutsionnoi Rossii [Sanitary Statistics in the Cities of Prerevolutionary Russia]. In Ptukha, M. V. (Ed.). Ocherki po istorii statistiki SSSR. Sbornik statei. Moscow, Gosstatizdat, pp. 121–162.
Merkov, A. M. (Ed.). (1966). Ocherki istorii otechestvennoi sanitarnoi statistiki [Essays on the History of Russian Sanitary Statistics]. Moscow, Meditsina. 286 p.
Morrissey, S. (2007). Suicide and the Body Politic in Imperial Russia. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 384 p.
Niemeyer, P. (1861). Bericht über den Volksgesundheits-Zustand und die Wirksamkeit der Civil Hospitäler im russischen Kaiserreiche für das J. 1858. In Jahrbücher der in-und ausländischen gesamten Medizin. Bd. 109. No. 3, pp. 360–362.
Otsolig, F. M. (Ed.). (1859). Otchet o sostoyanii obshchestvennogo zdraviya i deyatel’nosti bol’nits grazhdanskogo vedomstva v imperii za 1857 god [Report about the State of Public Health and the Activities of Departmental Hospitals in the Empire for the Year 1857]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Biblioteki meditsinskikh nauk doktora M. Khana. 358 p.
Porter, T. M. (1986). The Rise of Statistical Thinking 1820–1900. Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton Univ. Press. 360 p.
PSZ [Complete Collection of the Laws of the Russian Empire]. Coll. 1. Vol. 16; Coll. 2. Vol. 7, 9, 17.
Ptukha, M. V. (1959). Ocherki po istorii statistiki v SSSR v 2 t. [Essays on the History of Statistics in the USSR. 2 Vols.]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. Vol. 1. 239 p. Vol. 2. 476 p.
Review. General Principles of Medical Statistics, or a Development of the Rules Which Ought to Preside over the Use of Numbers in Medical Investigations. (1841). In The British and Foreign Medical Review. Vol. 12. No. 23, pp. 1–21.
RGIA [Russian State Historical Archive]. Stock 733. List 195. Dos. 61; Stock 1286. List 2. Dos. 168; Stock 1290. List 4. Dos. 16; Stock 1294. List 1. Dos. 2, 9; List 1SV. Dos. 36; Stock 1299. List 1. Dos. 265; List 13. Dos. 1184; Stock 1405. List 532. Dos. 607.
Rosser Matthews, J. (1995). Quantification and the Quest for Medical Certainty. Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton Univ. Press. 195 p.
Schlözer, A. L. (1768). Von der Unschädlichkeit der Pocken in Rußland und von Rußlands Bevölkerung überhaupt. Göttingen, J. C. Dieterich. 152 S.
Schlözer, A. L. (1802). August Ludwig Schlözer‘s öffentliches und privat-Leben, von ihm selbst beschrieben. Göttingen, V& R. 308 S.
Smith-Peter, S. (2005). Russkaya statistika pervoi poloviny XIX v. v obshcheevropeiskom kontekste [Russian Statistics of the First Half of the 19th Century in the European Context]. In Voprosy istorii, estestvoznaniya i tekhniki. No. 4, pp. 125–136.
Smith-Peter, S. (2007). Defining the Russian People: Konstantin Arsen’ev and Russian Statistics before 1861. In History of Science. Vol. 45. No. 1, pp. 47–64. DOI 10.1177/00732753070450010.
Stanziani, A. (2017). European Statistics, Russian Numbers, and Social Dynamics, 1861–1914. In Slavic Rev. Vol. 76. No. 1, pp. 1–23. DOI 10.1017/slr.2017.3.
Teare, S. W., Gino, M. C. (2007). Wargentin, Pehr Wilhelm. In Hockey, T. et al. (Eds.). The Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers. N. Y., Springer, pp. 2292–2293. DOI 10.1007/978–0–387–30400–7_1446.
Varadinov, N. V. (1862). Istoriya Ministerstva vnutrennikh del v 3 ch. [History of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. 3 Vols.]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Ministerstva vnutrennikh del. Vol. 2. Book 2. 604 p.
Vishlenkova, E. (2011). “Vypolnyaya vrachebnye obyazannosti, ya postig dukh narodnyi”: samosoznanie vracha kak prosvetitelya gosudarstva (Rossiya, Pervaya polovina XIX veka) [“In Carrying Out Medical Duties, I Understood the People’s Spirit”: Self-Awareness of a Physician as an Educator of the Russian State (First Half of the 19th Century)]. In Ab Imperio. No. 2, pp. 47–79. DOI 10.1353/imp.2011.0049.
Vishlenkova, E. A., Zatravkin, S. N. (2021). Meditsinskaya statistika i karty [Medical Statistics and Maps]. In Vishlenkova, E. A., Renner, A. (Eds.). Istoriya meditsiny i meditsinskoi geografii v Rossiiskoi imperii. Moscow, Shiko, pp. 216–254.
Werner, M., Zimmermann, B. (2006). Beyond Comparison: Histoire Croisée and the Challenge of Reflexivity. In History and Theory. Vol. 45. No. 1, pp. 30–50. DOI 10.1111/j.1468–2303.2006.00347.x.
Woolf, S. (1989). Statistics and the Modern State. In Comparative Studies in Society and History. Vol. 31. No. 3, pp. 588–604. DOI 10.1017/S0010417500016054.
Zhuravskii, D. P. (1846). Ob istochnikakh i upotreblenii statisticheskikh svedenii [On the Sources and Use of Statistical Data]. Kiev, Tipografiya Val’nera. 210 p.
