Deviations of the Politics of Memory in Eastern Europe and in the Post-Soviet Space

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2021.3.627

Keywords:

World War II, Eastern Europe, post-Soviet space, politics of memory, confrontation

Abstract

The narratives of the Second World War, which may undoubtedly be referred to as “complex issues of history”, have not been entirely reflected upon yet and therefore are full of phobias and myths. While analysing the set of tools of the politics of memory, the author of this article points outs the following: the politicization of history (following political conjuncture), the manipulation of facts, the glorification of history and its actors, demonisation, i. e., the construction of the image of an internal and external enemy, the ideological censoring of controversial assessments, and the actualisation of sociopolitical nostalgia. The use of this arsenal of ideological influence on mass consciousness can be seen in high-profile sociopolitical incidents of recent times. The difference in historical assessments is a reality that is pointless to obscure. Overcoming historical traumas, i. e., the “combination of history and memory”, is an indispensable condition for normalising and objectifying reflection on the past. The subject of the author’s attention is foreign policy invectives that have become hotbeds of diplomatic tension (more particularly, the Declaration of the European Parliament on the Outbreak of World War II adopted in 2019), the activities of governmental organisations “responsible” for the politics of memory (the Ukrainian Institute of National Memory), expositions of museums in Eastern Europe (the Museum of the Second World War in Gdansk, the Museum of the Occupation in Riga), school history textbooks, the fate of the monuments dedicated to the Second World War (in particular, the Bronze Soldier in Tallinn), public historical and political actions that “overturn” historical reality (for example, Legionnaire Day marches in Riga), and the censorship of publications with an alternative view of the traumatic events of the war.

Author Biography

Julia Kantor

Dr. Hab. (History), Chief Researcher, St Petersburg Institute of History of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Professor, Herzen State Pedagogical University of Russia.

7, Petrozavodskaya Str., 197110, St Petersburg, Russia.

48, Moika Embankment, 191186, St Petersburg, Russia.

ORCID 0000-0003-0362-345X

juliakantor@yandex.ru

References

Adamson, A., Valdmaa, S. (2000). Istoriya Estonii. Uchebnik dlya gimnazii [The History of Estonia. A Textbook for Gymnasiums]. Tallinn, Koolibri. 264 p.

Assman, A. (2016). Novoe nedovol’stvo memorial’noi kul’turoi [New Discontent with Memorial Culture] / transl. by B. Khlebnikov. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 223 p.

Bordyugov, G. A. (2011). “Voiny pamyati” na postsovetskom prostranstve [“Wars of Memory” in the Post-Soviet Space]. Moscow, AIRO-XXI. 256 p.

Bovdunov, A., Medvedeva, A. (2019). “Orientatsiya na peresmotr itogov voiny”: kak Evroparlament o’’yavil pakt Molotova – Ribbentropa prichinoi Vtoroi mirovoi [“Orientation on the Revision of the Results of the War”: How the European Parliament Declared the Molotov – Ribbentrop Pact the Cause of the Second World War]. In RT na russkom [website]. 21 Sept. URL: https://russian.rt.com/world/article/670247-evroparlament-rezolyuciya-vtoraya-mirovaya-voina (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Dembovskaya, D. (2010). Fashisty proshli po koridoru [The Fascists Walked along the Corridor]. In Vremya novostei [website]. 17 March. No. 43. URL: http://www.vremya.ru/2010/43/5/249693.html (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Do 77-ї rіchnitsі Aktu vіdnovlennya Ukraїns’koї derzhavi 30 chervnya 1941 roku rozgornuto ekspozitsіyu “Vіdnovlennya ukraїns’koї derzhavnostі v umovakh Drugoї svіtovoї vіini” [On 30 June 1941, the Exposition “The Restoration of Ukrainian Statehood in the Conditions of the Second World War” to Open on the 77th Anniversary of the Act of the Restoration of the Ukrainian State]. In Verkhovna Rada Ukraїni. Ofіtsіinii vebportal parlamentu Ukraїni [official website]. URL: https://www.rada.gov.ua/news/Novyny/160391.html (accessed: 20.02.2021).

Dogovor o peredache Litve goroda Vil’no i Vilenskoi oblasti i o vzaimopomoshchi mezhdu SSSR i Litvoi s konfidentsial’nym protokolom k nemu [Agreement on the Transfer of the City of Vilna and Vilna Region to Lithuania and on Mutual Assistance between the USSR and Lithuania with a Confidential Protocol]. In Runivers [website]. URL: https://runivers.ru/doc/d2.php?CENTER_ELEMENT_ID=150970 (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Ishchenko, V. V. (2010). Pamyat’ o voine i voina pamyati [War Memory and Memory War]. In Vtoraya mirovaya voina kak problema natsional’noi pamyati. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii. 24–26 sentyabrya 2009 g. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Rossiiskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta imeni A. I. Gertsena, pp. 7–12.

Kuvaldin, S. (2019). “Temnaya noch’” odna na vsekh. Kto i pochemu zapretil sovetskuyu pesnyu v Pol’she [“Dark Night” is One for All. Who Banned the Soviet Song in Poland and Why]. In Snob.ru [website]. 24 May. URL: https://snob.ru/entry/177406/?fromtg=1 (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Leszczyňski, A. (2017). II wojna światowa trwała pół wieku – według filmu wyprodukowanego przez IPN. Wyliczamy nadużycia. In OKO.Press [website]. September 15. URL: https://oko.press/ii-wojna-swiatowa-trwala-pol-wieku-wedlug-filmu-wyprodukowanegoipn-wyliczamy-naduzycia/ (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Litva. Entsiklopediya Katastrofy. Yad Vashem [Lithuania. Encyclopaedia of Catastrophe. Yad Vashem]. In Yadvashem.org [website]. URL: http://www1.yadvashem.org/yv/ru/holocaust/about/popup/lithuania.asp?height=420&width=560 (accessed: 19.01.2021).

Masłowski, A. (2019). Oświadczenie Muzeum II Wojny Światowej w Gdańsku. In Muzeum II Wojny Światowej w Gdańsku [official website]. 19 May. URL: https://muzeum1939.pl/oswiadczenie-muzeum-ii-wojny-swiatowej-w-gdansku/aktualnosci/2040.html?fbclid=IwAR1eGvzea4Ea7cv9pdH6oox4USoKcynN5E28_MvYQXrP7JcSQko7zVkjjQA (accessed: 20.01.2021).

MID Rossii: SSSR nikogda ne byl soyuznikom gitlerovskoi Germanii [The Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs: The USSR was Never an Ally of Hitler’s Germany]. (2019). In MID Rossii. VKontakte [social network]. 22 Sept. URL: https://vk.com/wall-70034991_369753 (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Neiburgs, U. (N. d.). Istoriya okkupatsii Latvii [The History of the Occupation of Latvia]. In Latvijas Okupācijas muzejs [official website]. URL: http://okupacijasmuzejs.lv/ru/istorija-okkupacii-latvii/nacistskaja-okkupacija/latvija-vo-vtoroj-mirovoj-vojnje (accessed: 08.01.2020).

Nollendorfs, V., Neiburgs, U. (2004). Latyshi v sostave vooruzhennykh sil Germanii vo Vtoroi Mirovoi voine [Latvians in the German Armed Forces in World War II]. In Ministerstvo inostrannykh del Latviiskoi respubliki [official website]. 3 Sept. URL: https://www.mfa.gov.lv/ru/informacionnye-materialy-i-dokumenty/publikacii-vpresse/36949-latyshi-v-sostave-vooruzhennyh-sil-germanii-vo-vtoroj-mirovoj-vojne (accessed: 08.01.2021).

Rokossovskaya, A. (2019). Temnaya Noch’ muzeev [The Dark Night of Museums]. In Rossiiskaya gazeta [website]. No. 108 (7866). 21 May. URL: https://rg.ru/2019/05/21/vpolshe-posle-skandala-stala-populiarnoj-sovetskaia-pesnia.html (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Shama, O. (2019). 80 rokіv vіd pochatku Drugoї svіtovoї. Yak 1939 roku Gіtler razom zі Stalіnim rozv’yazali naikrovoprolitnіshu vіinu v іstorії [80 Years since the Beginning of World War II. The Way in Which Hitler and Stalin Unleashed the Bloodiest War in History in 1939]. In NB. Novosti Ukrainy i mira [website]. 1 Sept. URL: https://nv.ua/ukr/world/countries/druga-svitova-1939-yak-gitler-rozv-yazav-viynu-80-rokiv-z-pochatkuviyni-foto-50040052.html?utm_campaign=langanalitics.&utm_medium=in_article&utm_source=set_lang (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Slavinas, A. (1993). Der inszenierte Aufstand. In Die Zeit. 25 June. No. 26.

Strany Baltii i Pol’sha vmeste budut soprotivlyat’sya popytkam RF perepisat’ istoriyu [The Baltic States and Poland Will Together Resist the Attempts of the Russian Federation to Rewrite History]. (2020). In Delfi.lt [website]. 15 June. URL: https://www.delfi.lt/ru/news/politics/strany-baltii-i-polsha-vmeste-budut-soprotivlyatsya-popytkam-rf-perepisatistoriyu.d?id=84535065 (accessed: 20.01.2021).

“Temnaya noch’” na raznykh yazykakh mira [The “Dark Night” in Different World Languages]. (N. d.). In YouTube [website]. URL: https://youtu.be/HVezeFj18BE (accessed: 20.01.2021).

The Unconquered: Riveting Story of Poland in WW2 Narrated by Sean Bean. (N. d.). In YouTube [website]. URL: https://youtu.be/Q88AkN1hNYM (accessed: 20.01.2021).

V’yatrovich, V. (N. d.). Bandera: starі ta novі mіfi [Bandera: Old and New Myths]. In Ukraїns’kii іnstitut natsіonal’noї pam’yatі [official website]. URL: https://old.uinp.gov.ua/news/bandera-stari-ta-novi-mifi (accessed: 20.02.2021).

V’yatrovich, V., Zabіlii, R., Derev’yanii, І., Sodol’, P. (2011). Ukraїns’ka Povstans’ka Armіya. Іstorіya neskorenikh. L’vіv, Tsentr doslіdzhen’ vizvol’nogo rukhu. 352 p.

Vanagaite, R., Zuroff, E. (2016). Svoi. Puteshestvie s vragom [Our People. A Journey with an Enemy]. Moscow, AST, Corpus. 416 p.

Ventslova: travlya Vanagaite ochen’ napominaet sovetskoe vremya [Venclova: Vanagaite’s Persecution is Very Reminiscent of Soviet Times]. (2017). In Delfi.lt [website]. 30 Oct. URL: https://ru.delfi.lt/news/live/venclova-travlya-vanagajte-ochen-napominaetsovetskoe-vremya.d?id=76195009 (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Vistavka “Ukraїns’ka Druga svіtova” [The “Ukrainian Second World” Exhibition]. In Mega [internet-platform]. URL: https://mega.nz/folder/8p5UURAB#DgsRWCGp0ZACEBNTzrEwFw (accessed: 21.02.2021).

Yatskyavichus, M. (2017). Izdatel’stvo Alma littera izymaet iz prodazhi vse knigi Vanagaite [Alma Litera Publishing House Withdraws All Vanagaite Books from Sale]. In Delfi.lt [website]. 27 Oct. URL: https://ru.delfi.lt/news/live/izdatelstvo-alma-litteraizymaet-iz-prodazhi-vse-knigi-vanagajte.d?id=76182929 (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Yuranets, A. (2019). Voina ne zabyta: Moskva i Varshava ssoryatsya iz-za istorii. Kak Rossiya i Pol’sha obvinyayut drug druga v popytkakh perepisat’ istoriyu [The War is Not Forgotten: Moscow and Warsaw are Quarreling Over History. How Russia and Poland Accuse Each Other of Trying to Rewrite History]. In Gazeta.ru [website]. 23 Dec. URL: https://www.gazeta.ru/politics/2019/12/23_a_12880478.shtml (accessed: 20.01.2021).

Published

2021-09-29

How to Cite

Kantor, J. (2021). Deviations of the Politics of Memory in Eastern Europe and in the Post-Soviet Space. Quaestio Rossica, 9(3), 1064–1079. https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2021.3.627

Issue

Section

Disputatio