Guilds of German Bakers of St Petersburg in the First Half of the 19th Century: Conflict Resolution Practices and Everyday Life
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2021.3.610Keywords:
St Petersburg in the first half of the nineteenth century, Russian and German guilds, German bakers, trade conflicts, everyday lifeAbstract
Referring to materials from the Russian State Historical Archive and the Central State Historical Archive of St Petersburg, this article investigates mechanisms of competition and resolving conflicts between tradesmen in St Petersburg and the level of German masters’ adaptation to a new cultural and social environment. It reveals an opportunity to reach a deeper understanding of bread production in the capital over a long period of time. Competitive confrontations between guilds reflect not only the negative aspects of monopolistic tendencies among trade masters, but also the vitality of St Petersburg trades. This manifested itself in constant rivalry among the guilds of Russian and German bread makers, confectioners, pretzel bakers, roll makers, and non-guild pastry makers. The intensive competition could increase or decrease due to national, confessional, cultural, and territorial factors. The 1830s and 1840s were the last period of this open competition: after, all such guilds were united into a single organisation. The author provides a periodisation that conditionally reflects the fundamental stages in the development of the guilds: 1721–1785 (their establishment), 1785–1840s (their flourishing), and the 1850s–1870s (unification and standardisation with new regulations). The struggle for the partial monopolisation of market segments in the 1830s and 1840s pointed to the need for clearer structures. The prosperity, entrepreneurship, and influence of German bakers manifested themselves in the black-market sale of a certain type of securities: bakery certificates whose price could reach 12,000 paper roubles. Bread production in St Petersburg can be used as a positive example of an institution that underwent a century-long cycle of modernisation characteristic of an immobile and conservative society. This cycle of modernisation was based on a catch-up model of development and contributed to dynamic innovation (the introduction of mechanical dough mixers from Germany). The author puts forward a hypothesis that the increase in stiff competition pointed to the limits of the market and thus the limits of growth: production volume could no longer grow arbitrarily, which meant that access to guilds became more restricted.
References
Aller, S. I. (1822). Ukazatel’ zhilishch i zdanii v Sanktpeterburge, ili Adresnaya kniga [Index of Dwellings and Buildings in St Petersburg, or an Address Book]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Departamenta narodnogo prosveshсheniya. XVI, 663 p.
Allmann, O. (1910). Geschichte der deutschen Bäcker- und Konditor-Bewegung. 2 Bd. Hamburg, O. Allmann. Bd. 2. 512 S.
Bigey, F., Segond, D. et al. (2021). Evidence for Two Main Domestication Trajectories in Saccharomyces cerevisiae Linked to Distinct Bread-Making Processes. In Current Biology. Vol. 31. Iss. 4, pp. 722–732.e5. DOI 10.1016/j.cub.2020.11.016.
Blintsov, A. (2013). Khoroshie drozhzhi. Peterburgskii bulochnik Fridrikh Sigizmund Veber. In Fontanka. Kul’turno-istoricheskii al’manakh. No. 14, pp. 52–56.
Erofeev, A. (N. d.). “Sladkii” pereulok [“Sweet” Lane]. In Administratsiya Sankt-Peterburga [official website]. URL: https://www.gov.spb.ru/gov/terr/reg_viborg/news/160574/ (accessed: 29.12.2020).
Gaisinovich, A. I. (1931). Tsekhi v Rossii v XVIII v. [Guilds in 18th-Century Russia]. In Izvestiya Akademii nauk SSSR. Seriya 7. No. 5, pp. 523–568.
Georgi, I. [G.] (1996). Opisanie rossiisko-imperatorskogo stolichnogo goroda Sankt-Peterburga i dostopamyatnostei v okrestnostyakh onogo, s planom [A Description of the Imperial Russian Capital of St Petersburg and Monuments in the Vicinity thereof, with a Plan] / preface by Yu. M. Piryutko. St Petersburg, Liga. 528 p.
Ivanov, B. (1920). Professional’noe dvizhenie rabochikh khlebo-pekarno-konditerskogo proizvodstva Petrograda i gubernii (s 1903–1917 god). S ocherkom polozheniya rabochikh i proizvodstva do 900-kh godov i osnovaniya Vserossiiskogo soyuza pishchevikov [The Professional Workers Movement in the Bread Production and Confectionery Industry of Petrograd and the Province (1903–1917). With an Outline of the Situation of Workers and Production until the 1900s and the Founding of the All-Russian Union of the Food Industry]. Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel‘stvo. 172 p.
Jerrmann, E. (1851). Unpolitische Bilder aus St Petersburg. Berlin, Allg. Deutsch. Verl.-Anst. 282 S.
Kopanev, A. I. (1955). Naselenie Peterburga ot kontsa XVIII v. do 1861 g. [The Population of St Petersburg from the End of the 18th Century until 1861]. In Ocherki istorii Leningrada v 7 t. Moscow, Leningrad, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. Vol. 1, pp. 506–549.
Kuznetsova, S. I. (Ed.). (2019). Tsekhovye znamena remeslennykh tsekhov Sankt-Peterburga kontsa XVIII veka iz sobraniya Gosudarstvennogo muzeya istorii Sankt-Peterburga. Al’bom-katalog [Guild Banners of the Craft Guilds of St Petersburg at the End of the 18th Century from the Collection of the State Museum of the History of St Petersburg. Catalogue Album]. St Petersburg, Gosudarstvennyi muzei istorii Sankt-Peterburga. 181 p.
Luppov, S. P., Petrov, N. N. (1955). Gorodskoe upravlenie i gorodskoe khozyaistvo Peterburga ot kontsa XVIII v. do 1861 g. [The Municipal Management and Municipal Economy of St Petersburg from the End of the 18th Century until 1861]. In Ocherki istorii Leningrada v 7 t. Moscow, Leningrad, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. Vol. 1, pp. 601–629.
Obryady dlya S.-Peterburgskogo pryanichnogo tsekha [Rites for the St Petersburg Gingerbread Workshop]. (1850). St Petersburg, Tipografiya pri kantselyarii Sankt-Peterburgskogo voennogo general-gubernatora. 12 p.
Opisanie S.-Peterburgskoi remeslennoi vystavki 1899 goda [Description of the Craft Exhibition in St Petersburg in 1899]. (1900). St Petersburg, S. n. II, 98, 215 p.
Otchet o S.-Peterburgskoi remeslennoi vystavke 1885 goda [Report on the St Petersburg Craft Exhibition in 1885]. (1885). St Petersburg, S. n. 108 p.
Otchet S.-Peterburgskoi remeslennoi upravy za 1866 god [Report of the St Petersburg Crafts Council for 1866]. (1867). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Yuliya Viganda. 49 p.
Otchet S.-Peterburgskoi remeslennoi upravy za 1872 god [Report of the St Petersburg Crafts Council for 1872]. (1873). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Yuliya Viganda. 78 p.
Otchet S.-Peterburgskoi remeslennoi upravy za 1876 god [Report of the St Petersburg Crafts Council for 1876]. (1877). St Petersburg, Tipografiya Yuliya Viganda. 94 p.
Otchet S.-Peterburgskoi remeslennoi upravy za 1889 god [Report of the St Petersburg Crafts Council for 1889]. (1890). St Petersburg, Tipografiya D. I. Ivanova. 167 p.
Pazhitnov, K. A. (1952). Problema remeslennykh tsekhov v zakonodatel’stve russkogo absolyutizma [The Problem of Craft Guilds in the Legislation of Russian Absolutism]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. 207 p.
Przhetslavskii, O. A. (2010). Vospominaniya [Memories]. In Feduta, A. I. (Ed.). Polyaki v Peterburge v pervoi polovine XIX v. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, pp. 29–290.
Repina, A. V. (1999). Nemetskie bulochniki v Sankt-Peterburge [German Bakers in St Petersburg]. In Samgina, G. I. (Ed.). Nemtsy v Rossii. Peterburgskie nemtsy = Die Deutschen in Russland: Petersburger Deutsche. Sbornik statei. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin, pp. 197–204.
Rezanov, N. P. (Ed.). (1799). Ustav tsekhov. Chast’ pervaya. Utverzhden: g. Gatchina. Noyabrya v 12 den’ 1799 goda [Guilds Charter. Part 1. Approved: Gatchina. Nov. 12, 1799]. [St Petersburg], [Senatskaya tipografiya]. 35 p.
RGIA [The Russian State Historical Archive]. Stock 1287. List 6. Dos. 1441; Stock 1287. List 37. Dos. 79, 92, 95, 231, 369, 892.
Ryndzyunskii, P. G. (1959). Melkaya promyshlennost’: remeslo i melkotovarnoe proizvodstvo [Small Industry: Crafts and Small-Scale Production]. In Rozhkova, M. K. (Ed.). Ocherki ekonomicheskoi istorii Rossii pervoi poloviny XIX veka. Sbornik statei. Moscow, Sotsekgiz, pp. 62–117.
Sheipak, A. A. (2007). Istoriya nauki i tekhniki. Materialy i tekhnologii. Uchebnoe posobie v 2 ch. [A History of Science and Technology. Materials and Technologies. A Textbook. 2 Parts]. 2nd Ed., add. Moscow, Moskovskii gosudarstvennyi industrial’nyi universitet. Part 1. 274 p.
Sidorov, M., Shcherbakova, E. (Eds.). (2006). “Rossiya pod nadzorom”: otchety III otdeleniya 1827–1869. Sbornik dokumentov [“Russia under Surveillance”. Reports of the 3rd Department for 1827–1869. Collection of Documents]. Moscow, Rossiiskii fond kul’tury, Rossiiskii arkhiv. 706 p.
TsGIA SPb [Central State Historical Archive of St Petersburg]. Stock 221. List 1. Dos. 80; Stock 223. List 1. Dos. 418, 514, 576, 658.
