Peter the Great as Antichrist: The Secular Sources of an Old Believer Compilation from Holy Scripture
This article is devoted to an Old Believer work about Peter the Great, known as A Compilation from Holy Scripture about the Antichrist, which was first published in 1861. Some scholars have suggested that the work dates back to Peter’s reign, when many traditionally minded Orthodox Christians regarded the tsar as the Antichrist. The author of this article argues, however, that the work dates from the early nineteenth century, and that the case it makes for Peter’s identity as Antichrist is based primarily on tales about the tsar which were published in the late eighteenth century. On the basis of anecdotes about Peter’s conception, for example, the author of the Compilation drew a comparison with the Annunciation, the Epiphany, and the Feast of the Circumcision, to demonstrate a sacrilegious parallel between Peter’s biography and that of Christ, which “proved” that Peter was the Antichrist. The Compilation also cites works which seem to blasphemously suggest that Peter was God incarnate, in order to argue that the tsar was the embodiment not of God, but of Satan. Finally, when one work praised Catherine the Great for representing “the spirit of Peter the Great”, the compiler concluded that the spirit of all subsequent Russian rulers was also the spirit of Peter, that is, the spirit of the Antichrist. This is an idiosyncratic version of the argument made in the late eighteenth century by Evfimii, the founder of the Old Believer sect of the beguny, that Peter had founded a dynasty of Antichrists, and that all “true Christians” should flee from his realm. The distinguished Russian scholars Viktor Zhivov and Boris Uspenskii have argued that the metaphorical sacralisation of the monarch, in secular eighteenth-century panegyrics, was interpreted literally by some Old Believers and contributed to their identification of Peter as the Antichrist. The author of this article suggests that a similar role was played by more popular works such as the collections of anecdotes which presented the tsar as a God-like figure.
Belyaev, O. P. (1793). Kabinet Petra Velikogo v 3 ch. [The Cabinet of Peter the Great. 3 Parts]. St Petersburg, Imperatorskaya Akademiya nauk. Part 1. , 170 p.
Bergholz, F. W. von (1858). Dnevnik kamer-yunkera Berkhgol’tsa v 4 t. [The Diary of Kamer-Junker Bergholz. 4 Vols.]. Moscow, Tipografiya Katkova i Co. Part 1. 1721-i god. 275 p.
Cherniavsky, M. (1966). The Old Believers and the New Religion. In Slavic Rev. Vol. 25. No. 1, pp. 1–39.
Eleonskii, F. G. (1864). O sostoyanii russkogo raskola pri Petre I [On the Condition of the Russian Schism under Peter I]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya departamenta udelov. 158 p.
Evfimii (1862a). Uchenie Evfimiya (osnovatelya Strannicheskoi sekty v Yaroslavskoi gubernii) [The Teachings of Evfimii (the Founder of the Wanderer Sect in Yaroslavl Province)]. In Sbornik pravitel’stvennykh svedenii o raskol’nikakh, sostavlennyi V. Kel’sievym. Iss. 4. L., Trübner & Co., pp. 248–258.
Evfimii (1862b). Vypiska iz Tsvetnika Evfimiya [An Extract from Evfimii’s Miscellany]. In Sbornik pravitel’stvennykh svedenii o raskol’nikakh, sostavlennyi V. Kel’sievym. Iss. 4. L., Trübner & Co., pp. 259–273.
Gur’yanova, N. S. (1988). Krest’yanskii antimonarkhicheskii protest v staroobryadcheskoi eskhatologicheskoi literature perioda pozdnego feodalizma [Peasant Anti-Monarchist Protest in Old Ritualist Eschatological Literature of the Late Feudal Period]. Novosibirsk, Nauka. 188 p.
Hughes, L. (1998). Russia in the Age of Peter the Great. New Haven, L., Yale Univ. Press. 602 p.
Kel’siev, V. I. (1861). Predislovie V. Kel’sieva [Foreword by V. Kel’siev]. In Sbornik pravitel’stvennykh svedenii o raskol’nikakh, sostavlennyi V. Kel’sievym. Iss. 2. L., Trübner & Co., pp. III–XVIII.
Krekshin, P. N. (1787). Skazanie o rozhdenii, o vospitanii i narechenii na vserossiiskii tsarskii prestol ego tsarskogo presvetlogo velichestva gosudarya Petra Pervogo [An Account of the Birth, Upbringing and Designation to the All-Russian Tsarist Throne of His Radiant Tsarist Majesty the Sovereign Peter I]. Moscow, Tipografiya Ponomareva. , 58 p.
Krekshin, P. N. (1788). Kratkoe opisanie slavnykh i dostopamyatnykh del imperatora Petra Velikogo… Predstavlennoe razgovorami v tsarstve mertvykh… [A Short Description of the Glorious and Memorable Deeds of the Emperor Peter the Great… Represented in Conversations in the Kingdom of the Dead…]. St Petersburg, Imperatorskaya tipografiya. , 104 p.
Mal’tsev, A. I. (1996). Starovery-stranniki v XVIII – pervoi polovine XIX v. [The Old Believer “Wanderers” in the Eighteenth and First Half of the Nineteenth Centuries]. Novosibirsk, Sibirskii khronograf. 268 p.
Marsden, T. (2015). The Crisis of Religious Toleration in Imperial Russia: Bibikov’s System for the Old Believers. Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press. 304 p.
Perrie, M. (2016). Russkaya narodnaya eskhatologiya i legenda o Petre I – Antikhriste [Russian Popular Eschatology and the Legend about Peter I as Antichrist]. In Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya. Iss. 4, pp. 77–86. DOI 10.21638/11701/spbu02.2016.407.
Shchapov, A. P. (1859). Russkii raskol staroobryadstva [The Russian Schism of the Old Ritualists]. Kazan, Izdanie knigoprodavtsa Ivana Dubrovina. , 547,  p.
Shchapov, A. P. (1906). Zemstvo i raskol II. Beguny [Society and the Schism II. The Runaways]. In Shchapov, A. P. Sochineniya v 3 t. St Petersburg, Izdanie M. V. Pirozhkova. Vol. 1, pp. 505–579.
Shmurlo, E. F. (1912). Petr Velikii v otsenke sovremennikov i potomstva [Peter the Great in the Judgment of Contemporaries and of Posterity]. Iss. 1 (XVIII vek). St Petersburg, Senatskaya tipografiya. II, 108, 161 p.
Sobranie ot Svyatogo Pisaniya o Antikhriste [A Compilation from Holy Scripture about the Antichrist]. (1861). In Sbornik pravitel’stvennykh svedenii o raskol’nikakh, sostavlennyi V. Kel’sievym. Iss. 2. L., Trübner & Co., pp. 245–267.
Stählin, J. von (1830). Podlinnye anekdoty o Petre Velikom. Sobrannye Yakovom Shtelinym v 2 ch. [Authentic Anecdotes about Peter the Great. Collected by Jacob von Stählin. 2 Parts]. 3rd Ed. Moscow, Tipografiya Reshetnikova. Part 2. IV, 179 p.
Vypisana Istoriya pechatnaya o Petre Velikom. Sobranie ot Svyatogo Pisaniya o Antikhriste [A Copy of a Printed History about Peter the Great. A Compilation from Holy Scripture about the Antichrist]. (1863). In Chteniya v Imperatorskom obshchestve istorii i drevnostei rossiiskikh pri Moskovskom universitete. Book 1, pp. 52–71.
Zhivov, V. M., Uspenskii, B. A. (1994). Tsar’ i Bog. Semioticheskie aspekty sakralizatsii monarkha v Rossii [Tsar and God. Semiotic Aspects of the Sacralisation of the Monarchy in Russia]. In Uspenskii, B. A. Izbrannye trudy v 3 t. Moscow, Gnozis. Vol. 1, pp. 110–218.