“A Radical Turn”: The Reform of the Soviet System of Public Healthcare
Abstract
While analysing medical statistics from the Russian archives and the political speeches of medical administrators in the 1930s–1940s, the authors of this article discovered a tendency in the development of the healthcare system which was dramatically different from the post-revolutionary era. The reform was ideologically grounded and consistently conducted in the USSR. During this time, the healthcare system was restructured and expanded in order to treat patients in the state’s economic and military interests, which forced doctors to care more about workers’ ability to work and production costs than about people’s health. For this reason, access to free medical care was severely limited for Soviet citizens, but the range of services provided to workers in leading industries was expanded (including the establishment of medical centres in factories, sanatoriums and resorts, day nurseries, etc.). During the prewar decade, the public healthcare system expanded in terms of the number of hospitals, doctors, and patient capacity while reducing the quality of medical care caused by poor training, poor hospital facilities, lack of medicines and instruments, low-quality catering, etc. The authors reach conclusions about this seeming concern about the development of the healthcare system, comparing statistical data, optimistic official reports and revelatory narrative evidence, political debates of medical managers, and the accusations of party leaders. It is established that during the Great Terror (1937), reform critics were repressed and the assessment of state policy prohibited. In the postwar years, the reform of the 1930s was concealed by medical historians inside a ‘grand narrative’ of the past, which described the achievements of the healthcare system as aimed at saving the Soviet people’s lives and health. The only possible and universally accepted approach was a myth about a consistent policy and quality science-based medicine available to everyone. The authors maintain that discourse control over the circulation of historical evidence about prewar healthcare policy made it impossible for researchers to see the discrepancies between politicians’ statements, which were based on selective statistics, and social realities.
References
[Andreev, E. M.]. (2014). Snizhenie mladencheskoi smertnosti v Rossii v 1940–1958 gg. [The Decline in Infant Mortality in Russia between 1940 and 1958]. In Denisenko, M. B., Elizarov, V. V. (Eds.). Razvitie naseleniya i demograficheskaya politika. Moscow, MAKS Press, pp. 108–128.
Andreev, E. M., Darskii, L. E., Khar’kova, T. L. (1993). Naselenie Sovetskogo Soyuza. 1922–1991 [The Population of the Soviet Union. 1922–1991]. Moscow, Nauka. 143 p.
Caroli, D. (2016). Rasprostranenie evropeiskoi obrazovatel’noi modeli detskikh yaslei (crèches) v Rossii [The Introduction and Spread of European-Style Crèches in Russia]. In Quaestio Rossica. Vol. 4. No. 3, pp. 141–158. DOI 10.15826/qr.2016.3.180.
Egorova, D. V. (2011). Pravovaya politika v sfere zdravookhraneniya i pravovaya okhrana zdorov’ya naseleniya v sovetskom gosudarstve (1917–1991 gg.) [Legal Policy and Legal Protection of Public Health in the Soviet Union (1917–1991)]. Dis. … kand. yuridich. nauk. Saratov, S. n. 181 p.
Field, M. (1967). Soviet Socialized Medicine. N. Y., Free Press, L., Collier – Macmillan. 231 p.
GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. Stock A-482. List 24. Dos. 1277.
Hoffmann, D. L. (2003). Stalinist Values: The Cultural Norms of Soviet Modernity, 1917–1941. Ithaca, Cornell Univ. Press. 264 p.
Hoffmann, D. L. (2011). Cultivating the Masses. Modern State Practices and Soviet Socialism, 1914–1939. Ithaca, Cornell Univ. Press. 327 p.
Hoffmann, D. L. (2018). Vzrashchivanie mass. Modernoe gosudarstvo i sovetskii sotsializm. 1914–1939 [Cultivating the Masses. Modern State Practices and Soviet Socialism, 1914–1939] / transl. by A. Tereshchenko. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 424 p.
Kaminskii, G. N. (1935). Okhrana zdorov’ya v Sovetskom soyuze [Health Care in the USSR]. Moscow, Biomedgiz. 118 p.
Kaminskii, G. N. (1936). Zadachi sovetskogo zdravookhraneniya [Aims of the Soviet Health Sector]. Moscow, Biomedgiz. 164 p.
Kolerov, M. A. (2017). Stalin: ot Fikhte k Beriya. Ocherki po istorii yazyka stalinskogo kommunizma [Stalin: From Fichte to Beria. Essays on the History of the Language of Stalinist Communism]. Moscow, Modest Kolerov. 640 p.
Kolerov, M. A. (2018). Totalitarizm: russkaya programma dlya zapadnoi doktriny [Totalitarianism: A Russian Programme for Western Doctrine]. Moscow, Izdanie knizhnogo magazina “Tsiolkovskii”. 152 p.
Kovrigina, M. D. (1946). Zabota gosudarstva o materi i rebenke [State Care of Mother and Child]. Moscow, Gospolitizdat. 32 p.
Lisitsyn, Yu. P. (2008). Istoriya meditsiny. Uchebnik [History of Medicine. Textbook]. 2nd Ed. Moscow, GEOTAR-Media. 398 p.
Lisitsyn, Yu. P., Ulumbekova, G. E. (2011). Obshchestvennoe zdorov’e i zdravookhranenie [Public Health and Healthсare]. 3rd Ed. Moscow, GEOTAR-Media. 544 p.
Materialy k pyatiletnemu planu zdravookhraneniya RSFSR [Materials for the Five-Year Health Plan of the RSFSR]. (1930). Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe meditsinskoe izdatel’stvo. 152 p.
O yasel’nom obsluzhivanii detei v gorodakh, promyshlennykh tsentrakh, sovkhozakh, MTS i kolkhozakh. Postanovlenie VTsIK i SNK RSFSR ot 20 sentyabrya 1932 g. [On the Nursery Services in Cities, Industrial Centres, State Farms, Machine Tractor Stations and Collective Farms. Resolution of the Central Executive Committee and the Council of People’s Commissars of the RSFSR as of September 20, 1932]. (1932). In Sobranie uzakonenii RSFSR. No. 78. Article 345, pp. 467–468.
Ob osnovnykh ustanovkakh plana po zdravookhraneniyu na 1937 god [About the Main Points of the Health Plan for 1937]. (1936). Moscow, Biomedgiz. 28 p.
Poddubnyi, M. V. (1997). Sanitarnaya okhrana okruzhayushchei sredy v Rossii i SSSR v pervoi polovine XX veka [Sanitary Protection of the Environment in Russia and the USSR in the First Half of the 20th Century]. Kiev, Kievskii ekologo-kul’turnyi tsentr, Tsentr okhrany dikoi prirody Sotsial’no-ekologicheskogo soyuza. 111 p.
Postanovleniya KPSS i Sovetskogo pravitel’stva ob okhrane zdorov’ya naroda [Decisions of the CPSU and the Soviet Government on the Protection of Public Health]. (1958). Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo meditsinskoi literatury. 338 p.
Rezolyutsii VII Vserossiiskogo s”ezda zdravotdelov [Resolutions of the 7th All-Russian Congress of Health Units]. (1930). In Na fronte zdravookhraneniya. No. 5–6, pp. 134–140.
RGAE [Russian State Archive of Economics]. Stock 1562. List 18. Dos. 192; List 41. Dos. 65; List 33. Dos. 2638.
Solomon, G. S. (1994). The Expert and the State in Russian Public Health: Continuities and Changes across the Revolutionary Divide. In Porter, D. (Ed.). The History of Public Health and the Modern State. Amsterdam, Rodopi, pp. 183–223.
Sorokina, T. S. (2008). Istoriya meditsiny. Uchebnik dlya studentov vysshikh meditsinskikh uchebnykh zavedenii [History of Medicine. A Textbook for Students of Higher Medical Educational Institutions]. 8th Ed. Moscow, Akademiya. 560 p.
Sorokina, T. S., Morozov, A. V. (2017). Otechestvennoe zdravookhranenie i meditsinskoe obrazovanie v pervoi polovine dvadtsatogo veka [Russian Healthcare and Medical Education in the First Half of the 20th Century]. Moscow, Rossiiskii universitet druzhby narodov. 55 p.
Sumpf, A. (2011). Book Review: David L. Hoffmann, Cultivating the Masses. In Cahiers du Monde Russe. Vol. 52. No. 4, pp. 724–726.
TsA FSB Rossii [Central Archive of the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation]. Stock 2. List 11. Dos. 47.
Vladimirskii, M. F. (1930). Zadachi organov zdravookhraneniya i sotsialisticheskoe stroitel’stvo [Tasks of the Health Authorities and the Construction of Socialism]. In Na fronte zdravookhraneniya. No. 5–6, pp. 3–15.
Voprosy truda v tsifrakh. Statisticheskii spravochnik za 1927–1930 gg. [Labour Issues in Numbers. Statistical Compendium 1927–1930]. (1930). Moscow, Gostrudizdat. 72 p.
Weissman, N. B. (1990). Origins of Soviet Health Administration. Narkomzdrav, 1918–1928. In Solomon, G., Hutchinson, J. F. (Eds.). Health and Society in Revolutionary Russia. Bloomington, Indiana Univ. Press, pp. 97–120.
XVI Vserossiiskii s”ezd Sovetov. 15–23 yanvarya 1935 g. [Moskva]. Stenograficheskii otchet: byulleteni. № 1–17. Postanovleniya [16th All-Russian Congress of Soviets: 15–23 January 1935 [Moscow]. Verbatim Transcripts. Newsletters. No. 1–17. Regulations]. (1935). Moscow, Vserossiiskii tsentral’nyi ispolnitel’nyi komitet. 708 p.
Zatravkin, S. N., Khabriev, R. U., Shchepin, V. O., Sarkisov, A. S. (2018). Zabolevaemost’ infektsionnymi boleznyami v SSSR. Soobshchenie 1. 1919–1949 gody [Incidence of Infectious Diseases in the USSR. Message 1. 1919–1949]. In Problemy sotsial’noi gigieny, zdravookhraneniya i istorii meditsiny. No. 5, pp. 350–356.
Zdravookhranenie v SSSR [Public Health in the USSR]. (1966). Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Tsentral’nogo statisticheskogo upravleniya pri Sovete ministrov SSSR. 447 p.
