“Difficult questions” of Russian History: Opinions and Forecasts
Abstract
This article deals with the professional discussion about the so-called “difficult questions” of Russian history that involves historians and teachers in the now independent republics of the former Soviet Union and Eastern Block. Both academic publications and teaching books are used as primary sources for the study. In the first section, the author studies several problems connected with the origin of Russian statehood, the Varangian question, and civilizational characteristics of East Slavic nations. The second section is devoted to the Russian imperial past and especially to the discourse on colonialism, which is often used as an explanatory model for the imperial period by historians and textbook authors in some of the post-Soviet countries. The third section is concerned with the conception of the 1917 revolution. The author emphasizes the fact that the conception of a continuous revolutionary process (1917–1922) has yet to be accepted by Russian secondary schools. In this part, the author considers several other factors significant for understanding the revolutionary process including issues such as the origins of the First World War and the developmental level of the Russian Empire in the early twentieth century. In the fourth section, the article discusses the conception of the 1930s Soviet modernization along with negative opinions about the Soviet period given by scholars of different former Soviet republics. In the fifth section, the author briefly observes contemporary studies of culture and everyday life. It is concluded that the history of culture is not represented well in Russian school textbooks, and it is also found that the studies on everyday life are often lacking in depth. Discussing various “difficult questions” of Russian history, the author highlights controversial historical ideas and opinions, formulated in the post-Soviet countries during the last decades.
References
Aksyutin, Yu. V., Gerdt, N. E. (2017). Russkaya intelligentsiya i revolyutsiya 1917 goda: v khaose sobytii i v smyatenii chuvstv [The Russian Intelligentsia and the 1917 Revolution: In the Chaos of Events and in the Confusion of Feelings]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 703 p.
Bakhturina, A. Yu. (2018). Sovetskaya natsional’naya politika [Soviet National Policy]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. Trudnye voprosy istorii Rossii. URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840004708-7-1/ (mode of access: 22.04.2020). DOI 10.18254/S2079878404708-7.
Barkhudaryan, V. (Ed.). (2001). Istoriya Armenii v kontekste mirovoi istorii dlya 9-go klassa [History of Armenia in the Context of World History for the 9th Grade]. Erevan, Zangak-97.
Barkhudaryan, V. (Ed.). (2005). Istoriya Armenii dlya 8-go klassa [History of Armenia for the 8th Grade]. Erevan, Luis, 2005.
Barkhudaryan, V. (Ed.). (2007). Istoriya Armenii dlya 8-go klassa [History of Armenia for the 8th Grade]. Erevan, Makmillan – Armeniya.
Brenton, T. (Ed.). (2017). Istoricheskaya neizbezhnost’? Klyuchevye sobytiya russkoi revolyutsii [Historically Inevitable? Turning Points of the Russian Revolution]. Moscow, Al’pina nonfikshn. 414 p.
Chorotegin, T. K., Omurbekov, T. N. (2005). Istoriya Kyrgyzstana (IX–XVIII vv.). Uchebnik dlya 7 klassov srednikh shkol [History of Kyrgyzstan (9th–18th Centuries). Textbook for 7th Grade High Schools]. Bishkek, Biiiktik. 184 p.
Danilevskii, I. N., Tairova-Yakovleva, T. G., Shubin, A. V., Mironenko, V. I. (2015). Istoriya Ukrainy [History of Ukraine]. St Petersburg, Aleteiya. 508 p.
Danilkin, L. A. (2017). Lenin. Pantokrator solnechnykh pylinok [Lenin. Pantocrator of the Solar Dust]. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya. 784 p.
Florya, B. N. (1997). O nekotorykh osobennostyakh razvitiya etnicheskogo samosoznaniya vostochnykh slavyan v epokhu Srednevekov’ya – Rannego Novogo vremeni [On Some Features of Development of Ethnic Identity of the Eastern Slavs in the Middle Ages – Early Modern Times]. In Rossiya – Ukraina: istoriya vzaimootnoshenii. Moscow, Shkola “Yazyki russkoi kul’tury”, pp. 9–27.
Gagkuev, R. G., Repnikov, A. V. (2017). Velikaya Revolyutsiya 1917 goda. Illyustrirovannaya letopis’ [The Great Revolution of 1917. Illustrated Chronicle]. Moscow, EKSMO, Yauza. 224 p.
Gisem, O. V. (2015). Istoriya Ukraïni. Pidruchnik dlya 7 klasiv zagal’noosvіtnіkh navchal’nikh zakladіv [History of Ukraine. 7th Grade Textbook]. Ternopil’, Navchal’na kniga – Bogdan. 272 p.
Istoriya Kryma [History of Crimea]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. URL: https://history.jes.su/issue.2017.2.4.e12/ (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Istoriya Orenburgskogo kraya [History of Orenburg Region]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. URL: https://history.jes.su/issue.2017.3.9.e13/ (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Istoriya Saratovskogo Povolzh’ya [History of the Saratov Volga]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. URL: https://history.jes.su/issue.2015.3.9.e4/ (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Istoriya Sibiri [History of Siberia]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. URL: https://history.jes.su/issue.2016.4.10.e11/ (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Izgoev, A. S. (2017). Rozhdennoe v revolyutsionnoi smute [Born in Revolutionary Turmoil]. Moscow, Izdatel’skii dom “Delo” Rossiiskoi akademii narodnogo khozyaistva i gosudarstvennoi sluzhby pri Prezidente Rossiiskoi Federatsii. 600 p.
Kantor, Yu. Z. (Ed.). (2017). 1917 g. Vokrug Zimnego [1917. Around the Winter Palace]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 247 p.
Kenin’sh, I. (1990). Istoriya Latvii. Uchebnik dlya 8–9-kh klassov [History of Latvia. Textbook for Grades 8–9]. Riga, Zvaigzne. 223 p.
Khandorin, V. G. (2017). Natsional’naya ideya i admiral Kolchak [National Idea and Admiral Kolchak]. Moscow, Russkii fond sodeistviya obrazovaniyu i nauke. 624 p.
Khmіl’, І. V. (1994). Na shlyakhu vіdrodzhennya ukraїns’koї derzhavnostі. (Ukraїns’kii natsіonal’nii kongres-z’їzd 6–8 kvіtnya 1917 roku) [Towards a Revival of Ukrainian Statehood. (Ukrainian National Congress-Congress April 6–8, 1917)]. Kiev, Institut istorii Ukraїny Natsional’noi akademii nauk Ukraїny. 62 p.
Kolonitskii, B. I. (2017). “Tovarishch Kerenskii”: antimonarkhicheskaya revolyutsiya i formirovanie kul’ta “vozhdya naroda” (mart – iyun’ 1917 goda) [“Comrade Kerensky”: the anti-Monarchist Revolution and the Formation of the Cult of the “Leader of the People”]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 520 p.
Kontseptsiya novogo uchebno-metodicheskogo kompleksa po otechestvennoi istorii [The Concept of a New Teaching Module on National History]. In Gorodskoi metodicheskii tsentr [website]. URL: https://mosmetod.ru/files/metod/srednyaya_starshaya/istor/ Koncepcia_final.pdf (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Kovalevs’ka, O. (2013). Іkonografіya Іvana Mazepi v obrazotvorchomu mistetstvі XX – pochatku XXI st. [The Iconography of Ivan Mazepa in the Fine Arts of 20th – Early of 21st Centuries]. Kiev, Tempora. 420 p.
Kurlovičs, G., Tomašūns, A. (1999). Latvijas vēsture vidusskolai. 1. daļa. Eksperimentāla mācību grāmata. Rīga, Zvaigzne ABC. 255 lpp.
Kurlovičs, G., Tomašūns, A. (2002). Istoriya Latvii Dlya osnovnoi shkoly [History of Latvia. For Secondary School]. Riga, Zvaigzne ABC. 295 p.
Litvin, S. (2001). Sud іstorії: Simon Petlyura і petlyurіana [The Court of History: Simon Petliura and Petliurian]. Kiev, Vidavnitstvo imeni Oleni Teligi. 640 p.
Markevich, A., Harrison, M. (2013). Pervaya mirovaya voina, Grazhdanskaya voina i vosstanovlenie: natsional’nyi dokhod Rossii v 1913–1928 gg. [The Great War, the Civil War, and Recovery: Russia’s National Income, 1913 to 1928]. Moscow, Mysl’. 111 p.
Maslov, E. (Ed.). (2017). 1917 god. Petrograd. Moskva. Bogorodsk. Khronika sobytii [1917. Petrograd. Moscow. Bogorodsk. Chronicle of Events]. Chernogolovka, Bogorodskii pechatnik. 122 p.
Medushevskii, A. N. (2017). Politicheskaya istoriya russkoi revolyutsii: normy, instituty, formy sotsial’noi mobilizatsii v XX veke [The Political History of the Russian Revolution: Norms, Institutions, Forms of Social Mobilization in the 20st Century]. Moscow, St Petersburg, Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ. 656 p.
Mel’nikova, E. A. (2011). Ryad v Skazanii o prizvanii varyagov i ego evropeiskie i skandinavskie paralleli [A Contract in the Legend of the Calling of the Varangians and Its European and Scandinavian Parallels]. In Mel’nikova, E. A. Drevnyaya Rus’ i Skandinaviya. Izbrannye trudy. Moscow, Russkii fond sodeistviya obrazovaniyu i nauke, pp. 249–256.
Mel’nikova, E. A. (2017). Normannskaya problema [The Norman Problem]. In Drevnyaya Rus’ v srednevekovom mire. Entsiklopediya. Moscow, Ladomir, pp. 560–561.
Mel’nikova, E. A. (Ed.). Slavyane i skandinavy [The Slavs and Scandinavians]. Moscow, Progress. 416 p.
Mel’nikova, E. A., Petrukhin, V. Ya. (1989). Nazvanie “Rus’” v etnokul’turnoi istorii Drevnerusskogo gosudarstva [The Name Rus’ in Ethnic and Cultural History of the Early Russian State]. In Voprosy istorii. No. 8, pp. 24–38.
Mikhutina, I. V. (2007). Ukrainskii Brestskii mir. Put’ vykhoda Rossii iz Pervoi mirovoi voiny i anatomiya konflikta mezhdu Sovnarkomom RSFSR i pravitel’stvom Ukrainskoi Tsentral’noi rady [Ukrainian Brest Peace. Russia’s Way out of the First World War and the Anatomy of the Conflict between the Council of People’s Commissars of the RSFSR and the Government of the Ukrainian Central Rada]. Moscow, Evropa. 288 p.
Nevskaya, T. A., Kondrasheva, A. S. (2011). Vlast’ i reformy na Severnom Kavkaze (konets XVIII – nachalo XX vv.) [Power and Reforms in the North Caucasus (Late 18th – Early 20th Centuries)]. Stavropol’, Izdatel’stvo Severo-Kavkazskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 91 p.
Nikolaev, A. B. (Ed.). (2017). A. F. Kerenskii: pro et contra. Antologiya [A. F. Kerenskii: Pro et Contra. Anthology]. St Petersburg, Russkaya khristianskaya gumanitarnaya akademiya. 768 p.
Omurbekov, T. N., Chorotegin, T. K. (2005). Istoriya Kyrgyzstana (XIX v. – 1917 g.). Uchebnik dlya 8 kl. srednikh shkol [History of Kyrgyzstan (19th Century – 1917). 8th Grade Textbook for Secondary Schools]. Bishkek, Biiiktik. 192 p.
Pashuto, V. T., Florya, B. N., Khoroshkevich, A. L. (1982). Drevnerusskoe nasledie i istoricheskie sud’by vostochnogo slavyanstva [Old Russian Heritage and Historical Fate of the Eastern Slavs]. Moscow, Nauka. 264 p.
Pavlenko, S. (2005). Іvan Mazepa yak budіvnichii ukraїns’koї kul’turi [Ivan Mazepa as a Builder of Ukrainian Culture]. Kiev, Kiєvo-Mogilyans’ka akademіya. 304 p.
Pervaya mirovaya voina na pochtovykh otkrytkakh v 4 kn. [World War I on Postcards. 4 Books]. (2014). Kirov, Krepostnov’’. 1692 p.
Petrov, Yu. A., Pavlov, D. B. (2014). Pervaya mirovaya voina: kto vinovat? (Istoriograficheskii etyud) [World War I: Who is to Blame? (Historiographical Study)]. In Rossiiskaya istoriya. No. 5, pp. 3–13.
Petrov, Yu. A., Zhuravlev, S. V., Bakhturina, A. Yu. (2018). Prichiny, posledstviya i otsenka padeniya monarkhii v Rossii, Revolyutsii 1917 g., prikhoda k vlasti bol’shevikov i ikh pobedy v Grazhdanskoi voine [Causes, Consequences and Assessment of the Fall of the Monarchy in Russia, the Revolution of 1917, the Coming to Power of the Bolsheviks and their Victory in the Civil War.]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. Trudnye voprosy istorii Rossii. URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840001282-9-1/ (mode of access: 22.04.2020). DOI 10.18254/S207987840001282-9.
Prokopov, T. F. (Ed.). (2017). Revolyutsiya glazami sovremennikov [The Revolution through the Eyes of Contemporaries]. Moscow, AST. 480 p.
Rakhimov, Zh. (2001). Istoriya Uzbekistana (vtoraya polovina XIX v. – nachalo XX v.). Uchebnik dlya 9-go klassa [The History of Uzbekistan (Second Half of the 19th Century – Beginning of the 20th Century). Textbook for 9th Grade]. Tashkent, Uzbekiston. 334 p.
Revolyutsiya 1917 goda glazami sovremennikov v 3 t. [The Revolution of 1917 through the Eyes of Contemporaries. 3 Vols.]. (2017). Moscow, ROSSPEN. 1608 p.
Reznik, A. V. (Ed.). (2016). L. D. Trotskii: pro et contra. Antologiya [L. D. Trotsky: Pro et Contra. Anthology]. St Petersburg, Russkaya khristianskaya gumanitarnaya akademiya. 864 p.
Rossiiskaya gazeta – Nedelya. Kirgiziya. No. 6975. 19 maya 2016 [Russian Gazette – Week. Kyrgyzstan. No. 6975. May 19, 2016]. (2016). In Rossiiskaya gazeta [website]. URL: https://rg.ru/gazeta/nedelya-aziya/2016/05/19.html (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Rossiiskaya revolyutsiya 1917 g. i ee mesto v istorii XX veka [The Russian Revolution of 1917 and its Place in the History of the 20th century]. In Institut vseobshchei istorii Rossiiskoi akademii nauk [website]. URL: (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Rossiya – Bashkortostan: obshchnost’ istoricheskikh sudeb [Russia – Bashkortostan: A Community of Historical Destinies]. In Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriya” [website]. URL: https://history.jes.su/issue.2015.3.9.e5/ (mode of access: 20.12.2019).
Rossiya i Pervaya mirovaya voina: ekonomicheskie problemy, obshchestvennye nastroeniya, mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya [Russia and the First World War: Economic Problems, Public Sentiment, International Relations]. (2014). Moscow, Institut rossiiskoi istorii RAN. 416 p.
Rossiya i Ukraina na perekrestkakh istorii. Posobie dlya uchitelei istorii [Russia and Ukraine at the Crossroads of History. A Manual for History Teachers]. (2012). Moscow, OLMA Media Group. 320 p.
Rossiya v sisteme mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii nakanune i v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny v 3 t. [Russia in the System of International Relations on the Eve of and During the First World War. In 3 Vols.]. (2019). Moscow, Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. 1368 p.
Rybakov, B. A. (1982). Kievskaya Rus’ i russkie knyazhestva XII–XIII vv. [Kievan Rus and Russian Principalities of the 12th–13th Centuries]. Moscow, Nauka. 592 p.
Sakharov, A. N. (2003). Ryurik, varyagi i sud’by rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti [Rurik, the Vikings and the Fate of Russian Statehood]. In Sbornik Russkogo istoricheskogo obshchestva. No. 8 (156), pp. 9–17.
Shteinberg, I. Z. (2017). Nravstvennyi lik revolyutsii [The Moral Face of the Revolution]. Moscow, Kuchkovo pole. 416 p.
Shubin, A. V. (2017a). Velikaya rossiiskaya revolyutsiya. 10 voprosov [The Great Russian Revolution. 10 Questions]. Moscow, Istoriya. 46 p.
Shubin, A. V. (2017b). Start Strany Sovetov. Revolyutsiya. Oktyabr’ 1917 – mart 1918 [Start of the Country of Soviets. Revolution. October 1917 – March 1918.]. St Petersburg, Piter. 448 p.
Sitii, I. (Ed.). (2005). Mazepina kniga [Book of Mazepa]. Chernihiv, Tsentr naukovotekhnіchnoї і ekonomіchnoї іnformatsії. 524 p.
Skocpol, T. (2017). Gosudarstva i sotsial’nye revolyutsii: sravnitel’nyi analiz Frantsii, Rossii i Kitaya [States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Instituta Gaidara. 550 p.
Smolii, V. A. (Ed.). (2008). Istoriya Ukrainy: nauchno-populyarnye ocherki [History of Ukraine: General Audience Essays]. Moscow, OLMA Media Group. 1070 p.
Soldatenko, V. F. (1999). Ukraїns’ka revolyutsіya. Іstorichnii naris [The Ukrainian Revolution. A Historical Essay]. Kiev, Libid’. 976 p.
Somov, K. A. (2017). Dnevnik. 1917–1923 [Diary. 1917–1923]. Moscow, Dmitrii Sechin. 928 p.
Sorokin, A. K. (Ed.). (2017). Rossiya v 1917 godu. Entsiklopediya [Russia in 1917. Encyclopedia]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 1095 p.
Sovetskie natsii i natsional’naya politika v 1920–1950-e gody. Materialy VI Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, Kiev, 10–12 oktyabrya 2013 g. [Soviet Nations and National Politics in the 1920–1950s. Materials of the 6th International Scholary Conference, Kiev, October 10–12, 2013]. (2014). Moscow, Politicheskaya entsiklopediya, Fond “Prezidentskii tsentr B. N. El’tsina”. 686 p.
Stanislavs’kii, V. (Ed.). (2002). Listi Іvana Mazepi v 2 t. [Letters from Ivan Mazepa. 2 Vols.]. Kiev, Institut istorii Ukraїny Natsional’noi akademii nauk Ukraїny. Vol. 1. 1687–1691. 480 p. Vol. 2. 1691–1700. 752 p.
Strukevich, O. K. (2017). Istoriya Ukraïni: pidruchnik dlya 9 klasu zagal’noosvіtnіkh navchal’nikh zakladіv [History of Ukraine. 9th Grade Textbook for General Education Schools]. Kiev, Gramota. 240 p.
“Svet vo t’me…”. V bor’be za Rossiyu. 1917–1922 [“Light in the darkness…”. In the Fight for Russia. 1917–1922]. (2017). Moscow, Posev. 305 p.
Taїrova-Yakovleva, T. G. (2013). Іvan Mazepa і Rosіis’ka іmperіya. Іstorіya “zradi” [Ivan Mazepa and the Russian Empire. The Story of “Betrayal”]. Kiev, Klio. 403 p.
Torkunov, A. V., Chubar’yan, A. O. (Eds.). (2018). Rossiiskaya revolyutsiya 1917 goda i ee mesto v istorii XX veka [The Russian Revolution of 1917 and Its Place in the History of the 20th Century]. Moscow, Ves’ mir. 352 p.
Trotsky, L. D. (2017a). Istoriya russkoi revolyutsii. Oktyabr’skaya revolyutsiya [The History of the Russian Revolution. October Revolution]. Moscow, Veche. 416 p.
Trotsky, L. D. (2017b). Istoriya russkoi revolyutsii. Fevral’skaya revolyutsiya [The History of the Russian Revolution. February Revolution]. Moscow, Veche. 448 p.
Vlasov, V. S. (2016). Istoriya Ukraïni. Pidruchnik dlya 8-go klasu zagal’noosvіtnіkh navchal’nikh zakladіv [History of Ukraine. 8th Grade Textbook]. Kiev, Geneza. 256 p.
Voina i islam na Severnom Kavkaze XIX–XX vv. [War and Islam in the North Caucasus of the 19th – 20th Centuries]. (2000). Moscow, Institut rossiiskoi istorii RAN. 54 p.
Voina i obshchestvo v XX v. v 3 kn. [War and Society in the 20th Century. 3 Books]. (2008). Moscow, Nauka. Book 1. Voina i obshchestvo nakanune i v period Pervoi mirovoi voiny. 611 p.
Vosstanie 1916 goda v Turkestane: dokumental’nye svidetel’stva obshchei tragedii. Sbornik dokumentov i materialov [The Uprising of 1916 in Turkestan: Documentary Evidence of a General Tragedy. Collection of Documents and Materials]. (2016). Moscow, Mardzhani. 468 p.
Z epіstolyarnoї spadshchini get’mana Іvana Mazepi [From the Epistolary Heritage of Hetman Ivan Mazepa]. (1996). Kiev, Institut istorii Ukraїny Natsional’noi akademii nauk Ukraїny. 191 p.
Zimin, A. A. (1974). O metodike izucheniya drevnerusskogo letopisaniya [About the Methodology for Studying Old Russian Chronicles]. In Izvestiya Akademii nauk SSSR. Seriya Literatura i yazyk. Vol. 33. No. 5, pp. 454–464.
