The Tsar Must Die: The Thanatological Discourse of Male Rule in 18th-Century Russia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2019.4.427Keywords:
18th-century Russia; gynecocracy; thanatological discourse; Emperor Ivan Antonovich; Peter III; Paul I; Catherine IIAbstract
This article considers the reasons for the degradation of male principles of rule in 18th-century Russia with reference to official documents, memoirs, and literary texts (F. Prokopovich, M. Lomonosov, G. Derzhavin, A. T. Bolotov, Catherine II, Ch. Masson, G. L. Oberkirch, etc.). The author considers the formation of the ideology “the Tsar must die” in conditions of gynocratic rule and “Russian matriarchy”, which reached its climax in the era of Empress Catherine II. The author considers the main mechanisms of women’s reigns, which include the formation of a state mythology of classicism based on grand genres and discrediting their royal opponents by accusing them of insanity, betraying national interests, or childishness unforgivable in the Enlightenment. The article also analyses the causes of the thanatological discourse of male rule, based on the sacrificial complex of the male ruler voluntarily sacrificing himself to the interests of the Fatherland (the case of Peter I) or being sacrificed to such interests by female rulers, guided by the ideology of the Enlightenment and based on the broad support of their subjects (Ivan Antonovich, Peter III). In the case of Emperor Paul I, the author studies why he was an implacable opponent of gynocratic rule as such, realising in his behaviour the literary mythologemes of the Russian Don Quixote and Hamlet on the throne. The article concludes with an answer to why gynecocracy exhausted its potential at the turn of the 19th century.
References
Abramzon, T. E. (2006). Poeticheskie mifologii XVIII veka: Lomonosov, Sumarokov, Kheraskov, Derzhavin [Poetic Mythologies of the 18th Century: Lomonosov, Sumarokov, Kheraskov, Derzhavin]. Magnitogorsk, Magnitogorskii gosudarstvennyi universitet. 480 p.
Aksenov, V. (2005). Vol’ter’yantsy i vol’ter’yanki [Female and Male Followers of Voltaire]. Moscow, Izografus. 555 p.
Anisimov, E. V. (2008). Ivan IV Antonovich [Ivan IV Antonovich]. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya. 350 p.
Billington, J. H. (2001). Ikona i topor: opyt istolkovaniya istorii russkoi kul’tury [Icon and Ax: The Experience of Interpreting the History of Russian Culture]. Moscow, Rudomino. 880 p.
Bolotov, A. T. (1871). Zhizn’ i priklyucheniya A. Bolotova, pisanye im samim dlya svoikh potomkov v 4 t. [The Life and Adventures of A. Bolotov, Written by Him for His Descendants. 4 Vols.]. St Petersburg, Pechatnya V. Golovina. Vol. 2. 1738–1793. 1120 p.
Catherine II. (1989). Zapiski, nachatye 21 aprelya 1771 goda i prodolzhennye v 1791 god [Notes Begun on 21 April 1771 and Continued in 1791]. In Zapiski imperatritsy Ekateriny Vtoroi. Moscow, Orbita, pp. 1–194.
Catherine II. (2003). Memuary [Memoirs]. In Pamyatnik moemu samolyubiyu. Moscow, EKSMO, pp.171–541.
Derzhavin, G. R. (1860). Zapiski Gavriila Romanovicha Derzhavina 1743–1812 [Notes by Gavrila Romanovich Derzhavin. 1743–1812]. Moscow, published by Russkaya beseda. 502 p.
Diderot, D. (1947). Filosofskie, istoricheskie i drugie zapiski razlichnogo soderzhaniya (god 1773-i, s 5 oktyabrya po 3 dekabrya [Philosophical, Historical, and Other Notes of Various Contents (1773, from 5 October to 3 December)]. In Diderot, D. Sobranie sochinenii v 10 t. Moscow, OGIZ. Vol. 10, pp. 41–263.
Foucault, M. (2010). Istoriya bezumiya v klassicheskuyu epokhu [Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason]. Moscow, AST, AST Moskva. 698 p.
Geno, A., Tomich (Eds.). (2014). Pavel I. Sobranie anekdotov, otzyvov, kharakteristik ukazov i pr. [Paul I. A Collection of Anecdotes, Reviews, Characteristics of Decrees, etc.]. Moscow, Librokom. 306 p.
Graham, S. (1912). Undiscovered Russia. L., N. Y., John Lane Company. 332 p.
Huizinga, J. (1992). Homo ludens. V teni zavtrashnego dnya [Homo Ludens. In the Shadow of Tomorrow]. Moscow, Progress. 464 p.
Il’in, I. A. (1996). O vechno-zhenstvennom i vechno-muzhskom v russkoi dushe [About the Eternally Feminine and Eternally Masculine in the Russian Soul]. In Il’in, I. A. Sobranie sochinenii v 10 t. Moscow, Rarog. Vol. 6. Book 3, pp. 165–195.
Imperator Ioann Antonovich [Emperor Ivan Antonovich]. (1879). In Russkaya starina. Vol. 25, pp. 291–306. Vol. 26, pp. 493–514.
Ionov, I. N. (2000). Zhenshchiny i vlast’ v Rossii: istoriya i perspektiva [Women and Power in Russia: History and Perspective]. In Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’. No. 4, pp. 75–87.
Ivanov, O. A. (2008). Petr III. Zagadka smerti [Peter III. The Riddle of Death]. Moscow, Tsentropoligraf. 863 p.
Korf, M. A. (1993). Braunshveigskoe semeistvo [The Braunschweig Family]. Moscow, Prometei. 413 p.
Lomonosov, M. V. (1803). Polnoe sobranie sochinenii v 6 ch. [Complete Works. 6 Parts]. St Petersburg, Imperatorskaya Akademiya nauk. Part 1. 343 p.
Madariaga, I. de (1981). Russia in the Age of Catherine the Great. New Haven, Vale Univ. Press. 698 p.
Marrese, M. L. (2002). A Woman’s Kingdom: Noblewomen and the Control of Property in Russia, 1700–1861. Ithaca, L., Cornell Univ. Press. 296 p.
Masson, Ch. (1996). Sekretnye zapiski o Rossii, i v chastnosti o kontse tsarstvovaniya Yekateriny II i pravleniya Pavla [Secret Notes on Russia, and in Particular on the End of the Reign of Catherine II and the Reign of Paul]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 208 p.
Oberkirch, G. L. (1869). Rasskaz velikogo knyazya Pavla Petrovicha o videnii emu Petra I [The Story of the Grand Duke Pavel Petrovich about the Apparition of Peter I]. In Russkii arkhiv. Iss. 3, pp. 517–526.
Obstoyatel’nyi Vysochaishii Manifest o vozshestvii na Vserossiiskii Prestol Imperatritsy Ekateriny II. 1762 g., iyulya 6 [Comprehensive Highest Manifesto on the Ascension of Empress Catherine II to the All-Russia Throne. 6 July 1762]. (1763). In Ukazy Vsepresvetleishei, Derzhavneishei, Velikoi Gosudaryni Imperatritsy Ekateriny Alekseevny, sostoyavsheesya s blagopoluchneishego vstupleniya Ee Imperatorskogo Velichestva na Vserossiiskii Prestol, s 28 iyunya 1762 po 1763 god. Moscow, published by the Senate, pp. 14–23.
Panin, N. I. (1880). Vsepoddanneishee predstavlenie slabogo ponyatiya i mneniya o vospitanii Ego Imperatorskogo Velichestva Pavla Petrovicha [The Most Submissive Representation of a Weak Concept and Opinion on the Education of His Imperial Majesty Pavel Petrovich]. In Russkaya starina. Vol. 36, pp. 315–317.
Pis’ma i bumagi Petra Velikogo [Letters and Papers of Peter the Great]. (1950). Vol. 9. Iss. 1. Moscow, Leningrad, Akademiya nauk SSSR. 528 p.
Prokopovich, F. (1961). Sochineniya [Works]. Moscow, Leningrad, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. 502 p.
Proskurina, V. (2006). Mify imperii. Literatura i vlast’ v epokhu Ekateriny II [Myths of the Empire. Literature and Power in the Age of Catherine II]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 328 p.
Radzinskii, E. S. (2019). Bab‘e tsarstvo. Russkii paradoks [Women’s Tsardom. Russian Paradox]. Moscow, AST. 656 p.
Renault, M. (2013). The King Must Die. NY, Open Road Integrated Media. 354 p.
Sakharov, V. I. (2004). Russkoe masonstvo v portretakh [Russian Freemasonry in Portraits]. Moscow, AiF Print. 512 p.
So shpagoi i fakelom. 1725–1825. Dvortsovye perevoroty v Rossii [With a Sword and a Torch. 1725–1825. Palace Coups d’État in Russia]. (1991). Moscow, Sovremennik. 594 p.
Sumarokov, A. P. (1957). Izbrannye proizvedeniya [Selected Works]. Leningrad, Sovetskii pisatel’. 607 p.
Vacheva, A. I. (2015). Potomstvu Ekaterina II. Idei i narrativnye strategii v avtobiografii imperatritsy [To Future Generations from Catherine II. Ideas and Narrative Strategies in the Autobiography of the Empress]. Sofiya, Sv. Kliment Okhridski. 717 p.
Vacheva, А. (2017). Yeye Imperatorskogo velichestva Yekateriny II avtotsenzura [Her Imperial Majesty Catherine II Self-Censorship]. In Quaestio Rossica. Vol. 5. No 2. Pp. 436–452. DOI 10.15826/qr.2017.2.235.
Voltaire, F. M. A. de (1771–1772). Questions sur l’ encyclopédie, distribuées en forme de dictionnaire par des amateurs: in 9 vols. 2-de éd. Londres, S. n. Vol. 8. Loix – Russie. 306 p.
Vysochaishii Manifest o vstuplenii na Prestol Gosudaryni Imperatritsy Elizavety Petrovny, s obstoyatel’nym iz”yasneniem blizhaishego i preimushchestvennogo prava Eya Velichestva na Imperatorskuyu Koronu [The Highest Manifesto on the Accession to the Throne of Empress Elizabeth Petrovna, with a Detailed Explanation of Her Majesty’s Immediate and Primary Right to the Imperial Crown]. (1741). St Petersburg, published by the Senate. 3 p.
Vysochaishii Manifest o vstuplenii na Prestol Imperatritsy Ekateriny II. 1762 g., iyunya 28 [The Highest Manifesto on the Accession to the Throne of Empress Catherine II. 28 June 1762]. (1763). In Ukazy Vsepresvetleishei, Derzhavneishei, Velikoi Gosudaryni Imperatritsy Ekateriny Alekseevny, sostoyavshiesya s blagopoluchneishego vstupleniya Ee Imperatorskogo Velichestva na Vserossiiskii Prestol, s 28 iyunya 1762 po 1763 god. Napechatano po Vsevysochaishemu Ee Imperatorskogo Velichestva poveleniyu. Moscow, published by the Senate, pp. 3–4.
Wortman, R. S. (1995). Scenarios of Power. Myth and Ceremony in Russian Monarchy : in 2 Vols. Princeton, Princeton Univ. Press. Vol. 1. From Peter the Great to the Death of Nicholas I. 469 p.
