Lev Kamenev at Nestor Makhno’s (Huliaipole, May 1919): The Four Stages of a Narrative


  • Korine Amacher




This article is devoted to a meeting between the anarchist leader Makhno and the Bolshevik leaders Lev Kamenev and Kliment Voroshilov in early May 1919. This meeting took place in Ukraine, in Huliaipole, the headquarters of Makhno, as the civil war was raging. A detailed narration of Kamenev’s expedition was published in the Soviet journal Proletarskaya revolyutsiya in 1925. Written by a member of the Soviet delegation, it is the only remaining testimony of the expedition and the meeting. It is this text, written by a member of the Soviet delegation, that Russian historians use when referring to the Bolshevik expedition in Ukraine and the meeting between Kamenev and Makhno. Until now, historians did not know the identity of its author. But this article brings to light the identity of the “anonymous chronicler” of the expedition, who happens to be Vladimir Sokolin, a Russian who grew up in Geneva and joined the Tsarist army before converting to Bolshevism and becoming Kamenev’s secretary in November 1918. His archives are kept in Geneva and Moscow. Sokolin is the author of four texts about the expedition in which he participated. The texts were written at different times and in different political contexts: between 1919 and 1966 in the USSR and Switzerland. After recounting the story of the texts, this article analyses their differences. Even though they seem minor at first sight, the differences allow us to think about the way past events are transmitted by a witness, as well as the use that historians can make of such accounts.


AFB. Dos. E 4260-03/2005/268/30453 (Dossier Socoline-Welsh, Vladimir, 02.04.1896).

Amacher, K. (2012). Lev Kamenev, historien d’Alexandre Herzen: un intellectuel entre deux rives. In Revue des Etudes slaves. № 1 (83), рр. 185–206.

Antonov-Ovseenko, V. A. (1924–1933). Zapiski o grazhdanskoy voyne [Notes about the Civil War]. Moscow, Leningrad, Gosudarstvennoe voennoe izdatel’stvo. Т. 1–4. 271 + 298 + 350 + 343 p.

Archinov, P. (2010). Makhnovchtchina. L’insurrection révolutionnaire en Ukraine de 1918 à 1921. Paris, Spartacus. 256 p.

Aunoble, E. (2010). La figure de Nestor Makhno, ou les tribulations d’un héros révo- lutionnaire. In Amacher, K., Heller, L. (Eds). Le retour des héros. La reconstitution des ationales à l’heure du postcommunisme. Louvain-la-Neuve, Bruylant – Academia, рр. 35–51.

Belash, A. V., Belash, V. F. (1993). Dorogi Nestora Makhno [The Roads of Nestor Makhno]. Kiev, Proza. 592 p.

BGE. Ms.fr. 7929. Doss. 11. F. 1–17, « À propos de Makhno » (Papiers Vladimir So- coline, 19e –20e s.).

Bolshaya sovetskaya entsiklopediya [The Great Soviet Encyclopaedia]. (1938). Mos- cow, OGIZ, Т. 38. 832 stlb.

Danilov, V., Shanin, T. (Eds.). (2006). Nestor Makhno. Krest’yanskoe dvizhenie na Ukraine. 1918–1921. Dokumenty i materialy [The Peasant Movement in Ukraine. 1918– 1921. Documents and Materials]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 1000 p.

Gerasimenko, N. V. (1922–1924). Makhno. In Istorik i sovremennik : in 5 t. Berlin, Ol’ga D’yakova i Ko. T. 3. 304 p.

Gerasimenko, N. V. (1928). Bat’ko Makhno. Memuary belogvardeyca [Batko Makhno. Memoirs of a White Guard]. Moscow, Leningrad, GIZ. URL: http://www.rummuseum.ru/ portal/node/302 (mode of access: 08.07.2017).

Golovanov, V. Ya. (2008). Nestor Makhno. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya. URL: http:// www.e-reading.club/book.php?book=86841 (mode of access: 08.07.2017).

Halbwachs, M. (2011). Les Cadres sociaux de la mémoire. Paris, Albin Michel. 367 p.

Istoriya Vsesoyuznoy kommunisticheskoy partii (bolshevikov). Kratkiy kurs [The History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks). Short Course]. (1938). Moscow, GIPL. 351 p.

Kessel, J. (2001). Makhno et sa juive. Paris, Gallimard. 86 p.

Lenin, V. I. (1970). Polnoe sobranie sochineniy [A Complete Collection of Works]. Moscow, Izd. politicheskoy literatury. Т. 50. 623 p.

Marie, J.-J. (2015). Histoire de la guerre civile russe, 1917–1922. Paris, Tallandier. 432 p. Paoustovski, C. (1964). L’Histoire d’une vie. Une ère inconnue commence… Paris, Gallimard. T. III. 248 p.

Pil’nyak, B. A. (2003). Ledokhod. In Pil’nyak B. A. Sobranie sochineniy v shesti tomakh [Collected Works in Six Volumes]. Moscow, Terra – Kniznyi klub. Т. 2. P. 453–477.

RGASPI. Stock 323. List 1. Dos. 134.

Skirda, A. (1982). Nestor Makhno. Le Cosaque de l’Anarchie. La lutte pour les soviets libres en Ukraine 1917–1921. Paris, A. S. 476 p.

Socoline, V. (1949). Ciel et terre soviétiques. Neuchâtel, À la Baconnière. 275 p. Trotsky, L. (1967). Écrits militaires. 1. Comment la Révolution s’est armée. Paris, L’Herne. 999 p.

V. S. (1925). Ekspeditsiya L. B. Kameneva dlya prodvizheniya prodgruzov k Moskve v 1919 godu [The Expedition of L. B Kamenev for the Forwarding of Food to Moscow in 1919]. In Proletarskaya revolyuciya. No. 6 (41), рр. 116–154.

Veller, M. I. (2007). Makhno. Moscow, AST. 304 p.

Voline, V. (2010). La révolution inconnue. Livre Troisième: Les luttes pour la véritable Révolution sociale (1918–1921). Genève, Entremonde. 298 p.



How to Cite

Amacher, K. (2017). Lev Kamenev at Nestor Makhno’s (Huliaipole, May 1919): The Four Stages of a Narrative. Quaestio Rossica, 5(3), 738–756. https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2017.3.248



Problema voluminis