A book of love and devotion: a communist father’s image reconstruction in the daughter’s memoirs


  • Natalia Gramatchikova Institute of History and Archeology of the Ural Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences
  • Lidia Yenina Ural Federal University




The article is based on S. B. Navarskaya’s documentary story The Life of a Soviet Family between the 1930s and 1940s. Stalda Borisovna Navarskaya (1932–2013) calls her narrative a genealogy as it combines seven autobiographies (including her own one and that of her husband).This previously unstudied text came to being because of the writer’s need to tell her grandchildren and great-grandchildren about the hard and decent life of their ancestors and was published on the Calameo website shortly before the author of the genealogy deceased. The narration of S. B. Navarskaya, a famous Uralmash engineer and constructor, head of the constructor group for the designing and introduction of the Malyutka small-sized washing-machine only becomes possible and necessary at the time when the bitter lot of the family (exiles, arrests, deaths of starvation, etc.) may become public and perceived as other heroic texts.

The central figure of S. Navarskaya’s family and personal history is her father, Boris Stepanov, and the chapter about him is subtitled A Life of a Communist. The article considers an intertwining of a number of discourses that are part of the autobiographic narrative of her father: they are excerpts of her father’s diary and his poems chosen by Navarskaya, a number of documents of the epoch (letters, orders, statements, certificates, deeds, etc.), his daughter’s frank and sharp language representing her father as a real communist, an ideal father and husband, and also concealed and more often than not unconscious means enabling Navarskaya to keep an idealized image of her own father. Among them is the tabooed reflection of well-known historical events, the interiorization of her father’s view of events, etc. The article describes the cultural code of the text introduced into the family history and her daughter’s narrative by Navarskaya’s mother: the events are commented on by means of poetic quotations and contain allusions to literary works.

The author analyzes the combination of the writer’s father’s words about himself and people like him and the peculiarities of his transformation in the biographic narrative authored by his daughter. For Navarskaya the text about her father becomes one about herself too, and may be regarded as the work of an autobiographic memory that lasts as long as its owner’s life. The contrast of two types of narrative – that of a father about himself and that of his daughter about him - turn out to be a powerful deconstructing mechanism of the text that tells more than the author initially meant. The text is complete compositionally, as it opens with a pathetic overture for a grave mourning where the possibility of a catharsis is inherently opposed to loyalty and is thus rejected for the sake of the father’s memory as understood by the author of the genealogy.

Author Biographies

Natalia Gramatchikova, Institute of History and Archeology of the Ural Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences


Lidia Yenina, Ural Federal University



Adon′eva, S. B. Ritualnye ploshсhadki [Ritual Sites]. In Russkiy folklor v sovremennyh zapisyah. Available at: URL: http://www.folk.ru/Research/adonyeva_ritual_plostch.php?rubr=Research-articles (mode of access: 12.09.2015).
Baydin, V. I., Golikova, S. V., Dashkevich, L. A. & Nechaeva, M. Yu. (Eds.). (1995). Dnevnik svyashchennika [Diary of a Priest]. In Ural′skij istoricheskij vestnik, 2, pp. 114–143.
Bykova, S. I. (2014). Dnevniki 1930-h godov. Terra sovietica incognita [Diaries of the 1930s. Terra Sovietica Incognita]. In Istoriya v ego-dokumentah: Issledovaniya i istochniki (pp. 117–138). Ekaterinburg, AsPUr.
Chukovskaya, L. K. (2013). Zapiski ob Anne Akhmatovoy [Notes on Anna Akhmatova]. (Vols. 1–3). (Vol. 3. 1963–1966). 608 p, ill. P. 400. Moscow, Vremya.
Dashkevich, L., Larionova, M., Neklyudov, E., & Shalina, I. (2015). Povsednevnaya zhizn′ provincial′nogo imeniya: dnevnik slugi ural′skih pomeshhikov Golubcovy′h [Everyday Life of a Provincial Estate: A Diary of a Landlords Golubtsovy’s Servant]. In Quaestio Rossica, 1, pp. 255–274. Available at: URL: http://journals.urfu.ru/index.php/QR/article/view/090 (mode of access: 12.09.2015).
Erny′hova, O. D. (2003). Kazy′msky myatezh: Ob istorii Kazy′mskogo vosstaniya 1933–1934 gg. 160 p. Novosibirsk, Sibirsky hronograf.
Ginzburg, E. S. (1990). Krutoj marshrut: hronika vremen kul′ta lichnosti [A Steep Route: a Chronicle of the Times of Personality Cult]. Part 13: Tarakanishhe. 608 p. Moscow, Sovetskiy pisatel′. Available at: URL: https://www.litmir.co/br/?b=10188&p=158#section_99 (mode of access: 12.09.2015).
Golovnev, A. V. (1995). Govoryashhie kultury: tradicii samodijcev i ugrov [Talking Cultures: Traditions of the Samoyedic and Ugric Peoples]. 607 p. Ekaterinburg, UrO RAN.
Levitan, L. & Razumovskaya, L. (2001). Zapiski medsestry′ [A Nurse’s Notes]. Hadera.
Litovskaya, M. A. (2014). Zhanr dokumental′noj istorii sem′i kak ego-dokument: problema implicitnogo chitatelya [The Genre of Family Documentary History as an Ego-Document: The Issue of the Implicit Reader]. In Istoriya v e′go-dokumentah: Issledovaniya i istochniki (pp. 55–66). Ekaterinburg, AsPUr.
Navarskaya, S. B. Zhizn′ odnoj sovetskoj sem′i v 30-e i 40-e gody 20 veka. Rodoslovnaya odnoj vetvi semejstv Navarskih, Vajsov, Zaporozhcev. Dokumental′naya povest′. Available at: URL: http://ru.calameo.com/books/0022066590bc0d68273cc (mode of access: 12.09.2015).
Novikova, V. (2014). P′esa s ottochenny′mi kogotkami [A Play with Sharpened Claws]. In Novaya gazeta, 48, December 11. Ryazansky vy’pusk. Available at: URL: http://novgazrzn.ru/nomer11122014_48/1947.html (mode of access: 12.09.2015).
Novoselov, A. E. (2013). Pamyatnaya A. E. Novoselova : Dnevnik dmitrovskogo kupca [A Collection of A.E. Novoselov’s Memories: A Dmitrov Tradesman’s Diary]. 157 p. Moscow.
Osipova, B. I. (Ed.). (1997). Vospominaniya rabotnicy M. N. Koltakovoj “Kak ya prozhila zhizn′” [Workwoman M. N. Koltakova’s Memoirs How I Have Lived My Life]. Omsk.
Przhiborovskaya, G. A. (2008). Larisa Reisner [Larisa Reisner]. 496 p. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya.
Sandomirskaya, I. (2001). Kniga o Rodine. Opyt analiza diskursivnyh praktik [A Book about Motherland. An Analysis of Discursive Practices]. 286 p. Wien, Wiener Slawistischer Almanach.
Stepanov Boris Afrikanovich [Stepanov Boris Afrikanovich]. In Hanty-mansijskij avtonomny′j ogrug – Yugra. Edinyj oficialnyj sajt gosudarstvennykh organov. URL: http://www.arhivugra.admhmao.ru/wps/wcm/connect/Web+Content/hmao-departments/archive/world-war-archives/voina/memory/world-war-archives-vospominaniya-navarskoistaldy-borisovny-ob-ottze-stepanove-borise-afrikanoviche?presentationtemplate=Web+Content%2Fpt_print (mode of access: 12.09.2015).



How to Cite

Gramatchikova, N., & Yenina, L. (2015). A book of love and devotion: a communist father’s image reconstruction in the daughter’s memoirs. Quaestio Rossica, (4), 109–129. https://doi.org/10.15826/qr.2015.4.128



Vox redactoris